Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Compare Nikon's new NS Studio, Lightroom, and Corel After Shot Pro
Page 1 of 3 next> last>>
Mar 6, 2021 13:02:49   #
IDguy Loc: Idaho
 
Interested in observations from anyone who has tried at least two of above. I am proficient with Lightroom but just exploring the other two. At the moment I am preferring Lightroom but that is likely because I am proficient with it and don't know the other two yet.

Just downloaded NS Studio so least knowledgeable about it. The terminology differs so I can't yet figure out how to do some things like lower highlights and make local exposure adjustments. I expect it has those capabilities.

I most like the clarity and haze reduction and local adjustment features of Lightroom so will have to see if others can do the same.

Reply
Mar 6, 2021 13:12:11   #
Bob Mevis Loc: Plymouth, Indiana
 
I can't help as I use Photoshop. I am going to download the new studio and try it. I'm sure there will be plenty of answers coming up soon.

Reply
Mar 6, 2021 14:22:09   #
Brucej67 Loc: Cary, NC
 
I find it useful as NEF files are properly rendered in Nikon's software and then I use process in Other Apps to send it to Photoshop as TIFF files. NX Studio also uses U-Point technology just like the Nik collection. It lacks a DAM system like Lightroom has, but that is not a problem for me. For free software I have no complaints, if I had to purchase it I would not.

Reply
 
 
Mar 6, 2021 16:35:27   #
Drbobcameraguy Loc: Eaton Ohio
 
I don't use Lightroom but have used the Nikon software forever for simple raw development. If I need layers or more complicated things I use Luminar4 and Affinity Photo. I like the raw development of the Nikon software because it likes the camera files due to being built by and for them. I also like the Nik control points.

Reply
Mar 6, 2021 18:13:01   #
IDguy Loc: Idaho
 
Brucej67 wrote:
I find it useful as NEF files are properly rendered in Nikon's software and then I use process in Other Apps to send it to Photoshop as TIFF files. NX Studio also uses U-Point technology just like the Nik collection. It lacks a DAM system like Lightroom has, but that is not a problem for me. For free software I have no complaints, if I had to purchase it I would not.


Assume “it” is NS Studio?

What is “U-Point”?

What is DAM? ( Digital Asset Management? ) If so I kind of like the idea of not having to import to a catalog. I thought I saw NS Studio enables filtering and maybe keywording.

Reply
Mar 6, 2021 18:33:02   #
Drbobcameraguy Loc: Eaton Ohio
 
Dam or lack of Dam means you retain control of where your pics are. I prefere it. Many don't. Control points allow you to adjust contrast color brightness ect in a area defined by you quickly and easily without layers.

Reply
Mar 6, 2021 19:30:24   #
IDguy Loc: Idaho
 
Drbobcameraguy wrote:
Dam or lack of Dam means you retain control of where your pics are. I prefere it. Many don't. Control points allow you to adjust contrast color brightness ect in a area defined by you quickly and easily without layers.


Working with the help file to figure out how to do that. One thing I really like in Lightroom is the radial filter. I often use it on eyes. I also like the ability to reduce highlights and increase shadow exposures. Haven't found that yet in either of the alternatives.

Since the Nikon one is free many may like it. I'm sure it can do most of what needs to be done with some learning. It might have limitation with RAW files from other camera makes.

I also got Corel After Shot for "free" (with $1200 lens purchase from Adorama). It appears reasonable if you wanted to buy about...about the same as Adobe Photoshop Elements.

Reply
 
 
Mar 6, 2021 20:40:46   #
Drbobcameraguy Loc: Eaton Ohio
 
IDguy wrote:
Working with the help file to figure out how to do that. One thing I really like in Lightroom is the radial filter. I often use it on eyes. I also like the ability to reduce highlights and increase shadow exposures. Haven't found that yet in either of the alternatives.

Since the Nikon one is free many may like it. I'm sure it can do most of what needs to be done with some learning. It might have limitation with RAW files from other camera makes.

I also got Corel After Shot for "free" (with $1200 lens purchase from Adorama). It appears reasonable if you wanted to buy about...about the same as Adobe Photoshop Elements.
Working with the help file to figure out how to do... (show quote)


The new Nikon software will do shadows and highlights. Also curves and such for cold and light. Nik control points allow very good control of color brightness contrast ect in a defined by you area. Shadows and highlights are controlled by a slider in the same tad with the other exposure controls.

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 06:38:33   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
IDguy wrote:
Interested in observations from anyone who has tried at least two of above. I am proficient with Lightroom but just exploring the other two. At the moment I am preferring Lightroom but that is likely because I am proficient with it and don't know the other two yet.

Just downloaded NS Studio so least knowledgeable about it. The terminology differs so I can't yet figure out how to do some things like lower highlights and make local exposure adjustments. I expect it has those capabilities.

I most like the clarity and haze reduction and local adjustment features of Lightroom so will have to see if others can do the same.
Interested in observations from anyone who has tri... (show quote)


https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/54861210

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 08:52:28   #
StevenG Loc: Long Island, NY
 
IDguy wrote:
Interested in observations from anyone who has tried at least two of above. I am proficient with Lightroom but just exploring the other two. At the moment I am preferring Lightroom but that is likely because I am proficient with it and don't know the other two yet.

Just downloaded NS Studio so least knowledgeable about it. The terminology differs so I can't yet figure out how to do some things like lower highlights and make local exposure adjustments. I expect it has those capabilities.

I most like the clarity and haze reduction and local adjustment features of Lightroom so will have to see if others can do the same.
Interested in observations from anyone who has tri... (show quote)


I’m new to Nikon (just purchased a Z6ii) and know nothing about their software. Will it work as a plug in to LR and Ps?

