Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Mac/PC external drive compatibility
Dec 16, 2014 09:53:14   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
I will be away from my PC desktop computer/storage devices for a period of about 2 months during which time I expect to take a lot of photos. My plan is to store the photos on an external hard drive connected to my Mac Air travel computer, Upon returning home I'll transfer the photos from that external hard drive to my home PC for post processing in LR/PS. I've not tried this before, but understand that if an external drive is formatted to exFAT that it will be compatible with Mac and PC and this scenario will be possible. This is all new to me and I would appreciate any input/advice from anyone who has actual experience in doing this. I'll be dealing with a large number-probably several thousand-photos, so if there's a flaw in this approach I'd surely like to know.

Reply
Dec 16, 2014 10:12:05   #
Dngallagher Loc: Wilmington De.
 
windshoppe wrote:
I will be away from my PC desktop computer/storage devices for a period of about 2 months during which time I expect to take a lot of photos. My plan is to store the photos on an external hard drive connected to my Mac Air travel computer, Upon returning home I'll transfer the photos from that external hard drive to my home PC for post processing in LR/PS. I've not tried this before, but understand that if an external drive is formatted to exFAT that it will be compatible with Mac and PC and this scenario will be possible. This is all new to me and I would appreciate any input/advice from anyone who has actual experience in doing this. I'll be dealing with a large number-probably several thousand-photos, so if there's a flaw in this approach I'd surely like to know.
I will be away from my PC desktop computer/storage... (show quote)


Yes, just like USB Flash drives... I have several USB externals - if I format them for a Mac then a PC cannot use them, but format them as EXFAT and they are good for both...

http://lifehacker.com/5927185/use-the-exfat-file-system-and-never-format-your-external-drive-again

Reply
Dec 16, 2014 10:49:06   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
Thank you. I really needed that confirmation.

Reply
 
 
Dec 16, 2014 10:56:35   #
Dngallagher Loc: Wilmington De.
 
windshoppe wrote:
Thank you. I really needed that confirmation.


Most likely an external drive may come already formatted as exfat... should be easy enough to confirm before traveling and loading up with images.

Good trip!

Reply
Dec 16, 2014 11:00:02   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
Thanks again. I appreciate your help.

Reply
Dec 16, 2014 19:18:54   #
jethro779 Loc: Tucson, AZ
 
Dngallagher wrote:
Yes, just like USB Flash drives... I have several USB externals - if I format them for a Mac then a PC cannot use them, but format them as EXFAT and they are good for both...

http://lifehacker.com/5927185/use-the-exfat-file-system-and-never-format-your-external-drive-again


If he has lightroom on both computers and downloads his sd/cf cards directly into lightroom and on the external drive won't the drive be readable by either computer?

Reply
Dec 16, 2014 21:12:04   #
Dngallagher Loc: Wilmington De.
 
jethro779 wrote:
If he has lightroom on both computers and downloads his sd/cf cards directly into lightroom and on the external drive won't the drive be readable by either computer?


If the OS cannot read the drive, having Lightroom makes no difference....

A PC will have problems reading an external drive formatted as a MAC Journaled drive....but BOTH can read an external formatted as EXFAT. That was the answer to the original question.

Reply
 
 
Dec 17, 2014 04:45:57   #
blackest Loc: Ireland
 
http://www.paragon-software.com/products/home/

these guys have drivers for ntfs hfs+ and ext2/3/4 for Windows OSX and Linux also a conversion utility for converting an external drive between ntfs and hfs+
some are free or have trials $19.95 seems to be the going rate.


There are other free drivers available elsewhere too (google fuse and file system name and operating system).

The exFat format is pretty much universal but not security aware and has a maximum file size of 4GB (in most cases). If you need large file support that can be a problem.

However there is a free option share folders on your lan.
e.g a windows PC can share an ntfs formatted drive and a Mac a HFS+ formatted drive. The file system then becomes unimportant.

Finally consider a nas drive (network attached storage) basically a hard drive that can be attached as an external drive to a computer or attached to a network. A networked drive can be very useful if you need files available to several computers or even phones.

Some nas drives also double as print servers and will allow a printer to be connected to it.

so lots of options, a current mac should support ntfs out of the box anyway.

Why so many different file systems? Security, speed and robustness really.

Camera's tend to just support exFat but that could be handy if you partition an SDCard say ntfs and fat the camera will only see the fat partition the ntfs partition would be hidden which might be handy on casual inspection, putting the card in a pc and both partitions would show up.

Reply
Dec 17, 2014 06:24:57   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
blackest wrote:
http://www.paragon-software.com/products/home/

these guys have drivers for ntfs hfs+ and ext2/3/4 for Windows OSX and Linux also a conversion utility for converting an external drive between ntfs and hfs+
some are free or have trials $19.95 seems to be the going rate.


There are other free drivers available elsewhere too (google fuse and file system name and operating system).

The exFat format is pretty much universal but not security aware and has a maximum file size of 4GB (in most cases). If you need large file support that can be a problem.

However there is a free option share folders on your lan.
e.g a windows PC can share an ntfs formatted drive and a Mac a HFS+ formatted drive. The file system then becomes unimportant.

Finally consider a nas drive (network attached storage) basically a hard drive that can be attached as an external drive to a computer or attached to a network. A networked drive can be very useful if you need files available to several computers or even phones.

Some nas drives also double as print servers and will allow a printer to be connected to it.

so lots of options, a current mac should support ntfs out of the box anyway.

Why so many different file systems? Security, speed and robustness really.

Camera's tend to just support exFat but that could be handy if you partition an SDCard say ntfs and fat the camera will only see the fat partition the ntfs partition would be hidden which might be handy on casual inspection, putting the card in a pc and both partitions would show up.
http://www.paragon-software.com/products/home/ br ... (show quote)


Thank you.

Reply
Dec 18, 2014 11:40:48   #
Bob Boner
 
I always take at least 2 external drives and keep them in different places in case of some kind of disaster. Those images will probably be the only thing on your trip that are not replaceable.

Reply
Dec 18, 2014 12:00:51   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
Bob Boner wrote:
I always take at least 2 external drives and keep them in different places in case of some kind of disaster. Those images will probably be the only thing on your trip that are not replaceable.


Very true.

Reply
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.