One of the most photographed places in the Phoenix area. I'd thought I'd give it a try. I have to confess, that's a sky replacement.
Excellent! I like the foreground.
Very nice image. The replacement sky adds to the image
Beautifully shot and processed. You don't have to confess to anything. It's your picture to do with as you will. If you feel obligated to tell people you might replace a sky or remove/add something use a disclaimer like mine. Keep them guessing, it's none of their business anyway.
It's a fine image and the sky replacement fits the tone of the image. That is not always the case.
hjachym wrote:
Very nice image. The replacement sky adds to the image
I’ll offer a counter opinion. I feel this particular sky replacement dominates the scene, and takes attention away from the spectacular rock formation. FWIW.
pigskin wrote:
One of the most photographed places in the Phoenix area. I'd thought I'd give it a try. I have to confess, that's a sky replacement.
I think the composition is very good and the sky replacement, while not my thing, is not distracting to me.
The focus seems a little on the "soft" side would be my only critique.
Nice scenic--the new sky fits well.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.