Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Best Flatbed Scanner for Mac
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
May 2, 2020 12:38:41   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
jsktb wrote:
After some research I settled on the Epson Perfection V600. My needs are to digitize 35mm and 2-1/4 slides covering 60 years along with B&W and color photos. I received the scanner on April 27th from B&H Photo. I am using the Epson Scan 2 software that I downloaded from the Epson website to use on my Mac Mini that is running Mojave. There are no problems and I am extremely happy with my decision and the results that I am getting.

The holder allows four 35mm slides at one time. The only annoyance is that I have to remove the film from the cardboard frame of 2-1/4 slides to fit that holder. It is time consuming. Does anyone have any suggestions for a better way?

The price was $219.
After some research I settled on the Epson Perfect... (show quote)


The price is still $219 for the V600, at Best Buy, Staples and Adorama.

I don’t have any 2-1/4 slides but a lot of negatives, as well as 120 size.

Reply
May 2, 2020 13:06:32   #
burkphoto Loc: High Point, NC
 
kb6kgx wrote:
First, I did search for this topic and did not see anything helpful so I'm asking now.

I used to have a Canon Canoscan 4400F which I used for scanning prints and slides, but after it "died" and Canon said they no longer supported this model, I have been looking for a replacement.

The two scanners that come up most often with the highest recommendations are the Epson Perfection V550 and V600. However, some of the user comments I have seen of these is that they are not necessarily incompatible with Mac computers -- they do work -- but that they do not come with Mac software and you have to find and download it yourself.

So, my question to the group is would any of you concur that either of these two scanners would be the way to go for me or should I look at other scanners? My requirements are that it must be at least 2400 DPI (4800 DPI is preferable), and it must have the ability to scan slides and negatives in other sizes than 35mm (such as 120 and 2-1/4, if possible). Actually, those are just "it'd be nice", not a necessity.

And I'd like to keep it under $200, if possible, but we can go a 'little' over, if need be.

Open to suggestions. Thank you all in advance.
First, I did search for this topic and did not see... (show quote)


In that $200 price range, the Epson V600 is a favorite pick. The skinny on use with a Mac is this:

You must use the 32-bit driver to get full use of all features, unless Epson Scan 2 is updated to include Digital ICE compatibility. The 32-bit driver (Epson Scan 5.x) runs on MacOS Mojave, but NOT by itself on MacOS Catalina. If your Mac uses Catalina, you have several choices:

A) Use the Epson Scan 2 driver. It's okay, but it IS crippled, compared to the older version.

B) Use the free download of SilverFast 8 SE from https://epson.com/Support/Scanners/Perfection-Series/Epson-Perfection-V600-Photo/s/SPT_B11B198011?review-filter=macOS+10.15.x

C) Use an older Mac with MacOS Mojave, or High Sierra, or Sierra, and Epson Scan 5.x.

D) Use your Catalina Mac with Parallels Desktop and Windows 10 with the Windows Epson Scan driver.

E) Use your Catalina Mac with Parallels Desktop and run MacOS Mojave and Epson Scan 5.x.

F) If your Mac supports MacOS Mojave, Install it on an outboard drive and start up from that by holding down the Option key after the chime, and until you see the Apple Logo. You can run Epson Scan from the outboard drive.

I'm currently running an iMac with Mojave most of the time (I have outboard drives that support several other versions of the MacOS and Windows, all of which boot in Parallels or BootCamp).

I also have an old 2010 Mac Mini that runs the old Epson Scan quite well in MacOS Sierra.

