Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Camera for my Granddaughter
Page <<first <prev 3 of 3
Oct 3, 2020 15:22:45   #
amfoto1 Loc: San Jose, Calif. USA
 
Wags wrote:
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interest in photography, and I’m thinking about buying her a combined birthday/Christmas gift of a DSLR. I’m a Nikon user, D500, and she has used my D7200 backup several times and really seems to have a good eye for composition. I’m considering a D3500 kit from Amazon (Nikon USA), and it includes a number of accessories and a couple lenses. This camera records HD 1080 video, but I can’t find if it records audio. I have a chat request into Nikon, but have not heard back. Anyone D3500 users know the answer? Also, I’d be interested in thoughts about this purchase. Thank you.
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interes... (show quote)


You may not be aware, the Nikon D3000-series and D5000-series cameras are not compatible with some of the lenses that can be used on your D7200 and D500.

The D3500 will only be able to autofocus AF-S and AF-P lenses. There also may be some metering limitations with some other lenses that work fine on your camera.

More info about lens compatibility here:

https://www.nikonusa.com/Images/Learn-Explore/Photography-Techniques/2011/Which-Nikkor-is-Right-for-You/Media/NIKKOR-lens-compatibility-chart.pdf
https://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/compatibility-lens.htm
https://www.nikonians.org/reviews/nikon-slr-camera-and-lens-compatibility

So, depending what lenses you have, your granddaughter may not be able to share them with you.

Compare the D3500 to your D7200 (since you're familiar with it):

https://cameradecision.com/compare/Nikon-D3500-vs-Nikon-D7200
https://www.apotelyt.com/compare-camera/nikon-d3500-vs-nikon-d7200
https://www.imaging-resource.com/cameras/nikon/d7200/vs/nikon/d3500/

There are any number of online reviews of the D3500, which might answer your questions and more. These jumps to the conclusions and the pros and cons...

https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-d3500/6

https://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/nikon-d3500/nikon-d3500-conclusion.htm

This short review says it's "not so good for video", for people expecting a smartphone style experience...

https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikon-d3500-review

I am not video expert, by any means... D3500 appears to have a built-in microphone, so I'm pretty certain it can record audio along with a video. HOWEVER, a lot of videographers like to use an external microphone for better quality audio.... D3500 DOESN'T have a mic jack to allow use of an external mic.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 18:30:25   #
Wags Loc: Mequon, WI
 
amfoto1 wrote:
You may not be aware, the Nikon D3000-series and D5000-series cameras are not compatible with some of the lenses that can be used on your D7200 and D500.

The D3500 will only be able to autofocus AF-S and AF-P lenses. There also may be some metering limitations with some other lenses that work fine on your camera.

More info about lens compatibility here:

https://www.nikonusa.com/Images/Learn-Explore/Photography-Techniques/2011/Which-Nikkor-is-Right-for-You/Media/NIKKOR-lens-compatibility-chart.pdf
https://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/compatibility-lens.htm
https://www.nikonians.org/reviews/nikon-slr-camera-and-lens-compatibility

So, depending what lenses you have, your granddaughter may not be able to share them with you.

Compare the D3500 to your D7200 (since you're familiar with it):

https://cameradecision.com/compare/Nikon-D3500-vs-Nikon-D7200
https://www.apotelyt.com/compare-camera/nikon-d3500-vs-nikon-d7200
https://www.imaging-resource.com/cameras/nikon/d7200/vs/nikon/d3500/

There are any number of online reviews of the D3500, which might answer your questions and more. These jumps to the conclusions and the pros and cons...

https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-d3500/6

https://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/nikon-d3500/nikon-d3500-conclusion.htm

This short review says it's "not so good for video", for people expecting a smartphone style experience...

https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikon-d3500-review

I am not video expert, by any means... D3500 appears to have a built-in microphone, so I'm pretty certain it can record audio along with a video. HOWEVER, a lot of videographers like to use an external microphone for better quality audio.... D3500 DOESN'T have a mic jack to allow use of an external mic.
You may not be aware, the Nikon D3000-series and D... (show quote)


Thank you for this information; it’s very helpful.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 18:54:42   #
rangel28
 
