Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
Wind farms--their long-run value?
Page <<first <prev 5 of 9 next> last>>
 
Note: posting politics outside of the Attic is against UHH rules. Users that bring politics into this discussion will have their accounts banned from replying in this topic. Repeated violations will lead to account suspension.
 
Nov 3, 2020 18:36:38   #
John Hicks Loc: Sible Hedinham North Essex England
 
Windmills for power it seems a waste of time to me firstly they are an eyesore if there is not any wind they don't work if there is to much wind they risk being damaged. In the coast here in England We have lots of windmills in the sea when there is not any wind they have a diesel engine in the last to rotate the blades this is because if the blades do not turn for a while you get a flat spot on the blade bearings and this will damage the bearings.
The best solution is wave power the university of Southampton which is on the south coast of England have built a small movable dam a boy two feet tall and it is strung across the estuary of the river Severn which has up to eight feet in difference of high and low tide and this barrier moves with the waves and produces electricity as it moves and as we know the ride is always moving also no expensive maintenance as the is with wind mills

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 18:52:46   #
robertjerl Loc: Corona, California
 
DarthMicrowave wrote:
As I understand, it's not proven - but the theory is that the earth continues to create fossil fuel on it's own...due to abiogenic hydrocarbon production (within the mantle?). There are several articles that entertain the thought that oil didn't originate from organic matter, but the theory has been around since the 1960s from what I can tell.

Article from 2015: https://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/we-are-not-running-out-of-oil-earth-produces-crude/

It references this study in Science: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/319/5863/604
As I understand, it's not proven - but the theory ... (show quote)


Yes, there are a lot of petroleum types who now believe that oil/petroleum and natural gas is chemically produced down deep and percolates up.
Coal of course is a different matter.

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 19:52:09   #
sodapop Loc: Bel Air, MD
 
tomad wrote:
What about renewable oils or synthetics? I seem to recall reading years ago that soy bean oil was being investigated as a possible replacement for fossil fuels and I also remember reading that it is already being used in diesel fuel. I use full synthetic oil only in my cars now and have been for years. I wonder if anyone is looking into creating synthetic fuel?


Synthetic fuel has been made from coal and other fossil fuels, Synthetic motor oil comes from petroleum.

Reply
 
 
Nov 3, 2020 19:56:34   #
JBruce Loc: Northern MN
 
StanMac wrote:
The biggest problem is that there are too many of us . . .

Stan


I agree 100%. But can you even imagine the uproar from all the invested parties if that idea were presented at a national level?

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 19:59:12   #
10MPlayer Loc: California
 
I worked for a small local utility company for nearly a decade and I have some understanding about how wind farms work. The utility puts out a bid for construction and manages the construction of the plant. It does all the electrical collection and hookup to the grid. In our case the company got a huge tax benefit from the federal government then promptly sold the entire wind farm and contracted to purchase the electricity back from the buyer. The object of the whole transaction was to comply with the state's mandate to have X percent of electricity coming from renewables AND to get the $4 million tax credit. Works out great for everyone excepting the people paying the tax and the people paying twice as much for electricity than they would if they had just built a new gas powered plant, which they had to do anyway to provide energy when the wind doesn't blow. It's all done with the best of intentions but the end result is it's a scam.

Have you seen the latest Michael Moore movie about renewables? I don't agree with the conclusions the movie comes to but Moore does a great job of pointing out how renewables aren't the answer to CO2. I think it's called "Planet of the Humans." Also, look into a guy name Michael Schellenberger if you're interested in the questions surrounding renewables. He's a former promoter of the climate scare and he's changed his views. Needless to say he's made a lot of enemies on the left. https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2020/6/29/on-behalf-of-environmentalists-i-apologize-for-the-climate-scare

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 20:54:03   #
scooter1 Loc: Yacolt, Wa.
 
jaymatt wrote:
A few days ago I posted some photos taken of some wind farm towers in northern Madison County in Indiana. There were some questions and musings in general about these farms, so I did a quick bit of online research which found the following information.

Each tower has a gearbox that contains 30 to 50 gallons of oil that must be changed at least yearly, usually more often. The life expectancy of a tower/field is 25 years. When the blades are replaced, the old ones are cut into three sections each and sent to a landfill for burial. Why they aren’t recycled, I don’t know.

Given the oil usage, the life expectancy, the supposed bird kill by the propellors, and the landfill problem, etc., many question their long-term value. Are they worth the problems that they cause? I am not sure; that’s for communities to decide.
A few days ago I posted some photos taken of some ... (show quote)


I read an article on the windmills and it seems the blades are made primarily of fiberglass and cannot be recycled.

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 20:54:16   #
Muddyvalley Loc: McMinnville, Oregon
 
repleo wrote:
I would rather have fiber composite blades buried in my local landfill than the remains of a nuclear power station. If you think wind turbines spoil your landscape, try to visualize it with a coal or oil fired generating station. Around here, most of the PV farms are located on closed landfills.
Wave energy converters (WECs) are an untapped source of renewable energy. These WECs can be located offshore either on the surface or below the water line and out of shipping lanes and fishing grounds. These generator fields would be close to where 50 % of the US population lives thus reducing the transmissions losses from remote generating stations.
I would rather have fiber composite blades buried ... (show quote)



Reply
 
 
Nov 3, 2020 20:55:14   #
scooter1 Loc: Yacolt, Wa.
 
