Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Monopod
Page <prev 2 of 4 next> last>>
Jan 26, 2020 14:47:44   #
speters Loc: Grangeville/Idaho
 
HistoryLover wrote:
I am thinking of getting a monopod to make it easier when traveling. Was wondering if a 600mm lens would be too much for it to handle.


No, if you get a good one, no lens will be too much!

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 06:18:37   #
ChazT Loc: Florida
 
I have the Oben ACM-2400L 4-Section Aluminum Self-Standing Monopod with Mini-Legs and really like it. It supports my D850 with Tamron 150-600 free standing. I wouldn't walk away from it while balancing but it is convenient if you need to grab something. Make sure to pair whichever you choose with a solid head.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 06:54:20   #
SteveG Loc: Norh Carolina
 
LWW wrote:
Yep, I like to take DSLR+battery grip+Heaviest lens+monopod+head+at least 5 lbs and get something that matches that weight.

Look for strong leg adjustment clamps.

They are, IMHO, invaluable.

Additional uses are a walking stick and, in a pinch, critter defense.


And what about image stabilization while using a monopod, on or off?

Reply
 
 
Jan 27, 2020 07:03:30   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
HistoryLover wrote:
I am thinking of getting a monopod to make it easier when traveling. Was wondering if a 600mm lens would be too much for it to handle.


No, if the monopod is of sufficient quality and build, it should be able to handle it. I suggest you try it out before your trip.
Personally, I would not take a lens like this unless I was going to shot exclusively wildlife or birds, if not, I do not know why you would even take it.
A monopod is not good for birds in flight because birds change direction quickly and a monopod cannot keep up.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 07:21:35   #
SteveG Loc: Norh Carolina
 
billnikon wrote:
No, if the monopod is of sufficient quality and build, it should be able to handle it. I suggest you try it out before your trip.
Personally, I would not take a lens like this unless I was going to shot exclusively wildlife or birds, if not, I do not know why you would even take it.
A monopod is not good for birds in flight because birds change direction quickly and a monopod cannot keep up.


I have not used a monopod, but what would be it's actual application then? I find image stabilization to be pretty effective for my 300mm. Sounds like either you need a tripod or nothing?

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 07:36:02   #
scubadoc Loc: Sarasota, FL
 
SteveG wrote:
I have not used a monopod, but what would be it's actual application then? I find image stabilization to be pretty effective for my 300mm. Sounds like either you need a tripod or nothing?


There is a reason professional sports photographers use monopods. 500-600 mm lenses get very heavy during a 3 hour event. Monopods are used primarily for supporting the weight of the lens and secondarily for stabilization. Tripods are not allowed at pro sporting events.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 07:39:06   #
SteveG Loc: Norh Carolina
 
scubadoc wrote:
There is a reason professional sports photographers use monopods. 500-600 mm lenses get very heavy during a 3 hour event. Monopods are used primarily for supporting the weight of the lens and secondarily for stabilization. Tripods are not allowed at pro sporting events.


Gotcha! Thanks so much!

Reply
 
 
Jan 27, 2020 07:49:39   #
LWW Loc: Banana Republic of America
 
SteveG wrote:
And what about image stabilization while using a monopod, on or off?


I've heard both, my gut would tell be off because VR is looking to adjust movement. If there is no movement it tends to get a bit weird from what I've heard.

Plus, a tripod/monopod is in essence VR in and of itself.

Not to start a shiite storm, but Im olde skool and IMHO VR is a crutch for people who don't want to learn hand holding skills in most, but not all, cases.

I'm 63 and can get sharp still photos at about 1/30 on a 300 with a monopod ... minimal wind of course and non frigid temps ... and that's about what a VR 300 will do.

So, there are cases where it would be nice on a long lens, but fast gas IMHO is superior to VR once one has a good handheld skillset, which isn't rocket science.

With slower glass, and my walk around lens is a NIKKOR 18-200 ... also have a NIKKOR 80-200 2.8 non VR ... and the loss of 2 stops in speed makes VR helpful so I just leave it on except when on a tripod.

I would suggest someone invest in used mint or close to mint NIKKOR AF-D glass. I have seen a NIKKOR 300 f4 sell here more than once for under $500. Although it has some weight, it's also built like a tank ... and the 300 PF VR is about 4 times that.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 07:50:18   #
LWW Loc: Banana Republic of America
 
scubadoc wrote:
There is a reason professional sports photographers use monopods. 500-600 mm lenses get very heavy during a 3 hour event. Monopods are used primarily for supporting the weight of the lens and secondarily for stabilization. Tripods are not allowed at pro sporting events.


Troo dat.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 07:58:33   #
SteveG Loc: Norh Carolina
 
LWW wrote:
I've heard both, my gut would tell be off because VR is looking to adjust movement. If there is no movement it tends to get a bit weird from what I've heard.

Plus, a tripod/monopod is in essence VR in and of itself.

Not to start a shiite storm, but Im olde skool and IMHO VR is a crutch for people who don't want to learn hand holding skills in most, but not all, cases.

I'm 63 and can get sharp still photos at about 1/30 on a 300 with a monopod ... minimal wind of course and non frigid temps ... and that's about what a VR 300 will do.

So, there are cases where it would be nice on a long lens, but fast gas IMHO is superior to VR once one has a good handheld skillset, which isn't rocket science.

With slower glass, and my walk around lens is a NIKKOR 18-200 ... also have a NIKKOR 80-200 2.8 non VR ... and the loss of 2 stops in speed makes VR helpful so I just leave it on except when on a tripod.

I would suggest someone invest in used mint or close to mint NIKKOR AF-D glass. I have seen a NIKKOR 300 f4 sell here more than once for under $500. Although it has some weight, it's also built like a tank ... and the 300 PF VR is about 4 times that.
I've heard both, my gut would tell be off because ... (show quote)


It comes in handy for me because my once steady hand, is not as steady as it once was.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 08:03:02   #
Notorious T.O.D. Loc: Harrisburg, North Carolina
 
You can likely go with a spike foot. Really Right Stuff sells them...as do others.

LWW wrote:
Perhaps I will check if BOGEN offers a hellfire missile upgrade.

Reply
 
 
Jan 27, 2020 08:09:07   #
ltatko
 
At 85 -- Need a steady hand. The Monopod is great help!!


LenT

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 08:13:18   #
LWW Loc: Banana Republic of America
 
SteveG wrote:
It comes in handy for me because my once steady hand, is not as steady as it once was.


I hear that.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 08:30:43   #
Larryshuman
 
If your using a Nikon 600mm F:4 then I don't recommend it. Its like a concrete block on your Monopod head. But if your using the new Cannon 600mmF:4III then it might work.

Reply
Jan 27, 2020 09:26:26   #
imagemeister Loc: mid east Florida
 
HistoryLover wrote:
I am thinking of getting a monopod to make it easier when traveling. Was wondering if a 600mm lens would be too much for it to handle.


If it is 600 f4 then you do need to be cautious in getting a very substantial pod and head. If one of the 150-600 zooms, the requirements are not so stringent. Many people use monopods with 600mm's. In the interest of strength, I have converted a STEEL cargo stabilizer into a monopod for my biggest lenses. I do not know of anyone making a steel pod commercially.

The head you choose will be critical too. I have and use a Manfro 502 video/fluid head that I would suggest if you are talking about an f4 version. For smaller lenses I like the Sirui VH-10 video/fluid on my monopod.
.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 4 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.