When stuff like this happens, I usually look for the money...... Somebody probably got a lot of money for publishing a paper debunking Pluto as a planet!
Welcome back Pluto!
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet. That article is from 2018. Although it would be nice to have a full-fledged planet named after a cartoon character, Pluto is tiny, and it has not cleared its orbit of debris. If it were larger, like a real planet, its gravity would have "vacuumed up" the smaller bits in its orbit. There are many objects roughly the size of Pluto. If we call Pluto a planet, we would have to add hundreds more to our list.
On the plus side, scientists have discovered another moon orbiting earth. It's only about the size of a car, with a very elliptical orbit, and it will probably leave earth orbit in April.
jerryc41 wrote:
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet. That article is from 2018. Although it would be nice to have a full-fledged planet named after a cartoon character, Pluto is tiny, and it has not cleared its orbit of debris. If it were larger, like a real planet, its gravity would have "vacuumed up" the smaller bits in its orbit. There are many objects roughly the size of Pluto. If we call Pluto a planet, we would have to add hundreds more to our list.
On the plus side, scientists have discovered another moon orbiting earth. It's only about the size of a car, with a very elliptical orbit, and it will probably leave earth orbit in April.
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet... (
show quote)
Classified by a small elite group. Who are they to say what is or is not a planet? Apparently they do NOT have a consensus.
So who cares what these clowns say about it not being a planet. There is a group that is far larger that says it is thus it is.
I tried to view it, but the #@^% ads kept blocking half the page and I couldn't find any way to get rid of them. They are so dang annoying! I finally just gave up.
jerryc41 wrote:
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet. That article is from 2018. Although it would be nice to have a full-fledged planet named after a cartoon character, Pluto is tiny, and it has not cleared its orbit of debris. If it were larger, like a real planet, its gravity would have "vacuumed up" the smaller bits in its orbit. There are many objects roughly the size of Pluto. If we call Pluto a planet, we would have to add hundreds more to our list.
On the plus side, scientists have discovered another moon orbiting earth. It's only about the size of a car, with a very elliptical orbit, and it will probably leave earth orbit in April.
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet... (
show quote)
In Astronomical terms October 2018 was just nano seconds ago. I still hold on to the fact it is a very small planet.
jerryc41 wrote:
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet. That article is from 2018. Although it would be nice to have a full-fledged planet named after a cartoon character, Pluto is tiny, and it has not cleared its orbit of debris. If it were larger, like a real planet, its gravity would have "vacuumed up" the smaller bits in its orbit. There are many objects roughly the size of Pluto. If we call Pluto a planet, we would have to add hundreds more to our list.
On the plus side, scientists have discovered another moon orbiting earth. It's only about the size of a car, with a very elliptical orbit, and it will probably leave earth orbit in April.
Sorry, but it's still classified as a dwarf planet... (
show quote)
The cartoon character was name after the planet, not the other way around.
Unless one is from Streator, Illinois (Clyde Tombaugh) I don't see this affecting anyone's life much. Although Mr. Tombaugh probably got more publicity out of the "controversy" than in the 60-80 years before.
FredCM wrote:
Unless one is from Streator, Illinois (Clyde Tombaugh) I don't see this affecting anyone's life much. Although Mr. Tombaugh probably got more publicity out of the "controversy" than in the 60-80 years before.
Actually Pluto was discovered by the Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, AZ.
Great visit and many photo ops there.
https://lowell.edu/the-story-of-pluto/
There is a picture of Clyde Tombaugh, and he's cited, on the top of page 1 on the right hand side. Tombaugh is from Streator, and the city is very proud of him.
Galileo recognized Pluto as a planet. Who needs more proof. And for what practical purpose does its category apply.
It was really a Mickey Mouse decision by a bunch of Goofy scientists to demote it
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.