RJWagons Loc: Lake Ridge Virginia

I've had this same dilemma several times but have always regretted it if I just take a point and shoot. I've "compromised" by using a Canon DSLR t2i which is so much better than a point and shoot but not nearly the weight of my 6D and big lenses. No matter how good the point and shoot they lack the speed and versatility you're accustomed to with the DSLR. Good luck and have a wonderful trip.

marcomarks Loc: Ft. Myers, FL

Panasonic FZ-70 bridge model. $227 most everywhere with a 20-1200mm zoom lens. Notice that's 20mm wide angle which is wider than most that use 24mm and that's a big difference. Highly rated. Very versatile. One of the best stabilization systems. Shoots JPG or RAW. Shoot in any manual mode you want or use the iAuto which is superb. One piece with no extra lenses to carry. Has a viewfinder besides the LCD screen. Smaller than a dSLR. Weighs about a pound. The zoom retracts in to very short when it's shut off. Lose it or break it and you're only out a little bit of money. Security at the airport won't be twisting your lens off the camera because it doesn't come off.

LarryN Loc: Portland OR & Carbondale, CO

I would take the D70, one zoom lens, like a 24-105mm & a point & shoot. You might want to consider upgrading the p&s. For instance, Canon has a G16 on sale for $400. Even on "big deal" trips there always seems to be down time when I can use my DSLR to capture unique and/or intresting shots. And if you take two cameras you can always hand off the p&s to a buddy from time to time and then you will not be solely responsible for the trip photos.

cjc2 Loc: Hellertown PA

Interesting question, fairly simple answer. Sounds like a golf trip with a little sightseeing so I would take something lightweight that produced a decent quality file. I recently bought a referb Nikon 7800 and I like it. I would actually like it more if I read the manual and actually knew more about operating it. Although it has the same brand name as my D4s, it lacks a few features. Since you mentioned a Canon, you might want to look into the G15 (or whatever number they're up too). I have learned that there is much more that I don't know about this class of camera that what I do. If you have a real camera store near you, I would suggest heading there and letting the sales people help you decide. I do just that when people ask me for recommendations. To bad I don't take my own advice! There is just so much stuff out there at so many price points that it really is mind boggling. Best of luck, and have a great trip!

LarryN Loc: Portland OR & Carbondale, CO

BTW, I'm not suggesting that you take the D70 on the golf course. Your primary focus should be on golf not photos. I'm talking about "down time." For me, photography is important, so I always find time to get special shots, especially in a place like Scotland. If it is not so important to you then a p&s should be fine. Wish I was heading out on a golf trip to Scotland. Enjoy.

Toment Loc: FL, IL

Aw, take 'em both and be done with it! You'll be glad you did.

amfoto1 Loc: San Jose, Calif. USA

This depends completely on you!

If you mostly make snapshots to capture memories of your trip... if photography is sort of low in your priorities... take the point-n-shoot. Nothing wrong with that.

But if photography is high priority, say if one of the key reasons you travel in order to make great photos and plan to will be spending a lot of time taking shots, I'd suggest you take the DSLR, lenses, etc.

Rather than schlep a lot of gear through the airport, I sometimes ship things ahead to be waiting for me when I get there. What with airlines now charging a lot for baggage, there's not much or anything to be saved over the cost of shipping. Shipping might be safer for your stuff, too.

Karl Shuffler Loc: Weinert, Texas

Time for a small upgrade, meaning you can buy use. Results speaks for itself. For me; I got The Sony DSC-W300 some time ago and not for sale nor a need for a replacement, its that good. This small marvel includes optics of Carl Zeiss and to mention, a must have view finder. Having a sensor of 13.6 Mp is ideal for prints if desire of 8x10 easily. You can get one for less than $130 used off eBay. Great for portraits too. You be the judge. Taken of cruise ship in the Bahamas and a portrait.

(Download)


(Download)


(Download)

Great Choice

(Download)

CHOLLY Loc: THE FLORIDA PANHANDLE!

Buy a Sony A6000 and you will be EXTREMELY happy.

tjphxaz Loc: Phoenix, AZ

I have been to Scotland twice. Once with a group of 8 as you are doing and once by myself. With the group, I suggest just the point and shoot and take it to the course for some good photos of you and your friends, each clubhouse, the golf course scenery, etc. Presuming you have a driver and escorted tour you won't be able to do much sightseeing except what the tour wants you to and by the time you load and unload your bags and clubs several times a day you won't want to fool with camera gear.
I went back in 2013 by myself for 16 days and put 1,600 miles on the rental car. Took the DSLR and a couple of lenses. Played 14 rounds, took a couple of days off to rest the body and had plenty of time for photography and sightseeing either before or after a round of golf.
I envy you, you will have a wonderful time.