sabfish wrote:
A relative send me a box full of very old (75-90 years old) and very badly curled black & white photos. Many of them are very small (4x3 and smaller). Does anyone have a good suggestion how to flatten them?
If you consider why photographs curl over time, it will help you remember why it is important to proceed gently, carefully, and with great caution when seeking to straighten them. It it also why it is important to follow Ed's direction and to be prepared for unexpected and damaging results as you proceed.
Any material that warps or curls does so because one side, for some reason, gets ever so slightly larger than the other side. If that expansion is uniform (or somewhat uniform), the material will "cup." If it is greater in one direction than the other, then the material will curl, or "roll," as the photographs in your photograph have done. This happens because paper has "grain," caused by the fibers aligning with each other as the raw materials pass through the paper-making process. That alignment is generally along the direction of the movement of the material through the process. This grain is why paper will almost tear more evenly in one direction than the other (most easily demonstrated with newsprint).
Anyway, over time, paper absorbs moisture and expands. There is more strength along the grain than across it, so the paper expands significantly across the grain, but very little along it. "Cured" photographic emulsion is a more plastic-like material and does not expand. The result is that the paper rolls up around the its long dimension. (In most cases, paper grain is intentionally aligned with the long dimension of the paper. Grain dimension is usually communicated by the dimension that is printed last on the labeling.)
The expansion that causes this rolling is generally permanent...you can't shrink the paper back to its original size. So that leaves two choices. Either you can find a way to "squeeze" the paper back to its original dimension (it will be an elastic process) or you can try to ever so slightly stretch the emulsion to allow the photograph to lie more flat. By the way, this is one of the primary reasons that proper archival presentation and storage of photographs is so important. The process of dry mounting seals the back of the photograph from moisture (the emulsion mostly seals it from the front) which mostly stabilizes the dimensionality of the paper substrate. Storage in a cool, dry place is a secondary way to reduce problems. And no, resin coated (RC) paper is not the archivel answer. There is a whole list of reasons why RC prints are not archival.
So in summary, understand what is going on, follow Ed's direction, and know that recovery is sort of a last-ditch recovery effort. It may or may not work. There are no guarantees.
Good luck as you proceed.