I have posted two images here – the first one I took of the Mission Mountains here in northwest Montana. The second one I wanted to create a moonscape where a daytime image was converted into a nighttime moonlit shot. I would very much appreciate any feedback regarding the conversion. I used a "moonlight" LUT for the basic conversion, decreased the opacity of the LUT to lighten it a bit, and added the moon and a few dodge and burn adjustments. Changed the sky to a starry night, of course. I used a layer mask to highlight the mountains and tried not to overdo any one aspect of this effort. Constructive criticism on how I might improve the converted image is most welcome... thanks for looking!
Overall a nicely done composite. My first impression was beautiful but over done. The treatment of the mountains is wonderful. That LUT is tricky to use but you did well with it. IMO the sky has way too many stars. When you isolate images like the moon maybe use a one or two pixel feather to help it blend into the background. If it were my image, and it's not, I would replace the sky with some wispy clouds and only a few stars.
Curmudgeon wrote:
When you isolate images like the moon maybe use a one or two pixel feather to help it blend into the background.
I went back and incorporated that into the image, and it definitely made an improvement! Thank you so much for the suggestion.
Can you post the edit Jack suggested, Tommy? The moon does look pasted. Another thought: because the rest - especially the mountains - are so gorgeous, I'd consider making the moon smaller, and also whiter.
tommystrat wrote:
I have posted two images here – the first one I took of the Mission Mountains here in northwest Montana. The second one I wanted to create a moonscape where a daytime image was converted into a nighttime moonlit shot. I would very much appreciate any feedback regarding the conversion. I used a "moonlight" LUT for the basic conversion, decreased the opacity of the LUT to lighten it a bit, and added the moon and a few dodge and burn adjustments. Changed the sky to a starry night, of course. I used a layer mask to highlight the mountains and tried not to overdo any one aspect of this effort. Constructive criticism on how I might improve the converted image is most welcome... thanks for looking!
I have posted two images here – the first one I to... (
show quote)
I enjoyed both lovely versions.
Linda From Maine wrote:
Can you post the edit Jack suggested, Tommy? The moon does look pasted. Another thought: because the rest - especially the mountains - are so gorgeous, I'd consider making the moon smaller, and also whiter.
So I feathered the moon a little bit, decreased its size and increased the brightness just a bit. I think it's getting there…
tommystrat wrote:
So I feathered the moon a little bit, decreased its size and increased the brightness just a bit. I think it's getting there…
For sure. Thanks Tommy, it's a beauty!
joecichjr
Loc: Chicago S. Suburbs, Illinois, USA
tommystrat wrote:
So I feathered the moon a little bit, decreased its size and increased the brightness just a bit. I think it's getting there…
Tommy, if you are not getting rich off of your exquisite shots, there is something wrong with the economy and people's tastes. So here: 💰💰💰💰💰
The modified image is from the movie... mystic.
tommystrat wrote:
So I feathered the moon a little bit, decreased its size and increased the brightness just a bit. I think it's getting there…
You took Jacks suggestions and ran with it. Much better.
Thanks for the input and suggestions. I really value the constructive thoughts that you all post. Linda, Jack, Frank, Karin, dpullum - much appreciated. And Joe, I promise not to spend all that loot in one place!
;-)
WOW! great challenge, well met.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.