Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
The Attic
POLL Which is more ridiculous?
Page <<first <prev 16 of 24 next> last>>
Jun 2, 2017 04:16:41   #
Steven Seward Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
 
user47602 wrote:
yes... it was a war of ideology... American leadership never forgot Khrushchev's idle threat, "we will bury you!". We had to fight communism wherever it reared its ugly head, even if we had to support fascist dictators....


If you will notice, after we left, Vietnam survived the genocidal monsters in the end. LOL

Hello User, I just had to respond to this one because this is an extremely little known area of World History. I'm no expert, but I have read a little about it. After the North Vietnamese took over the country in 1975. the wheels of Communist secrecy went into high gear. All Western journalists were expelled from the country and virtually the only news about Vietnam came from escapees to the West. In the first few months after the fall of Saigon, while Westerners were still escaping, the Communists managed a rather orderly takeover to dispel the fear that there would be a "bloodbath." Many, if not most people still think it never happened to this today.

However, shortly after the expulsion of Westerners, the summary executions started and a couple million people were put into "re-education camps." Typical of insulated Communist Regimes, such as Russia and China, the killing took place on a local level, out of the public eye, completely invisible to the Western World. We were still sorting out what happened in the Russian Gulags 50 - 70 years after they were in operation. Historians keep raising the death toll from Chinese starvation and executions higher all the time, 50 years after the death of Chairman Mao.

Information about the internal workings of Vietnam after 1975 is very difficult to come by. Just try an internet search. I found a few links that talk about the number of killings. Many of the deaths were simply due to the deplorable conditions in "re-education camps." An estimated quarter-million died just trying to flee the country. In the past I have heard estimates from as little as 50,000 Vietnamese killed by their government, up to more than one million killed.

This writer puts the total death toll from Communists in Indochina after the fall of Vietnam at 7.5 million. That is separated into, Cambodia - 3-4 million, Vietnam - 2.5 million, and Laos - 1.5 million. Cambodia is the most well known of these Genocides (or Demicide - the killing by a government of its own people), because somebody made a movie about it, and because the Cambodian Communists were so meticulous about keeping good records.

http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/dickeymf/_Years_after_Fall_of_Saigon,_75_Million_Murdered.shtml

This article on Vietnamese executions is long so I will get right to the number. She estimates that 65,000 of the deaths were outright political executions, but she adds that this is probably a low estimate. http://jim.com/repression.htm

This last article from the U.K. Guardian is more anecdotal, written by a guy who was there during the Fall of Saigon, but relates stories that happened much later. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3063381/Saigon-Apocalypse-40-years-ago-week-COLIN-SMITH-witnessed-fall-Saigon-says-came-ways-horrifying-war-itself.html

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 04:27:56   #
user47602 Loc: ip 304.0.0.33.32
 
interesting information, thank you Steven... I did not know the whole story.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 04:41:26   #
Steven Seward Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
 
user47602 wrote:
interesting information, thank you Steven... I did not know the whole story.

I didn't know this either for many decades. Who knows what is actually going on inside of North Korea today? Wikipedia reports the deaths just from starvation alone are somewhere between 1/4 million to 3.5 million. We may not find out the real truth for years. It kind of makes our "news" reporting about someone's outrageous tweets seem trivial. I've heard you say before "First-World problems!"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Korean_famine

Reply
 
 
Jun 2, 2017 04:52:46   #
Steven Seward Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
 
Steven Seward wrote:
Hello User, I just had to respond to this one because this is an extremely little known area of World History. I'm no expert, but I have read a little about it. After the North Vietnamese took over the country in 1975. the wheels of Communist secrecy went into high gear. All Western journalists were expelled from the country and virtually the only news about Vietnam came from escapees to the West. In the first few months after the fall of Saigon, while Westerners were still escaping, the Communists managed a rather orderly takeover to dispel the fear that there would be a "bloodbath." Many, if not most people still think it never happened to this today.

However, shortly after the expulsion of Westerners, the summary executions started and a couple million people were put into "re-education camps." Typical of insulated Communist Regimes, such as Russia and China, the killing took place on a local level, out of the public eye, completely invisible to the Western World. We were still sorting out what happened in the Russian Gulags 50 - 70 years after they were in operation. Historians keep raising the death toll from Chinese starvation and executions higher all the time, 50 years after the death of Chairman Mao.

Information about the internal workings of Vietnam after 1975 is very difficult to come by. Just try an internet search. I found a few links that talk about the number of killings. Many of the deaths were simply due to the deplorable conditions in "re-education camps." An estimated quarter-million died just trying to flee the country. In the past I have heard estimates from as little as 50,000 Vietnamese killed by their government, up to more than one million killed.

This writer puts the total death toll from Communists in Indochina after the fall of Vietnam at 7.5 million. That is separated into, Cambodia - 3-4 million, Vietnam - 2.5 million, and Laos - 1.5 million. Cambodia is the most well known of these Genocides (or Demicide - the killing by a government of its own people), because somebody made a movie about it, and because the Cambodian Communists were so meticulous about keeping good records.

http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/dickeymf/_Years_after_Fall_of_Saigon,_75_Million_Murdered.shtml

This article on Vietnamese executions is long so I will get right to the number. She estimates that 65,000 of the deaths were outright political executions, but she adds that this is probably a low estimate. http://jim.com/repression.htm

This last article from the U.K. Guardian is more anecdotal, written by a guy who was there during the Fall of Saigon, but relates stories that happened much later. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3063381/Saigon-Apocalypse-40-years-ago-week-COLIN-SMITH-witnessed-fall-Saigon-says-came-ways-horrifying-war-itself.html
Hello User, I just had to respond to this one beca... (show quote)

For some reason, this link will not paste correctly. You need to copy the entire length including the part that does not come up in blue print.

http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/dickeymf/_Years_after_Fall_of_Saigon,_75_Million_Murdered.shtml

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 06:04:58   #
richosob Loc: Lambertville, MI
 
Twardlow wrote:
So, protests must conform to your conception of what is right and proper? Do you understand the concept of"protest?"

