Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Minolta lenses on a Nikon body?
May 15, 2023 07:50:50   #
yvesfeder Loc: Bath, ME
 
I was given two Minolta-mount lenses (a wide angle and a zoom telephoto) that came from an estate - I use Nikons, so I purchased a "mount adapter" to place on standard "F" style film AND digital Nikon bodies - and I find it is not possible to bring them into focus! As if the adapters were not long enough (most of these type adapters are only about 1/2 cm in width) Are the adapters just junk? They are sold by reputable camera dealers...... so dunno what is wrong. Where would I find correct length adapters - or should I just give the lenses away to a Minolta user??? Thanks for any input - Best wishes, Yves

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:04:09   #
BebuLamar
 
What kind of Minolta lenses are they? SR mount or A mount (that is the old manual focus or the newer auto focus mount)? But both have shorter flange distance than that of a Nikon F mount lens so the adapter must have some lens element in it otherwise it won't focus to infinity.

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:07:49   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
According to Wiki, the Minolta/Konica mount (Sony-A) is 44.5mm. The Nikon F-mount is 46.5mm. That 2-millimeter difference would make it impossible to adapt the Minolta lenses onto an F-mount body. The Minolta lenses need to be closer to the film / sensor plane to focus properly. They would have to sit inside the Nikon body to be 44.5mm distance from the film / sensor. There are a few other Minolta lens mounts, but these are still closer to the film / sensor than the F-mount; and therefore, the same issue.

Legacy film lenses are useful on mirrorless digital bodies. With the removal of the mirror, the mirrorless mounts are closer, such as Nikon's Z-mount at 16mm. Now, an adapter will add distance to set the film-era lens to the proper flange distance and the lenses will focus perfectly.

Look again at the mount type of the Minolta lenses. The A-mount versions mount directly onto discontinued Sony bodies, such as the a900, a99, a77, a68. Some of these cameras were being sold new a recently as 2018, featuring either full-frame or cropped sensors, depending on model.

Reply
 
 
May 15, 2023 08:12:36   #
rmalarz Loc: Tempe, Arizona
 
Not a great deal of information is provided here. Who made the adapters?
--Bob
yvesfeder wrote:
I was given two Minolta-mount lenses (a wide angle and a zoom telephoto) that came from an estate - I use Nikons, so I purchased a "mount adapter" to place on standard "F" style film AND digital Nikon bodies - and I find it is not possible to bring them into focus! As if the adapters were not long enough (most of these type adapters are only about 1/2 cm in width) Are the adapters just junk? They are sold by reputable camera dealers...... so dunno what is wrong. Where would I find correct length adapters - or should I just give the lenses away to a Minolta user??? Thanks for any input - Best wishes, Yves
I was given two Minolta-mount lenses (a wide angle... (show quote)

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:19:23   #
agillot
 
When i went from film to digital , [ from pentax ] , a friend gave me his older nik D300 with 2 lenses . Got a fotodiox ???? adapter to use my old pentax lenses on the d300 . It work fine [ it has a lens in it ] . the only issue , in bright day , it show a donut like halo on the pictures . So i bought a used [ like new ] pentax ist D 6 mp body [ from japan ] and am using it at time . It has a ccd sensor , and you really see the difference in pic quality . The ccd sensor , if you ignore the low pixel count has better colors / contrast then the cmos sensor .So for about $ 50 , get a used minolta camera for a bargain price .

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:21:22   #
BebuLamar
 
agillot wrote:
When i went from film to digital , [ from pentax ] , a friend gave me his older nik D300 with 2 lenses . Got a fotodiox ???? adapter to use my old pentax lenses on the d300 . It work fine [ it has a lens in it ] . the only issue , in bright day , it show a donut like halo on the pictures . So i bought a used [ like new ] pentax ist D 6 mp body [ from japan ] and am using it at time . It has a ccd sensor , and you really see the difference in pic quality . The ccd sensor , if you ignore the low pixel count has better colors / contrast then the cmos sensor .So for about $ 50 , get a used minolta camera for a bargain price .
When i went from film to digital , from pentax ... (show quote)


I want a Sony A900 to use with Minolta A mount lenses but the price is anything but bargain. The price is more like $1000 for a good working one. I would have bought it when it was new when nobody wanted it and the dealer offered to sell the A900 body for $2500. But at the time I had no Minolta A mount lens. Recently my brother gave me a good number of the Minolta A mount lenses but looking at used A900 they are way too expensive.

