WF2B wrote:
Great photo, but I am pretty sure that it is an immature. In "Birds of New York State" by Budliger and Kennedy, they say that an adult has red eyes and that an immature has yellow eyes. Also, the adult has red horizontal bars on under parts while the immature has vertical brown streaking on breast and belly.
I've known Bob Budliger for a long time and trust his descriptions which are in greater detail than all of my other bird books.