People were dying, and President Nixon comitted Treason in the Vietnam war, but you--You!--have the right of approval of what is a proper protest and what is inconvenient for a treasonous President.

Wow! You certainly take yourself rather seriously, do you not?


I take him much more seriously than the likes of people like you, just an angry old man who can't except defeat.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 09:34:37   #
hondo812 Loc: Massachusetts
 
phcaan wrote:
Thanks for the link


No problem. It's a great speech and he delivered it very well.

Unfortunately for Vietnam vets, he more or less framed his foreign policy in it and Johnson wanted to go further. I think we've all read where JFK was contemplating pulling out of southeast Asia. I guess we'll never know.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 09:36:39   #
hondo812 Loc: Massachusetts
 
Steven Seward wrote:
For some reason, this link will not paste correctly. You need to copy the entire length including the part that does not come up in blue print.

http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/dickeymf/_Years_after_Fall_of_Saigon,_75_Million_Murdered.shtml


http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/dickeymf/_Years_after_Fall_of_Saigon,_75_Million_Murdered.shtml

Looks like it works for me?

Reply
 
 
Jun 2, 2017 10:30:46   #
Twardlow Loc: Arkansas
 
richosob wrote:
I take him much more seriously than the likes of people like you, just an angry old man who can't except defeat.


I think you protect the 'angry old man who can accept defeat,' the one really showing anger, not me.

The entire nation has been 'accepting defeat' since 1945, right?

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 12:48:12   #
richosob Loc: Lambertville, MI
 
Twardlow wrote:
I think you protect the 'angry old man who can accept defeat,' the one really showing anger, not me.

The entire nation has been 'accepting defeat' since 1945, right?


I was really thinking of asswipes like yourself. I'll bet you type in front of a mirror so you can watch yourself and smile.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 13:21:27   #
Twardlow Loc: Arkansas
 
richosob wrote:
I was really thinking of asswipes like yourself. I'll bet you type in front of a mirror so you can watch yourself and smile.


You lack the aura of sophistication and civilization, with serious deficiencies of vocabulary.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 13:36:20   #
thom w Loc: San Jose, CA
 
btbg wrote:
Conservatives didn't have weekly protests saying not my president and blocking streets while occasionally throwing rocks through storefront windows. That would be liberals.

Conservatives have never done some of the things that we are currently watching progressives do. And you seem to not understand that Bush and Trump are not conservatives. They are moderates. Trump takes a lot of stances that are actually quite liberal, such as saying that their should be healthcare for all.

Obama ran for office saying that he would transform America and that is exactly what he did. Those of us who didn't like that transformation despised what was happening, but did not behave in the way that liberals currently are. Now we are hoping that some of what Obama did will be rolled back. The more the better. And liberals are saying that Trump is destroying the country. It's really bizarre.

You behave as if Bush is a warm criminal because he intervened in Iraq and now you are angry that Trump is threatening to not intervene if there is a problem in Europe. Be consistent. Either be in favor of American interference in the world or be against it. I didn't think that we should have gone into Iraq, but I also didn't think that we should have abandoned them once we did go in. I don't think that we should intervene in Europe's problems either, so I don't see what the problem is if Trump offends some European politicians. Obama placated them and our approval rating in Germany plummeted. Now you are concerned that Trump might hurt our standing in the world. Obama already did that.
Conservatives didn't have weekly protests saying n... (show quote)


Which of our allies were we backing up when we went into Iraq? As far as leaving, they made it pretty clear they didn't want us there.

Reply
 
 
Jun 2, 2017 13:48:58   #
thom w Loc: San Jose, CA
 
usnpilot wrote:
Keenan, have you ever posted other than in the Attic, I couldn't find any? I believe that makes you the number one troll on UHH.


Only posting in the attic makes on a troll? How so? I've read a few troll definitions, but I missed that one.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 13:56:12   #
thom w Loc: San Jose, CA
 
boberic wrote:
Pleeease gimme a break. N.Korea is out of control. Iran is building nukes. Islamics are blowing up innocent children. And people are obsessing over handshakes etc.? All this trivial nit picking by the left is actually funny considering what's really happening.


N Korea has never been in control. Where did you dig up "Iran is building nukes" from? Unfortunately lots of people are blowing up innocent children.

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 13:58:41   #
thom w Loc: San Jose, CA
 
Twardlow wrote:
Trump is a profound danger to our nation, and you want us to go to a movie while the nation flounders.

Interesting, but Jared would agree with you, wouldn't he?


Maybe not a movie, but he is a good reason to have a drink, or 2, or--

Reply
Jun 2, 2017 14:00:55   #
nakkh Loc: San Mateo, Ca
 
"Where did you dig up "Iran is building nukes" from?"

Breitbart news or worse.

thom w wrote:
N Korea has never been in control. Where did you dig up "Iran is building nukes" from? Unfortunately lots of people are blowing up innocent children.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 16 of 24 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
The Attic
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.