Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
Electric Car Battery
Page <<first <prev 3 of 6 next> last>>
Sep 2, 2022 12:44:52   #
G. Crook Loc: Linden, TX
 
Of course, the truck and loader are electric, right?

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 12:45:43   #
Haenzel Loc: South Holland, The Netherlands
 
autofocus wrote:
here's another thing that's not often mentioned. A used EV nearing the end of life for it's battery has very little resale value. Often, the battery replacement costs more than the resale value of the car. In insurance terms, that means it's totaled! I just heard a sad story on the radio when the owner of an EV Ford called in with her tale of woe. Six months ago, or so, she said she purchased a clean used EV Ford for $11,000...not a bad price for a good used car in nice condition, especially nowadays. Six months later her battery died, so she got a quote from the Ford dealer for a replacement, and was shocked when she heard the price was going to be $14,000 dollars, not including labor! Unable to afford that, the car now sits. The dealer insulted her with a quote to buy the car for $500 dollars! And in my book, that's like the car was totaled!
here's another thing that's not often mentioned. ... (show quote)


Common practice is a factory warranty of 8 years or 100.000 miles on the battery. Even a secondhand EV can be bought with warranty on it's battery. It is pretty easy to determine the health of the battery by the dealer. A healthy battery won't just die overnight....Just make sure it's on paper before you buy...Also, as EV market share increases, more and more companies will refurbish used batteries by taking the bad cells out and install new or good used cells.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 13:01:40   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
lbrande wrote:
I have a 2006 BMW M5, and I haven't broken $7,500 in repair expenses to keep the vehicle running well.


Reply
 
 
Sep 2, 2022 13:12:17   #
edmixon Loc: Orange County CA
 
👍🥲

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 13:27:05   #
autofocus Loc: North Central Connecticut
 
Haenzel wrote:
Common practice is a factory warranty of 8 years or 100.000 miles on the battery. Even a secondhand EV can be bought with warranty on it's battery. It is pretty easy to determine the health of the battery by the dealer. A healthy battery won't just die overnight....Just make sure it's on paper before you buy...Also, as EV market share increases, more and more companies will refurbish used batteries by taking the bad cells out and install new or good used cells.


what you are saying is all true, and many EV batteries that have reached an unusable point for an EV application can still be used in "second life" applications with lessor demands, so they still have value. But in that case the car owner at that point is still faced with the potential replacement and labor costs associated with the replacement. I am sure many owners of EV's like the woman in question may not be aware of their options when their battery croaks. Also, what are the average costs of refurbishing a battery likely to be?? Is it still a major expense although somewhat lower than a new one? I have no information on that, do you? And, obviously, battery technology is changing with more power, smaller sizes, and lower costs being the goals. Will lithium batteries be obsoleted as old technology in the near term therefore making the refurbishing of those batteries a dying industry? So many questions.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 14:31:43   #
skylinefirepest Loc: Southern Pines, N.C.
 
Our government, aided strongly by our media, is pushing towards electric and there's a multitude of environmental, disposal, pricing, charging, off road, etc., etc. with the electrics. I simply won't take an electric to Moab or the Rubicon.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 14:39:22   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
lbrande wrote:
I have a 2006 BMW M5, and I haven't broken $7,500 in repair expenses to keep the vehicle running well.


I have a 2006 Mercedes E350 that I bought new, and so far, after 139,000 miles, I am on my fourth set of tires, only the second battery (!), still on my second set of Akebono pads, and the original rotors. I have changed the lower control arm joints, 1 tie rod end, the tensioner and serpentine belt and hoses (proactively), repaired one broken wire going to the trunk lid, replaced both HID bulbs, and that’s it except for oil/filter, transmission fluid/filter, coolant, brake fluid and a set of plugs. I am planning on changing the shocks for new Bilstiens this year. The car has been always garaged, driven only by me and looks and drives like the day it was bought. Maybe $2500 in routine maintenance, $3,000 on tires, and < $1,000 on other maintenance (I do jobs such as pads, belts, plugs and hoses myself). On the downside, the depreciation on Mercedes is brutal, but I plan to keep it ‘till I die, lacking an accident. Not trading it in for an EV any time soon.

Reply
 
 
Sep 2, 2022 15:25:05   #
plumbbob1
 
I'd love to have a silent electric pickup to run around the woods in. But, one reservation, if I got of range for the battery and no cellphone for a tow even if they could find me, my preferences would be
a plain ole pickup and a can of gas in the back.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 16:15:45   #
SteveFranz Loc: Durham, NC
 
I'm not driving a truck, but my 2013 Ford Escape had 99,000 miles right now. Never had any maintenance or repair issues. 25 MPG in town, 30+ Highway. And it only takes 5 minutes to fill the tank.