Reply
May 2, 2020 13:27:39   #
togajim
 
I use the V600 but with with a PC. Have been very pleased overall, as I am scanning the last 50 yrs of family photo negatives (actually 1970-2003 when I switched to digital, I'm up to 6900 photos and counting). Some of my observations:
1. The negatives holder can accommodate up to 12 negatives in 2 strips. Scanning in this fashion takes about 10-15 minutes/12 pictures, so you do the math
2. Scan time varies significantly depending on which scan options you choose- dpi, color restoration, Unsharp mask, grain reduction, Digital ICE. Since I'm a casual user and don't have plans to enlarge past about 8x10, I've been pretty satisfied with 1200 dpi resolution, Unsharp mask on, Digital ICE on, everything else OFF. PS or other Software does a better with grain reduction and color correction in much less time (if you're like me, you'll find less than 10% of the photos are worth fixing up anyway and if there's a couple of special ones you can always come back and scan at higher dpi). With slides you can do only 4 at a time
3. I've run into problems with Newton rings with badly curved negs. Usually scanning with the negs reversed cures that (but then you have to flip the scans in the on-board software)
4. Take extra care to clean the negs with an anti-static cloth, and clean the glass regularly, else you'll have a lot of dust spots to remove.

Reply
 
 
May 2, 2020 13:39:00   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
Boris77 wrote:
I have had mine for quite a few years, bought it new, run it from an iMac, and have NOT upgraded to the latest Apple OS.


My iMac is a "mid-2010" model and was told that it will NOT take the most recent upgrade. Currently it has 10.13.6 "High Sierra".

Reply
May 2, 2020 13:40:59   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
Many thanks to everyone here in the group for their advice and suggestions. Much appreciated.

Reply
May 2, 2020 13:49:54   #
bw79st Loc: New York City
 
jsktb wrote:
After some research I settled on the Epson Perfection V600. My needs are to digitize 35mm and 2-1/4 slides covering 60 years along with B&W and color photos. I received the scanner on April 27th from B&H Photo. I am using the Epson Scan 2 software that I downloaded from the Epson website to use on my Mac Mini that is running Mojave. There are no problems and I am extremely happy with my decision and the results that I am getting.

The holder allows four 35mm slides at one time. The only annoyance is that I have to remove the film from the cardboard frame of 2-1/4 slides to fit that holder. It is time consuming. Does anyone have any suggestions for a better way?
After some research I settled on the Epson Perfect... (show quote)


My V700 came with carrier for mounted slides. Check the web to see if someone supplies a slide mount carrier.

Reply
May 2, 2020 17:46:51   #
burkphoto Loc: High Point, NC
 
kb6kgx wrote:
My iMac is a "mid-2010" model and was told that it will NOT take the most recent upgrade. Currently it has 10.13.6 "High Sierra".


Then use Epson Scan with no worries.

Reply
 
 
May 2, 2020 18:05:59   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
burkphoto wrote:
Then use Epson Scan with no worries.


I just got back from picking it up. So, I'll give it a try later on. On the box, however, it says that it is compatible with Mac OS up through "10.12.x", but "High Sierra" is 10.13.6. Will that be a problem? I supposed there's only one to find out. Could be just that's in an older box without an updated label and I may just need to download a current driver.

Reply
May 2, 2020 18:10:18   #
burkphoto Loc: High Point, NC
 
kb6kgx wrote:
I just got back from picking it up. So, I'll give it a try later on. On the box, however, it says that it is compatible with Mac OS up through "10.12.x", but "High Sierra" is 10.13.6. Will that be a problem? I supposed there's only one to find out. Could be just that's in an older box without an updated label and I may just need to download a current driver.


No problem — 10.12 to 10.14 are fine.

Reply
May 2, 2020 18:11:14   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
burkphoto wrote:
No problem — 10.12 to 10.14 are fine.


I appreciate your help, as I do everyone else who responded.

