jerryc41 wrote:
Yes, that has always amazed me. Why can't BMW and Mercedes make a reliable car? When Consumer Reports or JD Power does a survey of owners about reliability, it's the Japanese cars, not the Germans, that keep running and running. The very expensive Land Rover series aren't any better. They're expensive and classy, but I wouldn't buy one.
I know this is going generate replies from owners who have put millions of miles on their German cars, but that doesn't disprove the testimony of thousands of owners. I traded my 1997 Honda Civic, with 325,000 miles, for a new Fit.
As for tinkering with cars, I still do that. Dealers do questionable work for ridiculously high prices. My Fit is getting new brake pads today.
Yes, that has always amazed me. Why can't BMW and... (
show quote)
After my youth spent with British cars, I bought my first new car in 1971 - a BMW 2002. BMWs were just being imported into America by Hoffman motors, and compared to my British and Swedish cars (I had 3 SAAB 2 strokes, including a triple carb Monte Carlo, complete with a Nardi Wood steering wheel), it was a revelation. It was solid, quiet, smooth and was really quite nimble if not blindingly fast - I loved it. The quality of the workmanship was quite good, but it did have some early mechanical issues, but it was definitely better built (especially the electricals) than any of my British cars, and never left me on the side of the road. Traded it for the first of my two Porsche 911Es (air cooled), which were quite fast, but the handling could be a handful at speed. If I had my choice of anything to drive today, cost no object, it might well be another 911, crazy expensive repairs and all.
Now back to your original observation of German vs Japanese cars. Full disclosure: I’ve owned a Datsun 280Z (great car for the $) and 3 Lexi (or Lexuses), and my wife is currently driving a 350ES, which is 15 years old and never had ANYTHING fail - it’s had oil changes, a battery or two, tires and brakes - nothing else. The dealership couldn’t be better, go out of their way to be helpful, and the service usually costs less than I expect. Always a (new) Lexus loaner if I don’t want to wait, and the car is always returned washed and spotlessly clean. My wife drove it on a 300 mile round trip this weekend, and it got 33.8 mpg - this with a 260 bhp very responsive engine with a 6 speed auto that will do 0-60 in about 6.5 sec. Quiet and smooth. Not a “driver’s car”, but a great automobile. if I ever replace it (eventually rubber seals fail and that is what often finishes off old cars), no question, I will buy another Lexus. As Road and Track said a few years ago: “Toyota Motor Company is making the best cars in the world”. BTW, her second car was totaled in Driver’s side T bone hard enough to break the B pillar, and she walked away without a scratch, thanks in part to the side air bags.
Now while my wife has had Lexi, I’ve been driving Mercedes since 97, starting with a C280 Sport (all the suspension mods of the AMG C36 plus leather Recaro seats, but not the AMG engine). Great little car - gave it to my son when I bought my current E350 in 2006. He drove it until it reached 280,000 miles. It was pretty reliable. Went though 2 A/C compressors (probably because I red lined it multiple times a day), and a crankshaft position sensor, but that’s about it. Quality was excellent, and it was still tight with good leather when he sold it and didn’t leak anything. The E350 is now 17 years old with 138K on the clock, and I’ll probably die with it. Always garaged and no one has ever driven it except me and my mechanic. I still do the work on it if it doesn’t require a lift. I think some of the quality has slipped over the years. It’s leaking oil from the separator and the gearbox pan seal at the moment (got to get that fixed), and it needs motor mounts and I think it has an exhaust manifold leak. Also this was one of the group of Mercedes V6s from 2006-2008 that was manufactured with a poorly heat treated balance shaft gear. This throws off the cam timing which sets the CEL and causes it to fail inspection. Mercedes would not pay for the 4K$ fix (would have been 6K at the dealer) which had to be done as eventually the timing chain would slip a cog or 2 destroying the engine. It’s also had a flakey crank position sensor, and I’ve had to have the side of the driver’s seat bolster repaired twice. On the positive side, it’s quite strong (the torque curve is dead flat from 1800-4000 rpm thanks to variable cam timing and variable intake length), Handles well, although with more body roll than I like, and just as solid and quiet as the day it was bought. Everything in the interior and exterior looks like new, and here’s the thing - I always smile inwardly when I walk up to it. The Europeans (and especially the Germans) know a thing or two about style and ergonomics that the Japanese have yet to master. Better seats, instruments, cruise control and interior than the Lexus hands down, and a much more elegant body. And little things, like putting the battery in the trunk - the original lasted 16 years (!), and fold down back seats, so you can load it full of 8’ lumber. Also while I have changed the serpentine belt proactively, the hoses, water pump and alternator and all the electricals have never failed (yet).
So here’s the thing. Here you have 2 mid sized “luxury” sedans, both about the same size and weight, both with 3.5L V6s with 260-270 bhp, one RWD, one FWD, both bought about the same time. The Merc is prettier (in my opinion) and with much better interior and ergonomics, plus I prefer the RWD. But it cost substantially more. The quality, except for the Merc’s drive’s seat, is about equal. But where the Germans fail compared to the Japanese, is they make very complex designs, with good quality, but the combination yields only average reliability. The parts are expensive and because of that, the resale value is awful. The Lexus, which cost about 12K less, is now worth twice as much. And then there’s the issue of the balance shaft gear. Mercedes had to be sued over that (and lost), and neither the factory or the dealer provided any help for those cars that were just out of warranty (when they all failed). And because of that, as much as I love mine and smile every time I drive it, looking at the 3 pointed star and knowing their 100+ year history, I won’t buy another - it will be a Japanese car (most likely another Lexus) instead.