I agonized over this image in color - hated the sky, didn't like the contrasts, color tones all wonky, lighting all wrong, etc. So... rather than ditch the whole thing I gave it a shot in b&w and I think it turned out reasonably well. Barn and windmill near Kalispell, Montana on an overcast day.
EDIT NOTE: I have been informed that this is actually a sepia rendition. I am red/green color blind and that hampers me a bit, as I often don't see what others see in reddish and greenish tones... ** sigh **
First, I would change the title 'cause this is sepia
There is something about reddish-brown clouds and skies that doesn't appeal to me. Love the rest, though.
I have to agree with Linda; b&w and no toning is much better.
I’m the odd man out here as I like it.
Linda From Maine wrote:
First, I would change the title 'cause this is sepia
There is something about reddish-brown clouds and skies that doesn't appeal to me. Love the rest, though.
It's my cursed red - green color blindness. I cannot really see the red/brown that you all see, so I guess I need another pair of eyes before I post these...
It is very nicely composed no matter the tone.
It is very nicely composed no matter the tone.
Yes - I can understand why you agonised over this subject - which I think is exceptional. Your composition is a real winner. If it were my pic (which it isn't) I would want to do something with the sky and bring out the mountains a bit. If it's not too far from home I'd want to go back and do it again - and perhaps again - until the sky was less heavy. As I've said, that composition is a potential winner. I agree B&W woud be better than Sepia. I would also want to try subdued colours, and it is a picture that would be worth the effort.
tommystrat wrote:
It's my cursed red - green color blindness. I cannot really see the red/brown that you all see, so I guess I need another pair of eyes before I post these...
Sorry I keep forgetting that Tommy. I can't remember much of anything anymore, but if I forget to feed Trixie, she lets me know
This is one of the best sepia-themed images I've seen in a long time. However you arrived here, it's a masterpiece. Have you ever thought about adding a rough texture, lightly blended? It might give it an even more rustic look.
Bob sends ...... Keep smiling!
Great photo, Tommy. Love it in sepia and I'm sure I'd love it in B&W too because the scene a composition are outstanding. Sepia clouds don't bother me, because sepia is like laying a light brown filter over the B&W to get that period look that is appropriate for the scene. Outstanding!
Nice shot - mixed feelings on the sepia. Works, but wouldn't mind seeing a monochrome version.
I have read about eyeglasses that mitigate colorblindness - not cheap, but ...maybe worth a try.
tommystrat wrote:
It's my cursed red - green color blindness. I cannot really see the red/brown that you all see, so I guess I need another pair of eyes before I post these...
It wouldn't be difficult to desaturate it entirely. Then the color blindness wouldn't matter.
Linda From Maine wrote:
First, I would change the title 'cause this is sepia
There is something about reddish-brown clouds and skies that doesn't appeal to me. Love the rest, though.
Don't come to west Texas, then. We get lots of reddish-brown clouds. They're called dust storms. No fun, and we don't like them either. Tommystrat did do a good job though.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.