Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Lightroom When You Stop: Need Solution
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
Dec 23, 2021 08:00:16   #
jaymatt Loc: Alexandria, Indiana
 
I wouldn’t worry about it too much. I have had a similar situation with my brother’s work. His wife kept two or three prints she liked, his son took a couple, and I a few. That’s it; no one really cared about the other thousands of photos. He was doing his thing, and we do ours. I am pretty sure my photo "legacy” will go the same way. And that’s ok with me.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 08:09:15   #
jackpinoh Loc: Kettering, OH 45419
 
Select the 100 best and print them. You want to be remembered for the best you can do. You don't want to be remembered as a hoarder.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 08:39:08   #
Bayou
 
Your workflow to date has been incomplete.

For the existing processed and saved photos: Cull, cull, cull...and EXPORT into a meaningful (to whomever may find them) series of folders.

Future workflow: Cull, process, save, EXPORT into a meaningful series of folders.

There is no substitute for exporting. You have been skipping the most important step.

Reply
 
 
Dec 23, 2021 09:05:45   #
Festus Loc: North Dakota
 
Your photos are not actually in Lightroom. The "catalogue" you create in Lightroom only points to where you have our photos stored. They are your photos not Adobes or Lightrooms. You could delete Lightroom form your computer completely and still have accessories to your photos. (on your C drive or any other internal or external drive you have them stored on)

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 09:20:23   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
Once you have them exported (I’d suggest, high res JPEGs) and organized into folders with recognizable names such as relatives names, locations, events, etc., then archive a local copy onto MDisks (currently the most reliable archive media available) and place a second copy in a MAJOR cloud provider such as Amazon, Google, Microsoft or Apple. Make sure your children/heirs have the password, that the site is set to auto renew and your dependents have instructions to maintain the account. That’s the most robust archive solution available.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 09:24:20   #
gvarner Loc: Central Oregon Coast
 
Your edited photos will always be accessible without having to use an Adobe product. I don’t know about PSD files though.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 09:39:10   #
DirtFarmer Loc: Escaped from the NYC area, back to MA
 
gvarner wrote:
Your edited photos will always be accessible without having to use an Adobe product. I don’t know about PSD files though.


GIMP will open a PSD file with all the layers.
IrfanView (Windows only) will open a flattened image from a PSD.
ImageMagick can extract layers from a PSD or convert it to a jpg/png. You can convert all the layers to individual png files. ImageMagick is pretty powerful so I expect it can do other things as well but I haven't played with it.
I'm sure there are other programs which will open a PSD.

Reply
 
 
Dec 23, 2021 10:03:56   #
gvarner Loc: Central Oregon Coast
 
DirtFarmer wrote:
GIMP will open a PSD file with all the layers.
IrfanView (Windows only) will open a flattened image from a PSD.
ImageMagick can extract layers from a PSD or convert it to a jpg/png. You can convert all the layers to individual png files. ImageMagick is pretty powerful so I expect it can do other things as well but I haven't played with it.
I'm sure there are other programs which will open a PSD.


I figured someone would finesse the details but I didn’t think the OP was looking for that level of reply.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 10:04:33   #
thegrover Loc: Yorba Linda, CA
 
rleonetti wrote:
How do you leave your photos to your heirs, or even to yourself after you no longer can take photos?

With more than 15,000 photos in Lightroom, that have involved many year-hours of editing, what solution are there to leave them for the future? Adobe say when you stop your subscription the photos remain in their un-edited state, in the folders originally set up. (for many of us that is date folders by years).

A less than satisfactory solution, which would take lots of work, is to export all of them, perhaps to a new file structure along the lines of your "collections" (if every photo is in a collection) but even then you loose the ability to search on all text like key words etc.

Anyone with a solution along the lines of a search and read-only, non subscription solution for years of work?
How do you leave your photos to your heirs, or eve... (show quote)


Your photos are not in Lightroom. LR just knows were they are.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 10:05:47   #
gvarner Loc: Central Oregon Coast
 
thegrover wrote:
Your photos are not in Lightroom. LR just knows were they are.


👍👍

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 10:17:43   #
lreisner Loc: Union,NJ
 
jim quist wrote:
You can print some photo books for them. We are going thru my dads pictures and slides scanning them all. When we are finished we are going to select the best of them and print photo books for each of my brothers and myself.



Reply
 
 
Dec 23, 2021 12:26:58   #
bsprague Loc: Lacey, WA, USA
 
rleonetti wrote:
How do you leave your photos to your heirs, or even to yourself after you no longer can take photos?

With more than 15,000 photos in Lightroom, that have involved many year-hours of editing, what solution are there to leave them for the future? Adobe say when you stop your subscription the photos remain in their un-edited state, in the folders originally set up. (for many of us that is date folders by years).

A less than satisfactory solution, which would take lots of work, is to export all of them, perhaps to a new file structure along the lines of your "collections" (if every photo is in a collection) but even then you loose the ability to search on all text like key words etc.

