DirtFarmer wrote:
I am not convinced that filters protect lenses from impacts. If an impact breaks your filter you have a lot of sharp pieces of filter sitting on your lens. You could see damage as a result of cleaning the splinters off the lens.
I am convinced that filters protect lenses from low energy environmental hazards like blowing sand and salt spray. Impacts are another class of damage. After all, an impact could damage the threads on the lens and filter making it difficult to get the broken filter off the lens.
I still believe that a good hood or a lens cap offers better protection against impacts than a filter.
BUT my study shows that a filter won't do significant damage to the image.
My study was not intended to encourage you to use a filter as all-purpose protection without other protective devices.
I am not convinced that filters protect lenses fro... (
show quote)
Amen.
Whenever I hear impact damage included in the Great Filter Debate I simply remind myself that this is UHH and Red Herring is the menu for every meal, every day.
Altho a filter could protect against minor impact, impact protection is not a filter’s main protective function.