Wags wrote:
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interest in photography, and I’m thinking about buying her a combined birthday/Christmas gift of a DSLR. I’m a Nikon user, D500, and she has used my D7200 backup several times and really seems to have a good eye for composition. I’m considering a D3500 kit from Amazon (Nikon USA), and it includes a number of accessories and a couple lenses. This camera records HD 1080 video, but I can’t find if it records audio. I have a chat request into Nikon, but have not heard back. Anyone D3500 users know the answer? Also, I’d be interested in thoughts about this purchase. Thank you.
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interes... (show quote)


I can also add another positive vote for the D3500. I had a chance to use and review one and can say I was very pleased with this camera, along with the 18mm-55mm AF-P kit lens. The camera and that lens are small and light, which may be good for your grandaughter as large cameras and lenses, would, I think, be a turnoff for people. The sensor is superior for both stills and video, and transferring photos to a cell phone is easy via the Snapbridge app. As you probably know there are numerous 70mm-300mm lenses on the market. If you do purchase that lens the AF-P DX version, with VR, is a very affordable and good choice. Overall I think this is a great "starter" camera.

Reply
 
 
Oct 3, 2020 19:17:15   #
Wags Loc: Mequon, WI
 
rangel28 wrote:
I can also add another positive vote for the D3500. I had a chance to use and review one and can say I was very pleased with this camera, along with the 18mm-55mm AF-P kit lens. The camera and that lens are small and light, which may be good for your grandaughter as large cameras and lenses, would, I think, be a turnoff for people. The sensor is superior for both stills and video, and transferring photos to a cell phone is easy via the Snapbridge app. As you probably know there are numerous 70mm-300mm lenses on the market. If you do purchase that lens the AF-P DX version, with VR, is a very affordable and good choice. Overall I think this is a great "starter" camera.
I can also add another positive vote for the D3500... (show quote)


Thank you. I appreciate your thoughts. I think I’m set on the D3500.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 22:25:27   #
dan59019 Loc: Washington Mi
 
Give her your camera - then get the one you want :)

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 22:28:52   #
SuperflyTNT Loc: Manassas VA
 
dpullum wrote:
Wags, your granddaughter is 13, which is 7th or 8th grade. Allow her to be in the peer-group and have a cellphone and be just like the rest in her class. Go to the school, PTA meeting, or call the school and ask several teachers what their opinion. Wags she is not you and she tries to please you when doing photography with you with DSLRs. Wags, your granddaughter is not you, she is a young girl that must fit her peer-group.

Put her on your account or just give a cellphone with no phone account. I taught for 3 years after retirement from industrial consulting/management. Kids love simple cellphone cameras. While people think the iPhone there are many other brands that are competitive. Android operating systems are more universal.

If she wants to do more serious photography the pocket cameras with 1" sensor are great.

You must buy her a camera that pleases her; not a camera that pleases you and the rest of the UHH people who say she must have ... "I love big bags weighing 40 pounds with great expensive glass, tripod, mono-pod bla bla bla. She is 13!! Can you say 13? When buying her shoes do not buy Wingtips!! like you wear.
Wags, your granddaughter is 13, which is 7th or 8t... (show quote)


I love how old geezers on here are such experts as to what 13 year olds want. The OP said she borrows his D7200 at times so she obviously is interested in using a DSLR and would probably love one if her own. Yes kids love taking photos with cell phones, but some actually are interested in learning the finer aspects of photography.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 22:29:12   #
Wags Loc: Mequon, WI
 
dan59019 wrote:
Give her your camera - then get the one you want :)


Thanks, Dan. The D500 is all I can handle!

Reply
 
 
Oct 3, 2020 22:38:42   #
SuperflyTNT Loc: Manassas VA
 
Wags wrote:
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interest in photography, and I’m thinking about buying her a combined birthday/Christmas gift of a DSLR. I’m a Nikon user, D500, and she has used my D7200 backup several times and really seems to have a good eye for composition. I’m considering a D3500 kit from Amazon (Nikon USA), and it includes a number of accessories and a couple lenses. This camera records HD 1080 video, but I can’t find if it records audio. I have a chat request into Nikon, but have not heard back. Anyone D3500 users know the answer? Also, I’d be interested in thoughts about this purchase. Thank you.
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interes... (show quote)


Go with your instinct. The D3500 kit will be great. It’ll be easier for her to handle than the D7200. Sure a used D7100 is nice but nobody wants to get their granddaughter a used gift. I also wouldn’t worry about it not having the focus motor. Unless she’s buying old lenses it’s not a problem.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 22:54:26   #
Wags Loc: Mequon, WI
 
SuperflyTNT wrote:
Go with your instinct. The D3500 kit will be great. It’ll be easier for her to handle than the D7200. Sure a used D7100 is nice but nobody wants to get their granddaughter a used gift. I also wouldn’t worry about it not having the focus motor. Unless she’s buying old lenses it’s not a problem.