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 10:08:41   #
CHG_CANON Loc: the Windy City
 
StevenG wrote:
I’m new to Nikon (just purchased a Z6ii) and know nothing about their software. Will it work as a plug in to LR and Ps?


No. The software works on the original Nikon specific RAW files. In a more complex and less efficient workflow, you would edit your NEF in the Nikon software and export that edited result as a 16-bit TIFF and then 'finish' the image in LR and / or PS. Canon's DPP software is the same workflow and functionality. The benefit is the vendor's software does a good to great job, just with less bells & whistles & bulk-image efficiency of commercial third-party software.

Reply
 
 
Mar 7, 2021 10:52:57   #
photoman43
 
IDguy wrote:
Interested in observations from anyone who has tried at least two of above. I am proficient with Lightroom but just exploring the other two. At the moment I am preferring Lightroom but that is likely because I am proficient with it and don't know the other two yet.

Just downloaded NS Studio so least knowledgeable about it. The terminology differs so I can't yet figure out how to do some things like lower highlights and make local exposure adjustments. I expect it has those capabilities.

I most like the clarity and haze reduction and local adjustment features of Lightroom so will have to see if others can do the same.
Interested in observations from anyone who has tri... (show quote)


I have downloaded Studdio, used it yeaterday and compared it to its previous products, Nikon View NX-i and Nikon Capture NX-D.

I love using its built in browser (former View NX-i) to quickly view and cull (delete) images that are not keepers. It renders in imbedded Jpeg in NEF files much faster than other programs I have used. And to delete an image it is a one step process. Just hit the delete key on a windows keyboard. I use it a lot as I have 1000-2000 images to go thru from a single day of shooting.

To process a NEF image you have most of the global adjustments available to you in other programs, but not all of them, like Clarity and Clearview, etc. It does have Control Points for local adjustments where you can adjust warmth, color and brightness for a portion of an image, like the face of a bird that needs a touch of light. This is maybe its best feature for a free raw processor. It will read all of the info you may have set in camera using Picture Controls. This is a big benefit if you are a Jpeg shooter of a RAW shooter if you do such adjustments in camera. The Control Point feature in DXO-PL4 is more powerful.

You can Crop, Straighten, and do Perspective Control. You can Export images(Tiffs or jpegs) to a file folder of your choice. And if the Tiff needs more work do that in LR or PS or another program.

Nikon uses NKSC as its sidecar files. It also allows info to be written to the file. Whether that written info is available to another program will have to be tested. Other programs will not read the NKSC data files. This is a feature I do not like, but that applies to almost all software of this type.

In my opinion, if you take mostly accurate images in camera, Studio might be the only program you will need. It comes with a pretty good on line Help function and a pdf version that can be downloaded. It is about 300 pages.

Download and try it out. Its Free.

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 11:05:50   #
IDguy Loc: Idaho
 
photoman43 wrote:
I have downloaded Studdio, used it yeaterday and compared it to its previous products, Nikon View NX-i and Nikon Capture NX-D.

I love using its built in browser (former View NX-i) to quickly view and cull (delete) images that are not keepers. It renders in imbedded Jpeg in NEF files much faster than other programs I have used. And to delete an image it is a one step process. Just hit the delete key on a windows keyboard. I use it a lot as I have 1000-2000 images to go thru from a single day of shooting.

To process a NEF image you have most of the global adjustments available to you in other programs, but not all of them, like Clarity and Clearview, etc. It does have Control Points for local adjustments where you can adjust warmth, color and brightness for a portion of an image, like the face of a bird that needs a touch of light. This is maybe its best feature for a free raw processor. It will read all of the info you may have set in camera using Picture Controls. This is a big benefit if you are a Jpeg shooter of a RAW shooter if you do such adjustments in camera. The Control Point feature in DXO-PL4 is more powerful.

You can Crop, Straighten, and do Perspective Control. You can Export images(Tiffs or jpegs) to a file folder of your choice. And if the Tiff needs more work do that in LR or PS or another program.

Nikon uses NKSC as its sidecar files. It also allows info to be written to the file. Whether that written info is available to another program will have to be tested. Other programs will not read the NKSC data files. This is a feature I do not like, but that applies to almost all software of this type.

In my opinion, if you take mostly accurate images in camera, Studio might be the only program you will need. It comes with a pretty good on line Help function and a pdf version that can be downloaded. It is about 300 pages.

Download and try it out. Its Free.
I have downloaded Studdio, used it yeaterday and ... (show quote)


Thanks. I’m working through the Help.

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 11:38:47   #
R.G. Loc: Scotland
 
IDguy wrote:
.....I also like the ability to reduce highlights and increase shadow exposures. Haven't found that yet in either of the alternatives.....


In NX Studio you use Highlight Protection and Shadow Protection. Active D-Lighting also applies a form of HDR adjustments dynamically.

Reply
Mar 7, 2021 15:24:56   #
DaveyDitzer Loc: Western PA
 
IDguy wrote:
Interested in observations from anyone who has tried at least two of above. I am proficient with Lightroom but just exploring the other two. At the moment I am preferring Lightroom but that is likely because I am proficient with it and don't know the other two yet.

Just downloaded NS Studio so least knowledgeable about it. The terminology differs so I can't yet figure out how to do some things like lower highlights and make local exposure adjustments. I expect it has those capabilities.

I most like the clarity and haze reduction and local adjustment features of Lightroom so will have to see if others can do the same.
Interested in observations from anyone who has tri... (show quote)


Joe Christina (Jchristina.com) just published a 20 minute You Tube review of Nikon Studio software. Very helpful.

Reply
Page 1 of 3 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.