CHG_CANON wrote:
Your contract language should cover this issue. Doesn't your contract speak to a range of a total number of images and services to be delivered? It would seem this request is outside the documented and agreed services and deliverables. If not, update your contract going forward. Or, use the other suggestion above and sell these additional images for a fixed fee, transferring them directly, not posting them along with the contracted deliverables.
Right on! He's got it!
I am not telling anyone what their policies should be- YOU the OP, has to decide what you want to stipulate on a wide range of issues as to the basics like price, schedule of payments, your rates and packages and the copyright aspects. You should also specify the disposition of so-called proofs, thumbnails, or whatever you want to call the complete choice of images you have submitted for selection.
I can tell you what I do. I simply NEVER submit defective, sub-standard, unflattering, or technically deficient images to a client. I don't usually get too many bloopers on a wedding coverage but Murphy's Law of wedding photography states that the client will select an out-of-focus, underexposed, and poorly composed image for a 30x40 portrait! Something that happened when the shutter release was accidently activated! Then they will ask you to frame and sign it! Bad as to "artistic integrity" and it's lousy PR!
The best way to preclude dissatisfied, argumentative, and disappointed clients is to spell out all your policies and explain your logical reason and benefits to the client for invoking your policies. If the client does not agree with your policies or methods, don't take on the job or you are asking for aggravation.
If I am in the midst of wedding reception and running and gunning a wild rock 'n' roll dance sequence and shooting 15 frames to grab a particular shot- who's counting? I'll pick the best to the sequence and cull the rest.
I'll shoot back up shots on formals and groups to avoid closed eyes and distracted expressions and edit out the misses. The client will still have a generous choice- closeups. 3/4 shots, full-face, profiles, 2/3 fill lengths and tons of action shots but the will be choosing out the best poses and candid sequences, not deciding whether to take a great shot or a failed image.
Again, in my own policies, I never have the client post-process, edit or print my work. It's artistic and business suicide! That's what thye pay me for! We explain in advance that the goal is to tell a comprehensive story of the day with all the romance, moods, celebration and fun and DESIGN an album that will be a joy to review over and over again. This puts everyone on a good cooperative trajectory. If you plan concisely, you will never have disagreements or misunderstandings with clients. If you do not plan and get everyone on the same page, you are walking into a minefield.
Of course, you can't simply adopt mine or anyone else's policies. You need to devise your own based on your experience and your clients' requirements. I am still kind of old school in that I produce WEDDING ALBUMS- in leather bindings with a minimum of 60 images. We have a separate video crew for folks who want that service and slideshows of stills are only sold accompanying album orders.