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:29:42   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
BebuLamar wrote:
I want a Sony A900 to use with Minolta A mount lenses but the price is anything but bargain. The price is more like $1000 for a good working one. I would have bought it when it was new when nobody wanted it and the dealer offered to sell the A900 body for $2500. But at the time I had no Minolta A mount lens. Recently my brother gave me a good number of the Minolta A mount lenses but looking at used A900 they are way too expensive.


The a900 is (was) a 24MP "pro-tier" Sony model. Prices are now in the $500 range if you shop around a little. These top-tier models will tend to retain their value the longest, but still, their prices drop as they age and fall further behind current / new technology.

Reply
 
 
May 15, 2023 08:33:27   #
BebuLamar
 
CHG_CANON wrote:
The a900 is (was) a 24MP "pro-tier" Sony model. Prices are now in the $500 range if you shop around a little. These top-tier models will tend to retain their value the longest, but still, their prices drop as they age and fall further behind current / new technology.


OK I look but really to answer the OP as I have the Minolta lenses and Nikon body but I never consider adapt them. They just won't work right.

Reply
May 15, 2023 08:38:44   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
BebuLamar wrote:
OK I look but really to answer the OP as I have the Minolta lenses and Nikon body but I never consider adapt them. They just won't work right.


Yep, for DSLRinosaurs. Mirrorless and / or the digital bodies with the native mount are valid options, technically.

Reply
May 15, 2023 10:33:17   #
newsguygeorge Loc: Victoria, Texas
 
I have a bunch of Minolta lenses from the SRT101 days. I researched using them on my Nikon D5300 and bought a FotodioX Pro Lens Mount Adapter for Minolta MD Lens to Nikon F Mount Camera from B&H. I had no expectation that the older lenses would work like the ones designed for the D5300. But, they do work. I have to manually focus and I choose to manually set exposure and shutter speed. After lots of experimentation, I only use an old Tamaron 600 with a converter to go for some really long shots. It works. On the other hand, since I also have the F mount Tamron 18-400, the old lenses don’t get much use.

TDLR; The FotodioX Pro Lens Mount Adapter for Minolta MD Lens to Nikon F Mount works manually.

Reply
May 15, 2023 11:25:24   #
yvesfeder Loc: Bath, ME
 
Thank you much for the detailed answer! Explains why I can't bring them in focus............

No, these lenses are older legacy models I suspect - the so-called adapters are too short I believe and I'm just offering them to any Minolta users who might want them. Nice glass - one is a Fujinon, the other Minolta, both very well made and finished. I toyed with the idea of picking up a Minolta body on the cheap just to have fun but in the end would rather pass them on..... :)

Take care,
Yves

Reply
 
 
May 16, 2023 12:51:23   #
Nicholas J DeSciose
 
Well, work on new Sony bodies with adapter EA – LA

Reply
May 16, 2023 16:38:03   #
AnotherBob
 
yvesfeder wrote:
I was given two Minolta-mount lenses (a wide angle and a zoom telephoto) that came from an estate - I use Nikons, so I purchased a "mount adapter" to place on standard "F" style film AND digital Nikon bodies - and I find it is not possible to bring them into focus! As if the adapters were not long enough (most of these type adapters are only about 1/2 cm in width) Are the adapters just junk? They are sold by reputable camera dealers...... so dunno what is wrong. Where would I find correct length adapters - or should I just give the lenses away to a Minolta user??? Thanks for any input - Best wishes, Yves
I was given two Minolta-mount lenses (a wide angle... (show quote)



I have multiple old Minolta MC Rokkor lenses from my old Minolta SRT-101 days. Although I prefer to use them on my Z6 with a Metabones MD - Z mount adapter, they do also work with a "Fotodiox Pro Minolta MD - Nikon" adapter for my Nikon D60, D800 or D500. Both adapters were purchased from B&H, with the Metabones being more expensive. In both cases, the lenses focus to infinity. I did not realize until I purchased it (my bad) that the Fotodiox has a lens in it to allow it to focus to infinity, while provided 1.4 x magnification. Much easier for me to use with the Nikon Z camera bodies, which assist with the focus; handy with my 77 year old eyes. I also find the lensless Z adapter provides a clearer image.

If you decide to give them away, and they are MC or MD mount, I would be more than happy to take them off your hands. Until then, enjoy the experiment, and treat it as such.

Reply
May 16, 2023 21:22:16   #
Frank Gossett Loc: Colleyville, TX
 
I, too, have Minolta Rokkor Lenses that I use on a Z6 with Fotasy MD/NZ Adapter. I have the 45, 50, 85 & 135. All go to Infinity.

Reply
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.