Billbobboy42 wrote:
Jerry, is there a reference as to what the colors mean? I have a red 2TB internal drive that I use in an external dock (cheaper than buying a cased external drive). I always wondered what "red" meant.
The WD 'RED' drives are designed for use in a multi-drive RAID configured NAS. They have firmware mods designed to identify block write errors more quickly and lock out bad sectors before they can cause problems with RAID-5 reliability. They are also supposed to be more reliable when running 24/7 - - but who knows.
Here is an answer I posted in 2011 to the storage question:
*********************
Run - Don't Walk - to Amazon, ZipZoomFly, NewEgg, etc and buy a NAS (Network Attached Storage) box that will hold 4 HDD. Then get 4 of your favorite HDDs (2 - 4 TB each IF the box will handle drives that size - BE CAREFUL here - only a few will handle larger than 2TB drives), install them in the box, and configure them as RAID-5 !! Press the Format and Build 'buttons' and come back in 2 days. You will now have a drive array available on your home network (if you don't have one - you can connect via USB or eSATA) that will tolerate ANY SINGLE DRIVE FAILURE - - and I don't care WHOSE drives you're in love with - - sooner or later THEY ALL have a significant probability of failure - just a matter of time!
.
I would ALSO recommend powering your drive array with a UPS - so when the power glitches - your drive array is unaffected.
.
I have been impressed by the favorable comments regarding the QNAP TS-410 4-Bay Desktop Network Attached Storage - - although I am not sure if it will handle a 3TB drive - it WILL handle a 2TB drive. Installing 4 x 2TB drives will give me 6TB of fault tolerant storage. If a drive fails, I remove the dead one, replace it with a NEW drive, and the Array will REBUILD ITSELF, preserving ALL THE DATA!!
.
I will wait until I am certain I can install 3TB drives - and will use the above process to create 9TB of NAS.
.
OBTW: current price tag for the above 6TB array will run about $1K - $350 for the box and about $150 each for the drives. I'm hoping that drive prices will come back down out of the stratosphere once Japan recovers from the Tsunami / Flood / Earthquake and Godzilla.
***********************
What I actually did:
Got a QNAP TS-459 Pro-II (newer models have replaced now)
Installed 4 x 3TB Seagate drives in RAID-5
The NAS has undergone several firmware revisions, including the ability for me to securely hit it from anywhere on the internet. It can also serve up videos to my smart TV.
Last week, one of the seagate drives died.
I replaced it with a 4TB WD Red
As time and finances permit, I will replace the other 3, one at a time (the Rebuild takes 14 hours)
Once all 4 have been replaced, I will "EXPAND" the system and will have 12TB of RAID-5 storage instead of the 9 I now have. Remember - - with RAID-5, you use ONE drive worth of storage for backup - so FOUR x 4TB drive will produce 12TB of fault-tolerant storage space.