Reply
May 2, 2020 19:06:18   #
burkphoto Loc: High Point, NC
 
togajim wrote:
I use the V600 but with with a PC. Have been very pleased overall, as I am scanning the last 50 yrs of family photo negatives (actually 1970-2003 when I switched to digital, I'm up to 6900 photos and counting). Some of my observations:
1. The negatives holder can accommodate up to 12 negatives in 2 strips. Scanning in this fashion takes about 10-15 minutes/12 pictures, so you do the math
2. Scan time varies significantly depending on which scan options you choose- dpi, color restoration, Unsharp mask, grain reduction, Digital ICE. Since I'm a casual user and don't have plans to enlarge past about 8x10, I've been pretty satisfied with 1200 dpi resolution, Unsharp mask on, Digital ICE on, everything else OFF. PS or other Software does a better with grain reduction and color correction in much less time (if you're like me, you'll find less than 10% of the photos are worth fixing up anyway and if there's a couple of special ones you can always come back and scan at higher dpi). With slides you can do only 4 at a time
3. I've run into problems with Newton rings with badly curved negs. Usually scanning with the negs reversed cures that (but then you have to flip the scans in the on-board software)
4. Take extra care to clean the negs with an anti-static cloth, and clean the glass regularly, else you'll have a lot of dust spots to remove.
I use the V600 but with with a PC. Have been very ... (show quote)


Great tips!

Those who have odd film sizes (60mm wide and narrower) can find third party film holders on Amazon.

There are several good videos on YouTube that walk new users through the finer points. (There are some that are a waste of time, too...)

Reply
 
 
May 2, 2020 21:39:43   #
adamsg Loc: Chubbuck, ID
 
I think you have a setup that you will enjoy using and getting fine results. When I was teaching public school to pay off educational debts, I taught at Sinaloa Jr. HS and Royal HS in the early 70s. The areas between Simi Valley and Calabassas, up in the hills, had some fine places for wild flower photography. I imagine Simi Valey has grown immensely and wonder how much of the wonderful countryside remains.

Best wishes!

Reply
May 2, 2020 23:01:41   #
kb6kgx Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
adamsg wrote:
I think you have a setup that you will enjoy using and getting fine results. When I was teaching public school to pay off educational debts, I taught at Sinaloa Jr. HS and Royal HS in the early 70s. The areas between Simi Valley and Calabassas, up in the hills, had some fine places for wild flower photography. I imagine Simi Valey has grown immensely and wonder how much of the wonderful countryside remains.

Best wishes!


Thanks. We live close to Simi Valley High School. Along with fire photography I like to photograph the trains near the Corriganville park.

Reply
May 3, 2020 00:17:24   #
Dalbon
 
kb6kgx wrote:
First, I did search for this topic and did not see anything helpful so I'm asking now.

I used to have a Canon Canoscan 4400F which I used for scanning prints and slides, but after it "died" and Canon said they no longer supported this model, I have been looking for a replacement.

The two scanners that come up most often with the highest recommendations are the Epson Perfection V550 and V600. However, some of the user comments I have seen of these is that they are not necessarily incompatible with Mac computers -- they do work -- but that they do not come with Mac software and you have to find and download it yourself.

So, my question to the group is would any of you concur that either of these two scanners would be the way to go for me or should I look at other scanners? My requirements are that it must be at least 2400 DPI (4800 DPI is preferable), and it must have the ability to scan slides and negatives in other sizes than 35mm (such as 120 and 2-1/4, if possible). Actually, those are just "it'd be nice", not a necessity.

And I'd like to keep it under $200, if possible, but we can go a 'little' over, if need be.

Open to suggestions. Thank you all in advance.
First, I did search for this topic and did not see... (show quote)




I also has a Nikon Scanner and it's the Nikon Supper Coolscan 9000 film scanner. Works great with my Mac although I haven't used in some time but it's a great scanner and does the job very well.
Thanks, David

Reply
May 3, 2020 08:09:14   #
rpavich Loc: West Virginia
 
adamsg wrote:
What you have heard about the Epson Perfection V600Photo scanner is incorrect, in my experience. I have an I-Mac with extra hard drive capacity and an external hard drive back-up. I have done all manner of scanning, film, slides and digitizing photographs. It works flawlessly and I can heartily recommend it, without reservation.


Same here (on a macbook pro 2015)

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.