Anyone with a solution along the lines of a search and read-only, non subscription solution for years of work?
How do you leave your photos to your heirs, or eve... (show quote)


Print the best, and only the best, then put them in a proper storage box. Your heirs will love discovering them when you croak. If you really think your heirs will have an interest in ALL your work, buy an external drive and export a complete set of JPEGs.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 12:29:42   #
bsprague Loc: Lacey, WA, USA
 
CHG_CANON wrote:
You should consult the Adobe documentation directly to confirm. My general understanding is:

1. Your LR catalog remains available for Library mode access and review of all images as well as ongoing Export module access of the current edit status of all your images.

2. The Develop model is disabled for any editing of images.

3. No new import processing into the LR library after you've suspended (cancelled) your Adobe subscription.

The points above disagree on several points within your original post. The exact details should be reviewed with Adobe or online 'experts' in the Adobe software.

Regarding leaving your images for prosperity, you definitely should be exporting your edited images into a proper organization. All your keywords are written into those export image files. If uploaded to a sharesite like Flickr and others, those keywords are brought along as hyperlinks within that target software / sharesite.

Personally, I would plan and execute a transition plan of my images. This would include all the following:

A. Export images at a minimum of 2048px on the long-side and / or the resolution of my family's widest HD TV, say 3840px for a 4K TV. Possibly export images at full-resolution or do both, 'share size' and full-resolution.

B. Descriptively rename all images during the Step-A export, such as a generic <YYYYMMDD-Topic-SeqNum> implemented via the LR export commands / formats. Example: 20101031-Halloween-0010.

C. Create an 'export' folder structure using YYYY high-level folders and YYYYMMDD-Topic subfolders.

D. Perform and confirm all the export actions (A-C) before notifying Adobe to disable the subscription.

E. Document, in writing such as email or MS Word, the locations and folder structure of my exported images. Include an explanation of Lightroom and all original images, folders. Explain (summary) the size and purpose of the export images, such as share-size vs full-resolution.

F. Transfer my exported images to a share site like Dropbox or physical media like CD / DVD, including the Step-E documentation file included in the transfer media.

G. Provide copies of the images and technical documentation to 1 to several (all?) family members, either via download links or copies of the physical CD / DVD media.

H. Assure my Power of Attorney / designated Executor of the Estate is knowledgeable of all my account numbers and sign-on credentials, including your personal Adobe software subscription, in the hope someone will want to restart the subscription. If password protected, include the basic sign-on credentials to start and access your primary workstation.

Optional:

D2: Run an additional export of all images as DNGs that allows for the transfer of the LR edit parameters into a target LR catalog. This may / may not be more useful than some taking over your LRCAT file and / or importing your LRCAT file into their own active LR catalog. Include explanation of where and why the DNGs are located on your workstation.

E2: Document your cameras and RAW file formats / original source files if a photographer in your family wants to take over these files. By putting these details in writing and storing the documentation along with export images, it may be eventually be a grandkid or in-law in the far future that receives, understands and utilizes this transition effort.
You should consult the Adobe documentation directl... (show quote)


"3. No new import processing into the LR library after you've suspended (cancelled) your Adobe subscription."

Paul, Import will still work. What won't work is only the entire Develop module, the Map module and mobile sync.

Reference the Lightroomqueen: https://www.lightroomqueen.com/cancel-cc-subscription-photos/

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 12:45:43   #
bsprague Loc: Lacey, WA, USA
 
I re-read the original from rleonetti. He writes that, " Adobe says when you stop your subscription the photos remain in their un-edited state, in the folders originally set up."

It is mostly true, especially for RAWs. The Library module will continue to work. So, if reonetti's heirs get his computer with password, Lightroom Classic will continue to read all his editing work stored in his Lightroom catalog. As the heirs scroll through the catalog, they will see his work as he left it. And, they can Export or Print anything that warms their hearts.

True story: My wife volunteered to make digital copies of 5000 Kodachromes her dad shot and put them on CDs for the family. Nobody ever got through them and nobody can even find the CD anymore.

Reply
Dec 23, 2021 13:18:52   #
ChrisKet Loc: Orange, CA
 
I’m bookmarking this page because of the excellent advice from Paul and DirtFarmer.

I have scanned photos, documents, and and digitized videos from my grandparents and parents; plus added 1000’s of my own. Fortunately, through the years I diligently tagged all of them with names, and have a filing system that contains dates and event names, so can easily find anyone in my current catalog.

I am finding now that my siblings (I’m the eldest of 10) and my children (5) are not real interested in what I have. Although, this Christmas I am giving each of my siblings a little photo book of “Christmas Eve Group Shots, 1956 through 2020”. The family continues to gather for Christmas Eve each year and the photos will now contain between 60 and 75 people.

I have found that several of my nieces and nephews really enjoy poking around the Portfolio site I set up to share my grandparents and parents photos. (Portfolio is an easy to use website creator that comes with your Lightroom annual fee. Giving up your annual subscription would most likely render this unusable as well, I haven’t checked.)

I’m planning to continue looking for potential interest from the next generation down to determine who I might pass this stuff on to. In the meantime, I’ll build and begin executing my plan, like Paul and DirtFarmer suggest.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.