therwol wrote:
It's a matter of taste, of course. Tchaikovsky and Rachmaninoff wrote emotional pieces. Beethoven is more intellectual. Tchaikovsky in particular wrote many memorable romantic melodies in his pieces. Rach 2 has at least two that I can think of that have been borrowed over and over. Rach 3 is more harsh than 2, and I have to be in a mood for it.
Beethoven's music is of the Classical period, while Tchaikovsky and Rachmaninff were in the Romantic style. In the 3rd, Rachmaninoff was probably trying to challenge himself as a performer.