Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
For Your Consideration
Gobinda Banerjee Lane School, Kolkata
Page <prev 2 of 2
Sep 15, 2016 22:08:47   #
ebrunner Loc: New Jersey Shore
 
Graham Smith wrote:
The charity supported school takes in poor children, many of them live on the streets, others come from very poor homes. The school helps to provide them with nutritious food and to cloth them. There is an overwhelming desire amongst them to receive an education, they know it is their only way, for themselves and their parents, out of the poverty they exist in.

The school is poorly equipped and the buildings are decrepit, all this is overcome by the dedication of the teaching staff. It is very humbling to visit places such as this, we have, in the western world, so much, they have so little, but my observation is that they are possibly, almost certainly, more "happy" than we are. They all want better for themselves but they are content with what they have, this might sound like a contradiction in terms but it is the only way that I can explain it. They are caring and sharing to each other to a fault.
The charity supported school takes in poor childre... (show quote)


I am a school teacher and these images are wonderful to me. You did manage to capture images that show hope and, in the last one, enthusiasm. These photos say a lot to me and I enjoyed them all very much. Glad you posted them.

Reply
Sep 17, 2016 18:52:26   #
jgordon Loc: Boulder CO
 
minniev wrote:
...There have been discussions, here and elsewhere, about the role of photography in addressing social and humanitarian issues. I don't want your thread drawn terribly off course, but I think the fact that these issues exist are part of what makes images like this valuable. Thanks for sharing them.


Graham, these are great images and they tell a very compelling story. They are among my favorites among UHH postings. Some of my other favs include examples of your black and white “decisive moment” type images. Many of those also tell stories about the nature of human responses to difficult or challenging circumstances.

I agree with Minni that photography can and (I think) should address social and humanitarian issues. It is true that many discussions on the UHH tend to be technical in nature (e.g., is the image “tack sharp” or is the depth of field adequate?). However, I disagree with the occasionally stated view that because of the technical nature of most discussions we should avoid posting images of homeless subjects of others facing adversity. There is another choice. We can expand the nature of our discussions.

I have noticed that this series of images has stimulated discussion about volunteering and helping others. That, in my view, is evidence that these are successful images. And that kind of discussion feels enormously more engaging to me than would any discussion of f-stops, equipment or leading lines.

In any event, I am moved by this set of images.

Reply
Sep 17, 2016 20:15:02   #
Uuglypher Loc: South Dakota (East River)
 
Graham Smith wrote:
The charity supported school takes in poor children, many of them live on the streets, others come from very poor homes. The school helps to provide them with nutritious food and to cloth them. There is an overwhelming desire amongst them to receive an education, they know it is their only way, for themselves and their parents, out of the poverty they exist in.

The school is poorly equipped and the buildings are decrepit, all this is overcome by the dedication of the teaching staff. It is very humbling to visit places such as this, we have, in the western world, so much, they have so little, but my observation is that they are possibly, almost certainly, more "happy" than we are. They all want better for themselves but they are content with what they have, this might sound like a contradiction in terms but it is the only way that I can explain it. They are caring and sharing to each other to a fault.
The charity supported school takes in poor childre... (show quote)


Graham,
Kudos for exceptional documentary photojournalism. ..and with your introductory comments very touching as well.
One can easily see why you plan to return.

Dave

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 2
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Check out Digital Artistry section of our forum.
For Your Consideration
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.