Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Have advances in camera and lens technology made tripods obsolete?
Page <<first <prev 12 of 12
Apr 25, 2022 14:32:59   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
Nickaroo wrote:
I told him that the 800mm was a good Lens for Birding. He does get good shots for BIF's with His 90D, could he get the RF 100-500L and add a teleconverter? And if he goes with that Combo, would Autofocus still perform well? He told me that He just wants to build around this body, yet still have good Glass if He happens to, let's say, upgrade to a better and New Cycle of Canon Mirrorless Body's. Thanks for the input.


Reports are the various EOS R# bodies all can drive the 100-500L with either the RF 1.4x or the RF 2x. Probably best to use AI Servo (continuous AF) rather than single-shot, where the motor has to start/stop from a dead stop, leading to perceived sluggishness of the extended configuration.

Reply
Apr 25, 2022 15:07:47   #
Barbara Ruth Loc: St.Pete Beach, FL
 
I use my tripod for taking group shots that I want to be included in, using the self-timer on the camera (of course)

Reply
Apr 25, 2022 15:10:39   #
hrblaine
 
MDI Mainer wrote:
Christian Irmler, an Austrian landscape photographer and painter has written a thought-provoking piece for Fstoppers in which he argues that the current state-of-the-art in image stabilization and sensor performance at high ISOs may have made tripods obsolete. Fstoppers is an online community and resource which reaches 1.5 million photographers each month.

As he provocatively put it a tripod may have "become a relic from a time with poor technology." (He does acknowledge that a tripod is still necessary for focus stacking and can serve as a useful aid to thoughtful composition.)

Given the frequent (some might go so far as to say obsessive) discussion of tripods on UHH (to which I will plead guilty to some degree) I think the question merits further dialog.

My personal conclusion is that ponderously heavy, stable (and expensive tripods) are no longer the critical tool they once were, and that the still-useful functions of a tripod can be fulfilled by lighter and more portable.
Christian Irmler, an Austrian landscape photograp... (show quote)


When I started in photography over 50 years ago, after an examination of camera possibilities, I decided on 35mm because I did not want to be overburdened with equipment. One Nikon body with an 85mm lens was all I had, and I used it for everything: theatre, dance, bird dog field trials, landscapes, city scapes, people...everything. When I switched to digital, I started with a 40D but soon switched to full frame. And my lens collection grew. I started with a Canon nifty fifty, soon added a 70-300, then a 70-200 f4. Oh, and an extender. These remain the heart of my collection with the addition of a WA plus a few more zooms. Now, whenever I have a gas attack, I think of my old pal, Charlie Harbutt and his one Leica lens and keep my $$ in my pocket. I guess that I get more enjoyment from interacting with a puppy than with a lens. <g> So I'm much more apt to buy a $500.00 bird dog puppy than a camera lens! Harry

Reply
 
 
Apr 25, 2022 15:27:51   #
Fotoartist Loc: Detroit, Michigan
 
I have been taught to always buy the best and sturdiest tripod your spouse can carry. I think that's still relevant.

Reply
Apr 25, 2022 15:55:39   #
Soul Dr. Loc: Beautiful Shenandoah Valley
 
Fotoartist wrote:
I have been taught to always buy the best and sturdiest tripod your spouse can carry. I think that's still relevant.


I can't get my spouse to carry mine!

will

Reply
Apr 25, 2022 17:32:21   #
btbg
 
MDI Mainer wrote:
Christian Irmler, an Austrian landscape photographer and painter has written a thought-provoking piece for Fstoppers in which he argues that the current state-of-the-art in image stabilization and sensor performance at high ISOs may have made tripods obsolete. Fstoppers is an online community and resource which reaches 1.5 million photographers each month.

As he provocatively put it a tripod may have "become a relic from a time with poor technology." (He does acknowledge that a tripod is still necessary for focus stacking and can serve as a useful aid to thoughtful composition.)

Given the frequent (some might go so far as to say obsessive) discussion of tripods on UHH (to which I will plead guilty to some degree) I think the question merits further dialog.

My personal conclusion is that ponderously heavy, stable (and expensive tripods) are no longer the critical tool they once were, and that the still-useful functions of a tripod can be fulfilled by lighter and more portable gear.
Christian Irmler, an Austrian landscape photograp... (show quote)


Try blurring a waterfall without a tripod or star trails or most other night photography. There are still a multitude of situations with low light or long exposures that are nearly impossible without a tripod.

Reply
Apr 25, 2022 20:18:19   #
lightyear
 
I agree with Orphoto who said it well. \Also, the tripod increases the time to compose the image and in my case results in better images.
Stan

Reply
 
 
Apr 26, 2022 00:21:33   #
David in Dallas Loc: Dallas, Texas, USA
 
Although I understand the uses of a tripod, and that some applications require one to work properly, I don't travel with one. I travel with planned tours and there is typically no time on an excursion to set up, use, and take down a tripod, and many locations (inside churches, e.g.) don't permit them.

For photographers doing birding with very long lenses, professionals doing very critical composition and focusing, etc. I would agree that tripods are essential. For the typical traveler just documenting a tour, not so much. My D7100 with 18-200VR2 lens does just about everything I need, hand-held without a tripod.

Reply
Apr 26, 2022 10:02:55   #
anotherview Loc: California
 
In a few words, that's about the size of it.
David in Dallas wrote:
Although I understand the uses of a tripod, and that some applications require one to work properly, I don't travel with one. I travel with planned tours and there is typically no time on an excursion to set up, use, and take down a tripod, and many locations (inside churches, e.g.) don't permit them.

For photographers doing birding with very long lenses, professionals doing very critical composition and focusing, etc. I would agree that tripods are essential. For the typical traveler just documenting a tour, not so much. My D7100 with 18-200VR2 lens does just about everything I need, hand-held without a tripod.
Although I understand the uses of a tripod, and th... (show quote)

Reply
Apr 26, 2022 13:13:10   #
petrochemist Loc: UK
 
Fotoartist wrote:
I have been taught to always buy the best and sturdiest tripod your spouse can carry. I think that's still relevant.


I suspect this advice would be why some now consider tripods obsolete. :)
My wife could lift my heaviest tripod, but certainly wouldn't carry it far enough to be useful (neither can I) and she's often not available when I'm shooting low light....

When out shopping I'm more likely to end up being her pack horse than the other war round.

Reply
Apr 26, 2022 23:47:35   #
Nickaroo
 
CHG_CANON wrote:
Reports are the various EOS R# bodies all can drive the 100-500L with either the RF 1.4x or the RF 2x. Probably best to use AI Servo (continuous AF) rather than single-shot, where the motor has to start/stop from a dead stop, leading to perceived sluggishness of the extended configuration.

Thank You Paul, He has brand new TC's and 95% of the time He shoots AI Servo.

Reply
 
 
May 20, 2022 10:18:00   #
zarathu Loc: Bar Harbor, MDI, Maine
 
I agree with Imler mostly. Before purchasing a canon R5, I would not have agreed. However, for night sky photos or any time when you have to shoot below 1/125s, then a tripod is still necessary for sharp photos. At 73, I cannot hold the camera as still as I once could, regardless of IBIS or lens IS.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 12 of 12
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.