erinjay64 wrote:
You can get by with one long zoom lens (18-270mm, or such)...if you are shooting mainly snapshots which will be emailed, or printed at 3x5 inch, or 5x7 inch. If you want to print much larger, or you want to win photo contests, or sell to magazines, that won't be such a good lens. The more zoom power you have, the fuzzier your photos will be. You will get sharper images from a zoom which is 3X (three power), or less....where the top mm focal length is three times, or less, the smallest one. .
I gotta disagree. You should be able to buy quality glass whether the zoom ratio is 3:1 or 40:1. The way the lens is corrected throughout the zoom range determines how fresh and sharp the image is.
When a lens has more than a single element, the others are dedicated to correcting geometry, and other issues that crop up as you travel through the zoom range. Another problem I have seen, quite frankly even with pros, they just do not know how to use a zoom. For the absolute sharpest image, always zoom the lens completely in, focus, then zoom to frame your image. The hallmark of a quality lens is that it will track in-focus through the entire zoom range.
When you shop for zooms you often see statements like, "16 elements in 3 groups. 5:7:4". These groups of lenses have the job of maintaining smooth performance throughout the zoom travel. They contain field flatteners and other distortion corrections. With the exception of very wide angle shots (we see this played out with the widest fisheye, which has geometry and focus issues which exaggerate the problem) which can have zones of barrel distortion and focus issues in zone 3 of the photo.
The better it handles it and tracks, the better the glass, price notwithstanding. I usually take a test series for television. It gives me everything I need to evaluate objectively any glass against any other for geometry, sharpness, resolution, light management at all ranges of the zoom.
When shopping, you can create a simple spread sheet on your phone or tab to grade the zoom at each of the calibrated marks on the zoom ring to select the best value. Drives the guy in the polo shirt on the other side of the counter from me nuts. But I think since you can drop hundreds, thousands, more on a quality zoom lens you are entitled to pick the best one.
NB: Especially beware to test the lens carefully if you use an adapter of any sort to mount the lens. A bad t-type, or Oly OM - 4/3rds or whatever adapter can quickly screw up zoom performance as well. A zoom must fit flush and snug when properly mounted. ~Vlieg