MarkintheHV wrote:
We are headed out to Southern Utah and North Rim of Grand canyon in a coupl e of weeks. Probably be in the Antelope Canyon area around 8/19. Is this a good time to grab one of the photography tours? Will the light still be good? Also, which lens would you use, Tokina 11-16 or Tamron 18-270?
Antelope Canyon is an interesting place for any photographer and well worth the visit anytime of year. In August, the sun angle will still be giving you pretty good light bouncing down the canyon walls. Truthfully, I, have not seen a time of year when you couldn't get some good shots.
As for tours, most (not all) but most are running to upper canyon. This is largely due to the way the canyons are configured. Upper canyon is an "A" type slot canyon, wider at the bottom than at the top. It is much easier to run a group of visitors through the upper canyon with its wider, flat, sandy floor. So, the upper canyon is a fairly constant stream of tourist groups. For the photography tours, guides will suggest shots, and hold back groups, and throw dust in the air so that you can get the typical cliche shots. Because of the volume of people coming through, even with the help of the guide holding back other groups for a few seconds, it is difficult to spend extended time setting up and perfecting a specific shot without other people getting in the way.
Lower canyon, on the other hand, is more of a "V" or straight sided slot canyon. At its narrowest part it can be a squeeze to get through. Trying to get a large group through is not easy, hence very few tour groups go to lower canyon. This is good because you have far fewer people coming through and can more easily setup shots without being interrupted. The first time I was there, I was asked if I had been there before. As I hadn't, a guide took my wife and me through. The young fellow gave good advice for photos. Since then, when I go to the canyon I tell them I have been there before, they give me a photographer pass, and I go into the canyon and shoot on my own. The pass is supposedly for 3-4 hours, but I have never had anyone enforce that if I shot half the day. Personally, I think lower canyon is the better of the two for the person wanting to try some serious photography.
As for lenses, take the one with the largest focal range. There are times you can use the widest angle possible, and other times when you want a much longer focal length to isolate details or interesting formations higher up the canyon walls. Your 18-270 should serve you well. Tripod is very helpful, and for many shots, necessary. Lower canyon, being more narrow and at places deeper, can be fairly low light. So, it's either use a tripod, or up your ISO substantially for taking handheld shots and probably get much more noise. Ideally, a tripod that allows you to swing legs out to 90 degrees is best, as you can use a leg against the side wall in some of the tighter spots. Also, because of the many odd angles you will be shooting at, if you have ever wondered about the usefulness of having an "L" bracket on your camera, this is the time that will convince you that they can be invaluable in some settings.
Enjoy the trip.