Desert Gecko wrote:
Gene, mostly nightscapes and some landscapes and other (like macro) when I want to change camera settings without the camera moving even the slightest (some settings cannot be programmed into a bracketed series). I'm getting some good suggestions here so far.
Other than macro, your needs are pretty modest. Your biggest issue will not be external vibrations, though. I would look at trying to dampen shutter (not mirror) vibrations, which are the cause of blur on cameras that do not have electronic shutters. Even mirrorless cameras suffer from this. Lots has been written about how to settle down Sony's mirrorless cameras that do not have an electronic front curtain.
What is your budget? Keep in mind that a bargain seldom is when it comes to tripods. And a heavy, old-school tripod which was intended for shorter focal lengths and bigger, heavier cameras, was fine for a 4x5 with a 135mm lens on it, (a normal focal length equivalent to a 50 mm on a full frame camera). Also, a heavy bulky tripod is less likely to be used, because it is heavy and bulky. A few years ago I sold an aluminum Bogen (3051) with a 3 way pan head (3047) which I used successfully for many years, but it had an extendable center column, and it weighed about 15 lbs. Great in a studio environment, and ok to carry for a few feet, but not really that portable. And the center column took away stability. I had trouble stabilizing a 200 mm lens.
Replaced it with a 3.5 lb carbon fiber tripod, with a 37mm top tube diameter, which I routinely use with a 150 and 180 macro, and a 600mm with a 1.4x TC - with no issues. It is rock solid and stable. Oh, and it is not a Gitzo or a RRS - both of which are no compromise brands.
BTW, I owned a Gitzo series 3 carbon, for about a month - and was completely unhappy with it. It was a great tripod, but not stable enough for a 500mm lens. I thought the Gitzo literature was being overly conservative in their rating this pod for up to 300mm focal length. They were dead-on.
So to recap - tripod weight and load capacity are not criteria for tripod selection. Stability, which is usually indicated by the maximum tube diameter (top tube attached to the camera platform), is usually a better indicator.
Not knowing which camera, I would suggest Sirui, Three Legged Thing, Feisol 3442, possibly one of the Induros, but I am not familiar with their line, and Ghiottos, and for the sake of your back, carbon fiber. Try and get a pod without a center column.