I got the 16-85 last year for use on my D300. It's a great lens I think you will like it. ;)
Do I get that or keep my 2 prime lenses and get a 20mm or a 12-24mm????
The 12-24mm is a neat lens but it's even more expensive than the 16-85mm. Do you often need an ultra wide angle? When I need wider that my 16mm end goes I usually shoot it as a panorama and get good results that way. That would be up to you if that would even work for you. When I shoot panos with a wide angle I typically do them as verticals with the camera to keep the distortion down. Try it sometime and see what you think. Check Ken Rockwell's reviews, he has done the 16-85 and the 12-24 both.
Having had no bites for sales and having done more research, I will try the wide kit lens (only costs $100 new) to see if its OK for indoor group photos.
Thanks to everyone for your advice.
Do you still have the 85mm for sale?
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.