Ted Evans wrote:
Recently I purchased a new Canon 100-400
II (newest) and now have a desire to get
a gimbal head for birds and other wildlife.
When looking at what is available I am blown
away at the variation in prices - from less
than $100 to $1500 plus. I don't want to
buy cheap b/c it never satisfies. Nor am I
willing to pay for far more than what I need.
I want one strong enough to use with a
large 500-600 mm rental on occasion. So
please tell me what you are happy with or
what you'd buy if doing it again. Also please
recommend a vendor. Thanks a bunch!
Ted Evans
Recently I purchased a new Canon 100-400 br II (ne... (
show quote)
There are two major types of gimbal heads:
1. Full size gimbal head.
Do you want to dedicate a tripod to long-lens-use only? If so, probably the best value is the Nest that MT_Shooter sells (Google "Camera Cottage" ). That's a high quality, full size gimbal that will handle the largest lens you can throw at it (is probably overkill for a moderate sized 100-400) and cost around $300 US the last time I looked.
There are cheap $100 Chinese-knock-offs in this type, some other moderately priced ones (Jobu, Induro, both around $350 US), as well as very high-end that sell for $500 US and up (RRS, Kirk, Wimberley, etc.)
These full size type gimbals completely replace any standard head on your tripod and generally don't accommodate other regular uses of the tripod (such as directly mounting a camera with a shorter lens that doesn't have a tripod collar). To be able to use the tripod for other purposes, you'd usually need to swap the heads back and forth and that may require tools to do. (There are some adapters, such as the Wimbeley M-8, to allow partial use of the camera directly on the full size gimbal.)
In most cases, full size gimbals attach to the lens with the foot positioned underneath, sort of "cradling" it and giving the best support for the biggest lenses.
2. Gimbal adapter.
Or do you have a heavy duty ballhead on your tripod and want to be able to switch back and forth quickly so that a single tripod can serve multiple purposes?
If so, there are "gimbal adapters" such as the Wimberley Sidekick, Induro GHBA and Jobu BWG Micro, that are used in conjunction with a ballhead already on the tripod and are generally rated safe for use with lenses up to 500/4 (about 7 or 8 lbs), not really recommended for 400/2.8 and 600/4 (although I know folks who use them with those). The Sidekick sells for around $250, while the other two each sell for about $140 US.
To use one of these adapters, the ballhead on your tripod needs to be a heavy duty one... I'd say a 30 lb. rating min.... But I use full size, 50 lb. rated heads personally. The ballhead also must have an Arca-Swiss type quick release platform for the adapter to lock into. And it must have an independent panning axis. (Note: the gimbal adapter only serves for the tilt axis, while the ballhead provides panning... and
some ballheads use a single lock mechanism for all movements, which makes them unusable with a gimbal adapter.)
Gimbal adapters are "side mount", meaning that to attach them the lens' tripod mounting foot is rotated to one side or the other. There are a few side-mount full size gimbals, too... but they are less common.
One thing I've found useful with a side-mount gimbal adapter (Wimberley Sidekick) is that it also can be handy for vertical camera mounting, when using shorter lenses.... So I don't need an expensive, bulky "L-bracket" on any of my cameras. A smaller and simpler Arca-Swiss compatible camera plate will do.
To use either type of gimbal, the lens must have a tripod collar and you will need to install a longer, Arca-Swiss style quick release lens plate on it. This provides means of sliding the lens/camera assembly forward and backward a little to achieve best balance. A-S lens plates are available from a number of different sources and cost around $25 to $50 each. The better ones have some sort of anti-rotation feature.
If you go with the gimbal adapter and are using an A-S platform ballhead to accommodate it, you'll also need a camera plate in order to be able to mount the camera directly to the ballhead (i.e., with shorter lenses and without the gimbal adapter). There are "generics", but I recommend better, specially fitted ones that more solidly prevent accidental rotation and protect against loosening. Those "fitted" plates typically cost about $55 US apiece.