Which is best in your opinion? (Page 3): My personal favorite is the photo of your dog, but I'd post #2 for the competition.

Dixiegirl Loc: Alabama gulf coast

My personal favorite is the photo of your dog, but I'd post #2 for the competition.

Rolenz Loc: Tripping around Oz

With the Parkinsons association, I would go with the dog. There is someone missing in that photo. Anyone who has had a pet will see that. Sometimes it is not what you see, it is the story you see. Good luck with your choice.

Tina

#2

MagicFad Loc: Clermont, FL

Rolenz wrote:

With the Parkinsons association, I would go with the dog. There is someone missing in that photo. Anyone who has had a pet will see that. Sometimes it is not what you see, it is the story you see. Good luck with your choice.

That is a very good observation.

graham52 Loc: Scotland

3 is the most unique of the set,

Hoss Loc: Near Pittsburgh, Pa

2

Gordon wrote:

I hope I have done everything correctly to get this topic posted. If I have, there should be three photos, one of my dog and two of three trees in a field. I want to enter one of them into a photography competition and would like your opinion as to which one I should enter. Thank you.

Bram boy Loc: Vancouver Island B.C. Canada

The trees are uninteresting , they are shot,s that fill every scrap book in the country . Now the dog is the best photo here , it grab's you and makes you want to look . I would not crop a thing out of it . The edges add to the picture , you take the edges out all you got is a picture of a dog . The whole is what makes this picture . But who are the judges ' if they are pros who knowes what they might say , if tis your local fair or church or the or the school your dog shot got it by a mile . Dont crop.

Bram boy Loc: Vancouver Island B.C. Canada

DK wrote:

#2. Three objects make for good composition. Dog has too many distractions and no detail such as an eye that shows. The first one has the disturbing trees on the left. Perhaps the horizon line should be level on #2. Can you straighten it? Maybe that is the terrain that slopes, but #1 appears level.

You remind me of a wine snob

wonkytripod Loc: Peterborough UK

Gordon wrote:

I hope I have done everything correctly to get this topic posted. If I have, there should be three photos, one of my dog and two of three trees in a field. I want to enter one of them into a photography competition and would like your opinion as to which one I should enter. Thank you.

#3

Coolcameragirl Loc: Bradenton, FL

Bram boy wrote:

DK wrote:

#2. Three objects make for good composition. Dog has too many distractions and no detail such as an eye that shows. The first one has the disturbing trees on the left. Perhaps the horizon line should be level on #2. Can you straighten it? Maybe that is the terrain that slopes, but #1 appears level.

You remind me of a wine snob

I must stand with Bram boy. I am a camera club judge and he is totally right on with his constructive criticism, especially the dog.

Coolcameragirl Loc: Bradenton, FL

Coolcameragirl wrote:

quote=Bram boy quote=DK #2. Three objects make f... (show quote)

Sorry, I meant DK.

DK Loc: SD

Bram boy wrote:

DK wrote:

#2. Three objects make for good composition. Dog has too many distractions and no detail such as an eye that shows. The first one has the disturbing trees on the left. Perhaps the horizon line should be level on #2. Can you straighten it? Maybe that is the terrain that slopes, but #1 appears level.

You remind me of a wine snob

I do like wine, but no one who knows me considers me a snob and I do judge a lot of photo competitions. If that makes me a snob, so be it. Do I care what you think? No!

docrob Loc: Durango, Colorado

Gordon wrote:

I hope I have done everything correctly to get this topic posted. If I have, there should be three photos, one of my dog and two of three trees in a field. I want to enter one of them into a photography competition and would like your opinion as to which one I should enter. Thank you.

the dog

Bram boy Loc: Vancouver Island B.C. Canada

DK wrote:

quote=Bram boy quote=DK #2. Three objects make f... (show quote)

But you care enough to come back to me , i drink a ton of wine , there is only three types -- good , so so -- bad . - all this crap " i can tast the strawberries in it, now the hint of bluebarries , oh" and the lemon peel , now i smell the rose pettles , and the shoe polish, must not forget the apple and peach . Bull! all this from grapes " gimme a brake"