My first Ford Escape had 137,000 miles when I got rear ended by a Ford F150 and pushed into the car in front of me. I was able to drive home, not a single headlight or taillight was broken. The F150 had to be towed. The insurance company ended up totaling my Escape because it was about 6" shorter after the crash.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 16:43:03   #
Haenzel Loc: South Holland, The Netherlands
 
autofocus wrote:
what you are saying is all true, and many EV batteries that have reached an unusable point for an EV application can still be used in "second life" applications with lessor demands, so they still have value. But in that case the car owner at that point is still faced with the potential replacement and labor costs associated with the replacement. I am sure many owners of EV's like the woman in question may not be aware of their options when their battery croaks. Also, what are the average costs of refurbishing a battery likely to be?? Is it still a major expense although somewhat lower than a new one? I have no information on that, do you? And, obviously, battery technology is changing with more power, smaller sizes, and lower costs being the goals. Will lithium batteries be obsoleted as old technology in the near term therefore making the refurbishing of those batteries a dying industry? So many questions.
what you are saying is all true, and many EV batte... (show quote)


A refurbished battery is half the price of a new battery. The battery will have at least 80% of it's original capacity. These are figures I could find online.
The process of refurbishing is not really difficult. Make sure you have enough used cells to repair batteries. You can do it your self if you know how to work safely. So a dying industry? I don't think so. I think it will be a booming industry for many years to come.

In the end (10 years from now?) I expect hydrogen technology will take over, especially for long range vehicles and trucks / busses. For now I'm enjoying my smooth, quiet and above all, cheap short distance rides...

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 17:04:33   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
Haenzel wrote:
A refurbished battery is half the price of a new battery. The battery will have at least 80% of it's original capacity. These are figures I could find online.
The process of refurbishing is not really difficult. Make sure you have enough used cells to repair batteries. You can do it your self if you know how to work safely. So a dying industry? I don't think so. I think it will be a booming industry for many years to come.

In the end (10 years from now?) I expect hydrogen technology will take over, especially for long range vehicles and trucks / busses. For now I'm enjoying my smooth, quiet and above all, cheap short distance rides...
A refurbished battery is half the price of a new b... (show quote)


I think that assumes that only a few cells in a pack go bad, which may happen, but in the long run, all the cells will reach the end of their life, and then the entire pack needs to be replaced and disposed of.

Reply
 
 
Sep 2, 2022 17:08:04   #
Valenta Loc: Top of NZ
 
Definitely not time yet to buy an EV......

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 17:15:11   #
BebuLamar
 
StanMac wrote:
Don’t know about that Bebu. My Impala is about to hit 375,000 and I’ve replaced the battery half a dozen times. That IC engine just keeps running. I’m not sure EVs have a long enough in-service history for us to determine how reliable their moving parts are in the lonhaul.

Stan


they don't have that many moving parts. The electric motor has very few moving parts. Most EV has 1 speed transmission that is no shifting gear and no clutch. You can also use regenerated braking which don't make use of brake pads.

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 17:18:56   #
Haenzel Loc: South Holland, The Netherlands
 
TriX wrote:
I think that assumes that only a few cells in a pack go bad, which may happen, but in the long run, all the cells will reach the end of their life, and then the entire pack needs to be replaced and disposed of.


EV batteries, on average, only degrade at a rate of 2.3% of maximum capacity per year..
Tesla is not far from producing a million miles battery. Time will tell...

Reply
Sep 2, 2022 17:37:57   #
autofocus Loc: North Central Connecticut
 
Haenzel wrote:
A refurbished battery is half the price of a new battery. The battery will have at least 80% of it's original capacity. These are figures I could find online.
The process of refurbishing is not really difficult. Make sure you have enough used cells to repair batteries. You can do it your self if you know how to work safely. So a dying industry? I don't think so. I think it will be a booming industry for many years to come.

In the end (10 years from now?) I expect hydrogen technology will take over, especially for long range vehicles and trucks / busses. For now I'm enjoying my smooth, quiet and above all, cheap short distance rides...
A refurbished battery is half the price of a new b... (show quote)


Ok, so they're still pretty expensive if half the price of new. I saw a piece discussing a replacement on a Tesla, and it was going to be $22,000 dollars, half of that for a refurb is still a lot of money as would be the case for the Ford in my story at $7000 dollars. Now, let's look at that Ford story. She never mentioned the year of the used Ford that she paid $11,000 for, but if the battery died, let's assume it probably was around a 2011-2013 car, and $11,000 was a fair resale price when she purchased it. (not considering the state of the battery) Now, several months later she needs a battery and she does go with the refurbished one at $7000 dollars now making her total purchase price for the car with the battery refurb of $18,000, and probably more than what that car was worth. There's an old expression here in the US that might fit in that story, "....throwing good money after bad." I suppose it's the old Caveat emptor when purchasing any used car, but when a repair on one costs around 3/4's of what you paid for it many would say the buyer bought a lemon! Thanks for your comeback!

Reply
Page <<first <prev 3 of 6 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.