Bilal
Loc: Henderson, Nevada
I took this photo some time ago while in New York. I did some cropping and tweeking in photoshop. I'd like some feedback.
Hawk with catch
Ummmm, sorry I don't think HDR effect improves it. It would be better in the natural as taken. But, just my opinion.
Way over "tweeked"! Also, there's an outline around the subject that makes it look like a cut-out doll. Sorry, but that's the way I see it. Would like to see the original photo.
Regardless, somehow it catches my eye. Maybe the HDR type affect or something, just grabs me. Would like an 8x10 framed somewhere in the house.
Sarge
Not liking the effects, I prefer to see the natural look of nature.
Way over done......all the detail is lost in the processing
It looks like one of those plastic things at Walmart.
It is better the natural one rather than that!! you can't see the natural beauty of your picture..
It looks like it could be an outstanding picture but, it is way, way over processed.
mollymolly wrote:
It looks like it could be an outstanding picture but, it is way, way over processed.
I could not have said it better.
Bilal wrote:
I took this photo some time ago while in New York. I did some cropping and tweeking in photoshop. I'd like some feedback.
sometimes we get enveloped with "Mores Law" ( if a little is good MORE is better)
This would be a stunning shot as is, the processing , in my opinion, pushes this image way over the top.
If you took the original shot and tweeked just a tad, I think you would have had a stunning image.
rufus1
Loc: Winter Haven, Florida
Nope, overdone. Let's see the original.
I'm not a big fan, like to see the original or this pic a lil' less "done"
Hoss
Loc: Near Pittsburgh, Pa
I have to agree with the majority on this one. I feel it would look much better without all the PP!!!!
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.