grillmaster5062 wrote:
Any suggestions for an affordable, sturdy ballhead? At the moment, I am using an old Slik model, but it is getting pretty beat up. I will be using my Nikon N90, FM2, FA and Coolpix P900 cameras. I already have a Kirk Enterprises Quick Release and plates for each camera body.
If you want a heavy duty ball head, it's hard to beat the Smith Victor BH8 for about $60. It's rated up to about 40 lb. and is pretty decent.
They also offer a slightly smaller BH5X, rated for about 26 lb. and costing a couple $ more. The reason it costs more even though it's smaller is probably because it has a bubble level in the QR platform, which the BH8 doesn't have.
Now, I bought a BH8 to use on a backup tripod occasionally. Didn't want to spend as much as I did for the Kirk BH-1 that I use on my main tripod. Frankly I was pleasantly surprised how close the quality of the S-V ball head was to the Kirk!
The S-V BH8's panning movement was rather stiff when I got it. So, I took it apart (several Phillips screws on the base). I found they'd used really heavy grease in it. Being very careful not to lose any of the ball bearings or other parts, I cleaned that out and replaced it with a bit of heavy oil I had on hand (bicycle chain oil... about the thickness of honey). A lighter synthetic grease would probably work fine, too. Anyway, not it's got really nice, smooth panning action.
Another minor quirk... the Arca-Swiss compatible platform on the BH8 has a rather unique safety latch. It works fine with the "universal" A-S plate that's supplied with the ballhead, but won't work with some other brands of A-S camera and lens plates that I use on various cameras and lenses. However, it simply unscrews. No big deal... now my BH8 doesn't have that safety latch, but my Kirk BH-1 has never had one either, and it works fine.
Where the the Kirk ballhead has knurled metal control knobs that will last an eternity, the S-V head uses little rubber grips that will probably wear out in ten years or so. When that happens, I'll find something to replace them. Otherwise, it works and looks a lot like the Kirk or any other ball head. Not bad for $60.
The Smith-Victor ball heads are no doubt made in China and probably sold under a bunch of other brand names.
Note: Manfrotto (and Bogen) won't work for you... Their quick releases are not at all compatible with Arca-Swiss type lens and camera plates. Not even close.
I do have a smaller Manfrotto ball head on a monopod that's been modified and now has an Arca-Swiss compatible platform on it... But I had to buy the platform separately to replace the original one that was on the ball head. And that replacement QR platform cost around $50, so this wouldn't have been very economical if I hadn't already had the ball head left over from somewhere else. The replacement platform was from either Kirk or Wimberley... I forget which. And I made a point of using Locktite on it's threads so there's no risk of it accidentally loosening.