Thanks. I agree.

Reply
Oct 3, 2020 23:41:44   #
ronpier Loc: Poland Ohio
 
Wags wrote:
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interest in photography, and I’m thinking about buying her a combined birthday/Christmas gift of a DSLR. I’m a Nikon user, D500, and she has used my D7200 backup several times and really seems to have a good eye for composition. I’m considering a D3500 kit from Amazon (Nikon USA), and it includes a number of accessories and a couple lenses. This camera records HD 1080 video, but I can’t find if it records audio. I have a chat request into Nikon, but have not heard back. Anyone D3500 users know the answer? Also, I’d be interested in thoughts about this purchase. Thank you.
My granddaughter (13) has shown some real interes... (show quote)


The D3500 is a great camera, 24mp sensor, expeed 4 processor. 5 fps. Same sensor and processor as the D 7200. I have owned the D3400 for three years. Love its size, weight and great images. She will be able to use all of the Nikkor AF-P and AF-S lenses along with 3rd party. That’s a lot of lenses. I have five myself that all auto focus on these cameras. BTW: Very easy to learn and use.



Reply
Oct 4, 2020 10:42:07   #
frankraney Loc: Clovis, Ca.
 
dpullum wrote:
Wags, your granddaughter is 13, which is 7th or 8th grade. Allow her to be in the peer-group and have a cellphone and be just like the rest in her class. Go to the school, PTA meeting, or call the school and ask several teachers what their opinion. Wags she is not you and she tries to please you when doing photography with you with DSLRs. Wags, your granddaughter is not you, she is a young girl that must fit her peer-group.

Put her on your account or just give a cellphone with no phone account. I taught for 3 years after retirement from industrial consulting/management. Kids love simple cellphone cameras. While people think the iPhone there are many other brands that are competitive. Android operating systems are more universal.

If she wants to do more serious photography the pocket cameras with 1" sensor are great.

You must buy her a camera that pleases her; not a camera that pleases you and the rest of the UHH people who say she must have ... "I love big bags weighing 40 pounds with great expensive glass, tripod, mono-pod bla bla bla. She is 13!! Can you say 13? When buying her shoes do not buy Wingtips!! like you wear.
Wags, your granddaughter is 13, which is 7th or 8t... (show quote)


Wow!!! How will you know this girl you have never met! And you were a reacher?

You have not learned that people are individuals with different likes, dislikes, desires etc. and even different mentalities at different ages.

I have posted several times that my granddaughter got interested in photography at an earlier age than 13, and is still in it as a pro.

Instead of being so NEGATIVE and discouraging, you should be encouraging. If she loses interest do be it. It will not take away from peer association but instead may make it better.

Reply
 
 
Oct 4, 2020 10:48:06   #
Hip Coyote
 
If you buy a child a Nikon, you risk emotionally injuring them for life. Go with a Canon. All joking aside, I like the idea of staying in the same system you have (Nikon) so you can share lenses, talk the same talk on menus, grandpa can help with more expertise, etc. Get different system from what you use, you are at a disadvantage and are missing some of the important interaction with the child. In this case, go with a Nikon that can use your lenses. Enjoy.

Reply
Oct 4, 2020 18:53:53   #
Hip Coyote
 
If you buy a child a Nikon, you risk emotionally injuring them for life. Go with a Canon. All joking aside, I like the idea of staying in the same system you have (Nikon) so you can share lenses, talk the same talk on menus, grandpa can help with more expertise, etc. Get different system from what you use, you are at a disadvantage and are missing some of the important interaction with the child. In this case, go with a Nikon that can use your lenses. Enjoy.

Reply
Oct 4, 2020 19:02:50   #
Wags Loc: Mequon, WI
 
RWebb76 wrote:
If you buy a child a Nikon, you risk emotionally injuring them for life. Go with a Canon. All joking aside, I like the idea of staying in the same system you have (Nikon) so you can share lenses, talk the same talk on menus, grandpa can help with more expertise, etc. Get different system from what you use, you are at a disadvantage and are missing some of the important interaction with the child. In this case, go with a Nikon that can use your lenses. Enjoy.


Thanks, I agree with you. I will be able to help her more with the Nikon.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 3 of 3
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.