Seeking SAFE card reader (Repeat SAFE!!!)
Aug 27, 2019 22:57:32 #
waliddle
Loc: Washington State
I have had several card readers an d have had no problems with them, the computers or damage to the cards themselves. Don't think I have spent more than $15.00 for any of my readers.
Aug 27, 2019 23:22:36 #
TriX wrote:
This is always a subject of controversy, but two r... (show quote)
Interesting. I shoot RAW. Usually 30-40 on a card or thereabouts. Time doesnt matter too much to me I must admit, but it doesnt seem to take that long.
Aug 28, 2019 01:06:18 #
jdubu
Loc: San Jose, CA
TonyP wrote:
Interesting. I shoot RAW. Usually 30-40 on a card or thereabouts. Time doesnt matter too much to me I must admit, but it doesnt seem to take that long.
Well, to each their own. I personally never use the camera as a card reader. I use the usb port only when I need tethering, either to a CamRanger or directly to a laptop and am always careful plugging into the port. Otherwise, I download via a dedicated card reader.
I use multiple cards (CF and SD) in my cameras and may have used multiple cameras and cards during a session or day of shooting. At times, especially on vacation, I will have changed cards multiple times and would never have the chance to download to a PC. I do download backup copies to portable HDs via RavPower and/or WD My Passport Pro wireless systems regardless of the situation.
Anything you can do to shorten your time behind the computer, you should, IMHO
Aug 28, 2019 02:34:31 #
I have never had a failure of a card reader, but if you want to play it safe, just buy a Brand Name, like LEXAR, SANDISK, PNY, BELKIN, etc. Also, DO NOT TRUST AMAZON'S REVIEWS! They are often misplaced, out of date, or Both! I buy my Photo Gear from B&H, Adorama, Hunts and Similar Camera Shops. If you pay into the Free Shipping Deal at Amazon, just be sure you receive what you intended to buy, and that it is in a Sealed Package. You can trust Amazon with simple Photographic items, but if anything involves a rebate, I would go to an actual Camera Shop. I have NEVER, EVER, Had any problems with B&H Photo & Video
Aug 28, 2019 11:51:18 #
JD750 wrote:
I have done tests. Actually the cord is a lot slower for large numbers of high resolution images.
The cord is ok for a few images or for images scattered around.
The cord is ok for a few images or for images scattered around.
I recently downloaded the images from my Alaska cruise using the camera and cable and for 990 images it took approx. ten minutes to download.
Was this slow or fast, it depends on what you consider slow or fast. Could I have downloaded them using the card reader I have any quicker, possibly, but the the number of images I had I believe it would have taken just as long.
When I get ready to format my card I will probably do another download to another drive just to ensure that I have the images. By the way all the images were on a 32GB CF card and I shoot RAW and JPEG. I know some one is going to ask why but that is my preferred method of shooting.
Aug 28, 2019 14:08:35 #
John Maher
Loc: Northern Virginia
Years ago, a "company" compared the reliability of HP and TI programmable calculators.
They found that HP "company" calculators were more reliable than equivalent "company" TI models.
They also found that HP and TI "personally-owned" calculators were equally reliable.
Seems like a lot of it was how people took care them.
They found that HP "company" calculators were more reliable than equivalent "company" TI models.
They also found that HP and TI "personally-owned" calculators were equally reliable.
Seems like a lot of it was how people took care them.
Aug 28, 2019 18:26:39 #
Have several of these; never had a problem (though only handles SD, not CF, cards). I prefer the white; easier to find. Pink for my better half so we don't argue. Cap keeps crud out while in my computer bag.
https://www.amazon.com/Transcend-TS-RDF5K-microSDHC-Reader-Black/dp/B009D79VH4/ref=sxin_3_osp22-aaa5f6c1_cov
At home, plugs into an Orico USB3 hub that is kept attached to desktop.
For ease of attaching to notebook, I use a short USB3 extension cable from Monoprice (also have a number of these cables attached to the notebook's docking station).
