Manzanar: A controversial part of our nation's history
Thank you for the post. We stopped there a few years ago and it was a profound experience. Not enough people who are traveling on Highway 395 up and down the East side of the Sierra Nevada take the time to stop and learn our history's details. Since our visit I've encouraged many people to make the visit - especially young people.
Another major internment center was at the other end of California, in the far North at Tulelake. Visiting there isn't as easy as at Manzanar, and the facilities aren't in the same condition, but it is possible.
Fascinating. Thank you for the pictures and story.
Very interesting. I remember reading about the internment camps as a boy. Glad to learn the facts. Also very interesting to see what the internees did to better their own situation. A lesson for many today.
Thanks for “the rest of the story.” I was very surprised to hear of the non interring states / areas.
DougS
Loc: Central Arkansas
Thank you for posting this very interesting story(s), and history lesson! There were two of those camps in my home state, which I have never visited... I have passed by one, but as you noted, there is nothing there except a small sign. Researching more information is most enlightening on the camps.
The snow covered mountains are certainly pretty! Thanks for sharing!!!
Very interesting. I get why the powers that were back then believed this was a good decision, but wish it had not happened. I wonder how many Japanese spies were actually interred. I did not know that a Japanese American could relocate to other states as presented here.
Well done story
Chuck
Mac
Loc: Pittsburgh, Philadelphia now Hernando Co. Fl.
OldCADuser wrote:
This past January, my wife and I met some friends in Lone Pine, California, located up in the Owens Valley region of the state. This was the first time I had been there and I took advantage of that to visit the Manzanar National Historic Site, dedicated to the memory of when it was one of 10 War Relocation Centers where individuals of Japanese ancestry were interned for the duration of World War II. In total, these camps were home to over 120,000 people.
Now this has special meaning for me as one of my first bosses after I graduated from engineering school was of Japanese decent. He was born in Los Angeles and his family ran a truck garden, supplying vegetables to local markets and restaurants. His parents were born in Japan, but Paul and his older brother, were born in LA.
Now Paul never talked much about what happen back then, but I knew a few things. I knew that he was in high school when the war started and that he and his family were forced to leave Los Angeles as part of the displacement of Japanese-American families. I also know that he eventually joined the Army and served in the 442nd Infantry Regiment, which consisted of mostly Americans of Japanese ancestry. This unit served in Europe and was the most decorated regiment in the army. Paul was wounded twice while fighting in France and Germany.
Because of this, I had always wanted to visit Manzanar as it's the only one of the 10 camps where the government has tried to preserve any of its history.
For the next few posts, I'm going to present some of the photos I took that day and at the end, I'm going to relate a bit more information about my old boss and what happened to his family.
This past January, my wife and I met some friends ... (
show quote)
Thank you for sharing this about a little acknowledged period in our history. Ansel Adams photographed Manzanar in 1943, and Dorothea Lange photographed internment camps also. Lange’s photos were impounded by the US Army and not released until 2006. I grew up in the 1950s and 60s, we were not taught about the internment camps in school. I did not learn about them until I was an adult.
Interesting, both the photos and the narrative. Thanks for posting.
Just Fred wrote:
I visited Manzanar and Lone Pine (where the fabulous Alabama Hills are) a couple of years ago.
Lone Pine also has a very nice museum, The Museum of Western Film History, dedicated to the film industry due to all of the many westerns and other movies filmed in the area. A large number of the 50's TV westerns were filmed in the are like the 'Lone Ranger', as well as several famous movies where a desert local was needed, like 'Bad Day at Black Rock' and 'Gunga Din'.
The Museum of Western Film History, which is housed in a old theater which still shows films on a regular basis - January 2023 - Sony a6500, 10-18mm
Some of the material on display in the museum - January 2023 - Sony a6500, 10-18mm
They had a well documented display of memorabilia honoring Audie Murphy, the most decorated American soldier in WWII, who later became a movie actor and who made many of his films in the Lone Pine area - January 2023 - Sony a6500, 10-18mm
Lone Pine is also where you can get a good view of Mount Whitney, the highest peak in the contiguous United States, at 14,505 feet.
Mount Whitney as seen from the Eastern Sierra Visitor Center in Lone Pine, California - January 2023 - Sony a6500, 18-135mm
OldCADuser wrote:
And here are photos of the only remaining structures on the site that have survived since the camp closed. As one would expect, due the harsh winter and summer conditions, the wooden buildings were all destroyed and removed years ago. Except for what you see below, virtually all of the buildings in the camp were constructed of wood.
Nice set and info.
OldCADuser
Thank you recording and describing an undertold piece of American history. Arigato.
There are many stories which cover the heroism of the 442nd Regimental Combat Team. However, very few cover the stories of the draft resisters or tell the stories of the 5000+ people who denounced their American citizenship or tell the individual stories of the more than 125,000 people who were sent to Camp.
Your Topic and Post are excellent. I would not attempt to judge the rights and wrongs of what was happening in the world 80 years ago - they were scary times in a world that was just starting to embrace technology as we know it.
There must have been enormous emotional problems for the Loyal-to-USA Japanese Americans - especially when the final curtain dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Very interesting and full of information. I was born in 1944, in London, and only came to live in the USA in 2010, although I had business interests in California and New Jersey from 1978.
go2hale
Loc: North of , Abilene, TEXAS
Thank you for this info ! I was in an area north of Boise Idaho that the US gave some of the interns some land when this was over. I went to school there back in the late 60's & early 70's and knew there were several Japanese kids & familys there. I was told of a little bit of the past & always admired them for how they preserved their heritage. Yes it was hard for them but I understand why it happened. Thank you again for the pictures & the story !
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.