10MPlayer wrote:
I worked for a small local utility company for nearly a decade and I have some understanding about how wind farms work. The utility puts out a bid for construction and manages the construction of the plant. It does all the electrical collection and hookup to the grid. In our case the company got a huge tax benefit from the federal government then promptly sold the entire wind farm and contracted to purchase the electricity back from the buyer. The object of the whole transaction was to comply with the state's mandate to have X percent of electricity coming from renewables AND to get the $4 million tax credit. Works out great for everyone excepting the people paying the tax and the people paying twice as much for electricity than they would if they had just built a new gas powered plant, which they had to do anyway to provide energy when the wind doesn't blow. It's all done with the best of intentions but the end result is it's a scam.

Have you seen the latest Michael Moore movie about renewables? I don't agree with the conclusions the movie comes to but Moore does a great job of pointing out how renewables aren't the answer to CO2. I think it's called "Planet of the Humans." Also, look into a guy name Michael Schellenberger if you're interested in the questions surrounding renewables. He's a former promoter of the climate scare and he's changed his views. Needless to say he's made a lot of enemies on the left. https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2020/6/29/on-behalf-of-environmentalists-i-apologize-for-the-climate-scare
I worked for a small local utility company for nea... (show quote)



Reply
Nov 3, 2020 21:09:10   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
John Hicks wrote:
Windmills for power it seems a waste of time to me firstly they are an eyesore if there is not any wind they don't work if there is to much wind they risk being damaged. In the coast here in England We have lots of windmills in the sea when there is not any wind they have a diesel engine in the last to rotate the blades this is because if the blades do not turn for a while you get a flat spot on the blade bearings and this will damage the bearings.
The best solution is wave power the university of Southampton which is on the south coast of England have built a small movable dam a boy two feet tall and it is strung across the estuary of the river Severn which has up to eight feet in difference of high and low tide and this barrier moves with the waves and produces electricity as it moves and as we know the ride is always moving also no expensive maintenance as the is with wind mills
Windmills for power it seems a waste of time to me... (show quote)


I was pretty impressed with the Rance project in France using wave power, which also had an 8’ tidal surge. It had a peak power >250 MW, but the average was 57 MW which according to the site was 0.12% of France’s energy demand - not a very impressive percentage (sadly): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rance_Tidal_Power_Station

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 22:23:13   #
krashdragon
 
I drive a big rig around the country... lots of solar farms.
My question is...
why are they all so low to the ground?
If the panels and supporting equipment were raised by possibly one foot, possibly more, there would be room, light and in many cases water available for growing many types of gourmet vegetables, speciality flowers, or grasses for grazing animals such as goats or sheep.
The panels protect the ground from too much sun, and water collects and then drips off anyway. The land could be rented out by whoever, and it seems to me everyone would benefit.
Pbly a pipe dream, but along with the question of tearing out forests and farmland, instead of recycling older areas that are all but deserted.
Ok, I think too much while I'm driving....

Reply
Nov 3, 2020 22:28:29   #
repleo Loc: Boston
 
krashdragon wrote:
I drive a big rig around the country... lots of solar farms.
My question is...
why are they all so low to the ground?
If the panels and supporting equipment were raised by possibly one foot, possibly more, there would be room, light and in many cases water available for growing many types of gourmet vegetables, speciality flowers, or grasses for grazing animals such as goats or sheep.
The panels protect the ground from too much sun, and water collects and then drips off anyway. The land could be rented out by whoever, and it seems to me everyone would benefit.
Pbly a pipe dream, but along with the question of tearing out forests and farmland, instead of recycling older areas that are all but deserted.
Ok, I think too much while I'm driving....
I drive a big rig around the country... lots of so... (show quote)



Reply
 
 
Nov 4, 2020 07:36:45   #
Bill_de Loc: US
 
krashdragon wrote:
I drive a big rig around the country... lots of solar farms.
My question is...
why are they all so low to the ground?
If the panels and supporting equipment were raised by possibly one foot, possibly more, there would be room, light and in many cases water available for growing many types of gourmet vegetables, speciality flowers, or grasses for grazing animals such as goats or sheep.
The panels protect the ground from too much sun, and water collects and then drips off anyway. The land could be rented out by whoever, and it seems to me everyone would benefit.
Pbly a pipe dream, but along with the question of tearing out forests and farmland, instead of recycling older areas that are all but deserted.
Ok, I think too much while I'm driving....
I drive a big rig around the country... lots of so... (show quote)


This might interest you.

FARMING UNDER SOLAR PANELS SAVES WATER AND CREATES ENERGY

https://www.futurity.org/agrivoltaics-farming-solar-panels-2152772/#:~:text=Farming%20crops%20under%20solar%20panels,of%20electricity%20production%2C%20researchers%20report.

---

Reply
Nov 4, 2020 11:28:37   #
clickety
 
Bill_de wrote:
This might interest you.

FARMING UNDER SOLAR PANELS SAVES WATER AND CREATES ENERGY

https://www.futurity.org/agrivoltaics-farming-solar-panels-2152772/#:~:text=Farming%20crops%20under%20solar%20panels,of%20electricity%20production%2C%20researchers%20report.

---


Irresponsibly misleading headline. That is not “farming”, it is “gardening”. Like many sustainable green ideas, it is not scalable to the size of feasibility.

Reply
Nov 4, 2020 11:51:08   #
Abo
 
StanMac wrote:
The biggest problem is that there are too many of us . . .

Stan


CORRECTAMUNDO!!!!!!!!!

Reply
Nov 4, 2020 12:49:15   #
Bill_de Loc: US
 
clickety wrote:
Irresponsibly misleading headline. That is not “farming”, it is “gardening”. Like many sustainable green ideas, it is not scalable to the size of feasibility.


Did you read the article or just look at the picture?

---

Reply
 
Note: posting politics outside of the Attic is against UHH rules. Users that bring politics into this discussion will have their accounts banned from replying in this topic. Repeated violations will lead to account suspension.
 
Page <<first <prev 5 of 9 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.