After a day's shooting, simply take the SD card and battery out of the camera. SD card goes in the reader, battery in the charger.
https://www.amazon.com/Transcend-TS-RDF5K-microSDHC-Reader-Black/dp/B009D79VH4/ref=sxin_3_osp22-aaa5f6c1_cov
At home, plugs into an Orico USB3 hub that is kept attached to desktop.
For ease of attaching to notebook, I use a short USB3 extension cable from Monoprice (also have a number of these cables attached to the notebook's docking station).
After a day's shooting, simply take the SD card and battery out of the camera. SD card goes in the reader, battery in the charger.
Aug 31, 2019 21:42:25 #
marine73 wrote:
<snip>... Could I have downloaded them using the card reader I have any quicker, possibly, but the the number of images I had I believe it would have taken just as long.
You are speculating. If you want the real answer do some comparative tests and write down the results and post them here.
Sep 1, 2019 13:22:14 #
Believe it or not
Loc: West Virginia
jdubu wrote:
I gave away all my old card readers (mostly 2.0 USB). I replaced them with a Lexar 3.0 and Delkin 3.0 readers. Both have performed flawlessly and are always connected to one of my PCs.
Sep 1, 2019 13:33:48 #
Believe it or not
Loc: West Virginia
I have a Vivitar card reader with 5 slots, can't remember where I got it, have used it for years with no problem. Micro SD - MS - GS - GX - XD - CF Slots.
Sep 2, 2019 16:42:23 #
I have used $1 card readers fro eBay for years and have never had a problem. The card readers will not cause any problems with your computer, so spend as much as you think is worthwhile.
Sep 5, 2019 20:14:14 #
TonyP wrote:
This may be a silly comment, question, but why do ... (show quote)
Then you have been very lucky so far, if you have any glitch happening on your computer, while your camera is connected, you have a very good chance it will be damaged beyond repair! Never connect your camera to a computer for that!
Sep 13, 2019 13:19:45 #
speters wrote:
Then you have been very lucky so far, if you have any glitch happening on your computer, while your camera is connected, you have a very good chance it will be damaged beyond repair! Never connect your camera to a computer for that!
I am sorry but that is a ridiculous and incorrect statement.
Yes it "could" happen that a glitch scrambles some images but the chance of the computer failing and damaging the camera is very very small. Maybe if the computer was struck by lighting wile connected to the camera it would cause damage.
Sep 13, 2019 13:49:50 #
[quote=JD750]I am sorry but that is a ridiculous and incorrect statement.
Or if you are downloading in the house, the ceiling could fall in and your camera could be crushed, so download outdoors.
I see time after time folks on this forum, more than on any other forum, that are constantly looking for problems, like little kids afraid of the monster under the bed.
Or if you are downloading in the house, the ceiling could fall in and your camera could be crushed, so download outdoors.
I see time after time folks on this forum, more than on any other forum, that are constantly looking for problems, like little kids afraid of the monster under the bed.
Sep 13, 2019 14:31:27 #
[quote=Bill P]
Good point!! Or an earthquake or tornado could strike the house, or maybe an airplane or truck could crash into the house, so there are even more reasons to only download outdoors. Never download inside the house.
On UHH you get:
(1) Expert advice
(2) Strong conflicting opinions
(3) Completely wrong answers
It is up to the reader to sort them out.
JD750 wrote:
I am sorry but that is a ridiculous and incorrect statement.
Or if you are downloading in the house, the ceiling could fall in and your camera could be crushed, so download outdoors.
I see time after time folks on this forum, more than on any other forum, that are constantly looking for problems, like little kids afraid of the monster under the bed.
Or if you are downloading in the house, the ceiling could fall in and your camera could be crushed, so download outdoors.
I see time after time folks on this forum, more than on any other forum, that are constantly looking for problems, like little kids afraid of the monster under the bed.
Good point!! Or an earthquake or tornado could strike the house, or maybe an airplane or truck could crash into the house, so there are even more reasons to only download outdoors. Never download inside the house.
On UHH you get:
(1) Expert advice
(2) Strong conflicting opinions
(3) Completely wrong answers
It is up to the reader to sort them out.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.