Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Viewfinder or Screen?
Page <prev 2 of 7 next> last>>
Jul 3, 2022 07:40:35   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
roxiemarty wrote:
I will never own a camera without a viewfinder! I might as well shoot blind outside.


Reply
Jul 3, 2022 07:41:35   #
Red6
 
As in most things in life, it is not white or black but a shade of gray. In other words, it depends on the situation. Sometimes I use the viewfinder and sometimes I use the LCD screen. In film days, before DSLRs and autofocus, the viewfinders were all we had to compose and focus, and we got used to them. Today, we have a choices.

The viewfinder works best for me when shooting a landscape or an outdoor shoot and I want to center the image on a particular point. If for example, I am using the camera handheld and want to take a photo of an airplane in flight or other moving targets, the viewfinder usually works best.

If I am shooting in a crowd and want to shoot over the heads of the crowd, I extend the screen and angle it down so as I hold the camera over my head, I can still center the subject in the image. The screen is also best when I want to shoot a large scene with no particular center point, such as a lake, mountain, or large crowd of people or objects. It also works best if you just want to capture a scene, such as a family gathering, and want to capture on-the-go shots of people and activities without a central focal point.

Astrophotography is the one time that the LCD screen is most important for me. I can more easily target my subject, especially the moon, and get it properly centered. It is quite difficult and even uncomfortable to look through a viewfinder when the camera is tripod mounted and pointed at high angles in the sky. Extending the tripod higher for more comfortable viewing then makes the setup less stable and prone to vibration. In fact, I am even considering buying a small 8-10 inch external screen to mount on my tripod to view astro subjects much more comfortable and stable.

So again in life situations, very few things are yes or no, white or black. It is maybe, sometimes, and a shade of gray between white and black.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 07:49:03   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
Red6 wrote:
...
...
If I am shooting in a crowd and want to shoot over the heads of the crowd, I extend the screen and angle it down so as I hold the camera over my head, I can still center the subject in the image. ...
...

Yea, it would be nice if my camera had an articulated screen so I wasn't shooting blind in those situations.
I use the viewfinder 100% of the time, even though I can utilize live view on the rear screen.

Reply
 
 
Jul 3, 2022 08:00:18   #
jaymatt Loc: Alexandria, Indiana
 
It’s a viewfinder for me, always, unless I am using my phone where I have no choice.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 08:11:07   #
photophly Loc: Old Bridge NJ
 
I like to use a viewfinder,it helps me compose my shot more effectively.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 08:12:57   #
Bayou
 
I wonder how much shake/wobble is introduced into the equation when hand holding with a screen out in front of your body. Surely a viewfinder is more easily held stable.

I'll never buy another camera that lacks a viewfinder.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 08:32:17   #
lamiaceae Loc: San Luis Obispo County, CA
 
Just Fred wrote:
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 CX-format camera, which I bought as something of a transitional piece, having gone from 35mm SLR film, to an early Olympus battery-draining fixed-lens, 3 mpx handheld that was my entry point into digital photography. The Nikon 1 offered what I thought was the best of both worlds, a small form factor digital camera with interchangeable lenses. For a while, it became my camera of choice, although I never quite bonded with it the way I thought I should.

Part of this was the strange way Nikon forced one to power on the camera and then "unlock" the lens before shooting. OK, that was easy enough to adjust to, but the one thing that I could never ease into was using the LCD screen as the viewfinder.

My old 35mm SLRs (Minolta and Canon) both had through-the-lens metering and viewfinder systems where I could view and compose my shots, while using both hands to focus, set shutter speed and aperture opening. In a sense, I could do it all and still keep my attention on the subject.

When I finally moved to the Nikon D7xxx series, both LCD and viewfinder were available, and I never bother to use the screen for anything other than pre-shooting setup (I think Nikon may have earned enough ire from it's 1 customers to ultimately add an electronic viewfinder to the later models).

So, now I've pulled my old 1 out of mothballs, have added the 10-100mm autozoom lens which doesn't require either swapping lenses or the awkward rotation to start the process, and am thinking of finding out where this fits in my camera toolkit.

I'm still not comfortable using the LCD screen, and in some cases outdoors, the image is washed out by sunlight, but I'm wondering

a) Am I alone in preferring a viewfinder? I don't quite understand the difference between electronic and manual, but my eye in a cup seems to work.
b) How do those of you using the LCD make it work best for you? Are there tricks or tips I just don't know?
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 ... (show quote)


Viewfinder or I won't buy it.

Reply
 
 
Jul 3, 2022 09:09:32   #
StanMac Loc: Tennessee
 
I’m a viewfinder kinda guy. However, I’d really like to have a flippy screen for those low angle shots or low to the ground macro/closeups.

Stan

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 09:19:06   #
whatdat Loc: Del Valle, Tx.
 
Bought a Fuji waterproof p&s a couple of years ago for a rafting trip. No viewfinder & needed an option. Found a fold out lcd hood for the camera. Works pretty well. Through Amazon & inexpensive.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 09:38:14   #
BebuLamar
 
With my DSLR (a Nikon Df) I always use the viewfinder and never use liveview. Even when the meter in the viewfinder failed and the metering system with liveview was still functioning correctly I rather guess the exposure than to use liveview.
With my old Nikon Coolpix 5000 I never used its optical viewfinder I always used the screen. The reason? The optical viewfinder is so inaccurate it has severe paralax problem. If I adjust the diopter for my eye sight at one end of the zoom then it's not correct for the other end. It's a direct optical viewfinder which doesn't work for manual focusing.

