Has anyone used these new tripods...either aluminum or carbon? If so, what are the pros and cons in actual field use?
gsmith051 wrote:
Do they have a name?
Peak Design, I think she said.
gsmith051 wrote:
Do they have a name?
Yes, Peak Design . . . one comes in aluminum and one in carbon fiber...wanted to have opinions from the field from a very credible group rather than reading the reviews from anonymous people.
Kmgw9v wrote:
Peak Design, I think she said.
Thank you Kmgw9v! I should have added the name in the body of the message instead of just relying on the title...
Wow! I own an older Manfrotto (doesn't have the name BeFree on it but it does have the the same colors) travel carbon tripod...am going to Iceland the end of February 2020.
I wanted a tripod that had those feet with "nails" that could dig into the ice. BeFree doesn't seem to have them as an accessory.
The sales guy in the local photo shop sold me a heavier forged aluminum tripod with the feet that will allow you to twist and the "nails" appear. (I just don't know what the "nails" are called. First time needing them in over 50 years!) he said I needed the forged aluminum given it was heavier for the winter weather. It also has the hook so I can hang my case off of it for steadiness. The brand is Sirui T-2005X.
Hopefully, it will work as expected. Thank you for sending the link! While Peak Design may/may not be a great tripod, for the money, it won't work for me. Now I know for sure and will be able to resist!
Really Right Stuff sells different feet and probably others do as well. I suspect the feet probably use a fairly common thread also. I can’t comment on the Peak Design tripods however.
Linda S. wrote:
Wow! I own an older Manfrotto (doesn't have the name BeFree on it but it does have the the same colors) travel carbon tripod...am going to Iceland the end of February 2020.
I wanted a tripod that had those feet with "nails" that could dig into the ice. BeFree doesn't seem to have them as an accessory.
The sales guy in the local photo shop sold me a heavier forged aluminum tripod with the feet that will allow you to twist and the "nails" appear. (I just don't know what the "nails" are called. First time needing them in over 50 years!) he said I needed the forged aluminum given it was heavier for the winter weather. It also has the hook so I can hang my case off of it for steadiness. The brand is Sirui T-2005X.
Hopefully, it will work as expected. Thank you for sending the link! While Peak Design may/may not be a great tripod, for the money, it won't work for me. Now I know for sure and will be able to resist!
Wow! I own an older Manfrotto (doesn't have the na... (
show quote)
47greyfox
Loc: on the edge of the Colorado front range
Just a personal thought, I think the PD travel tripod is uber expensive for what you get and not robust to support heavy body/lens combination. Yeah, it’s small and easy to pack but there’s a cost (skinny legs). And then there’s that cost thing again.....
The nails are called "spikes" and many Manfrotto tripods have retracting rubber feet that you can then allow the spikes to protrude, or screw in the foot so only rubber touches the floor you are setting the tripod on. You may also want to consider "snow feet" which have a circular disc, with a spike in the center often, That way you have more stable feet in snow or ice? Manfrotto used to sell those as a user installed option for their tripods as well.
FYI everyone. The Peak Design Travel Carbon tripod
https://www.peakdesign.com/collections/tripods isn't shipping to March 2020 and the price is $349.00. I saw a post on UHH where it was shown being packing in small camera bag. However, none of the normal suppliers, Hunt Photo, B&H, or Amazon had them listed. I Googled and found the exact description but shipping out of Hong Kong for only $39.95. I emailed Peak Design and reply stated that the site I found them at was a Fake/Spam site and they did not have product to sell or ship. It looks great, looks functional for up to 20lbs, but for $349 I think NOT.
you can add spikes feet to a PD tripod. I have the alum. tripod and see no advantages for the CF for the cost difference.
I have the carbon fiber Peak Design Travel tripod. While I was waiting for it, I got a Wimberly gimble head and a Sony 200-600 lens. This is some seriously heave stuff to put on a travel tripod BUT it handles it perfectly. I see no difference in stability in my heavy carbon fiber I have used for years. I love this thing! I haven't tried the neat little included ball head because I'm so hooked on the freedom of movement of the Wimberly head.
Really like mine. It's the aluminum one. I've only had it a week but am well impressed with its design and functionality. The ball head is a new design that requires a twist of a ring to have total motion control. Excellent quick release and lock for arca swiss plates. Solid build with no wiggle. The size is small when packed. Great carry bag. I believe I will continue to be very happy with it in the coming years.
I have been very happy with the Sirui A 1205 carbon fiber, $ 209 at B&H. Wt. 2,2 lb, max height 55.1", minimum ht. 10.2" and 22 lb. load capacity. It folds to a compact 14.6". Center column hook to add weight and one leg detaches to become a monopod. Arca type compatible Y-11 ball head. The legs are twist tighten which takes longer to set-up than the flip type but most flip types are plastic which can and has broken.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.