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 09:40:15   #
Jeffcs Loc: Myrtle Beach South Carolina
 
Grew up on viewfinder still viewfinder

Reply
 
 
Jul 3, 2022 09:47:47   #
AzPicLady Loc: Behind the camera!
 
I use the viewfinder most of the time. Putting the camera to my face is part of my stabilization technique. However, I do use the screen when using a tripod and locking the mirror up. On my "baby" camera, I sometimes use the screen when shooting at an uncomfortable angle. One of my problems shooting with a cell phone is having to hold it away from my body. It's very difficult for me to get it steady! I wish cell phones came with a viewfinder!

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 09:54:46   #
Jimmy T Loc: Virginia
 
Just Fred wrote:
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 CX-format camera, which I bought as something of a transitional piece, having gone from 35mm SLR film, to an early Olympus battery-draining fixed-lens, 3 mpx handheld that was my entry point into digital photography. The Nikon 1 offered what I thought was the best of both worlds, a small form factor digital camera with interchangeable lenses. For a while, it became my camera of choice, although I never quite bonded with it the way I thought I should.

Part of this was the strange way Nikon forced one to power on the camera and then "unlock" the lens before shooting. OK, that was easy enough to adjust to, but the one thing that I could never ease into was using the LCD screen as the viewfinder.

My old 35mm SLRs (Minolta and Canon) both had through-the-lens metering and viewfinder systems where I could view and compose my shots, while using both hands to focus, set shutter speed and aperture opening. In a sense, I could do it all and still keep my attention on the subject.

When I finally moved to the Nikon D7xxx series, both LCD and viewfinder were available, and I never bother to use the screen for anything other than pre-shooting setup (I think Nikon may have earned enough ire from it's 1 customers to ultimately add an electronic viewfinder to the later models).

So, now I've pulled my old 1 out of mothballs, have added the 10-100mm autozoom lens which doesn't require either swapping lenses or the awkward rotation to start the process, and am thinking of finding out where this fits in my camera toolkit.

I'm still not comfortable using the LCD screen, and in some cases outdoors, the image is washed out by sunlight, but I'm wondering

a) Am I alone in preferring a viewfinder? I don't quite understand the difference between electronic and manual, but my eye in a cup seems to work.
b) How do those of you using the LCD make it work best for you? Are there tricks or tips I just don't know?
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 ... (show quote)


I rely on both for different tasks and conditions.
I also use both to "Chimp" in unusual or strange conditions.
The Canon R5 articulating viewfinder is a real boon when "just a viewfinder" can't or will not get the job done . . . like accommodating my +75 age.
So for me, photography is fun, and they both make me . . . .
Smile,
JimmyT Sends

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 10:04:38   #
GLSmith Loc: Tampa, Fl
 
If I'm shooting handheld, the viewfinder is normally what I use, however, if I am using a tripod, quite often my targets are 2-3 miles away (rocket launches), so the LiveView screen comes into play as I magnify the image to verify I have the sharpness needed. Using remnant fabric, my wife made a small drape with a hole in it. The hole fits over the top of my head & the camera body is underneath. As there is a lot of wind sometimes, she sewed in small fishing weights at the bottom. Definitely shortens the amount of time needed to fine focus & more importantly makes viewing the screen so much easier. ...Folded up, its small enough to tuck into my waste band or a side compartment on the camera case

Reply
Jul 3, 2022 10:39:02   #
bwana Loc: Bergen, Alberta, Canada
 
Just Fred wrote:
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 CX-format camera, which I bought as something of a transitional piece, having gone from 35mm SLR film, to an early Olympus battery-draining fixed-lens, 3 mpx handheld that was my entry point into digital photography. The Nikon 1 offered what I thought was the best of both worlds, a small form factor digital camera with interchangeable lenses. For a while, it became my camera of choice, although I never quite bonded with it the way I thought I should.

Part of this was the strange way Nikon forced one to power on the camera and then "unlock" the lens before shooting. OK, that was easy enough to adjust to, but the one thing that I could never ease into was using the LCD screen as the viewfinder.

My old 35mm SLRs (Minolta and Canon) both had through-the-lens metering and viewfinder systems where I could view and compose my shots, while using both hands to focus, set shutter speed and aperture opening. In a sense, I could do it all and still keep my attention on the subject.

When I finally moved to the Nikon D7xxx series, both LCD and viewfinder were available, and I never bother to use the screen for anything other than pre-shooting setup (I think Nikon may have earned enough ire from it's 1 customers to ultimately add an electronic viewfinder to the later models).

So, now I've pulled my old 1 out of mothballs, have added the 10-100mm autozoom lens which doesn't require either swapping lenses or the awkward rotation to start the process, and am thinking of finding out where this fits in my camera toolkit.

I'm still not comfortable using the LCD screen, and in some cases outdoors, the image is washed out by sunlight, but I'm wondering

a) Am I alone in preferring a viewfinder? I don't quite understand the difference between electronic and manual, but my eye in a cup seems to work.
b) How do those of you using the LCD make it work best for you? Are there tricks or tips I just don't know?
I recently remembered my old, original Nikon 1 J1 ... (show quote)

I normally use the viewfinder (and wish my smartphone had one).

I use the screen when I can't easily get in a position to see through the viewfinder and I definitely use it for focusing when astro-imaging.

Both have their value...

bwa

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 7 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.