Dalbon wrote:
Since I know absolutely nothing about the Tamron lens I have a question about them. How is the Tamron 16-300 Di; II; PZD VC lens when shooting with the Nikon D-800 camera??? I kind of figured on this mainly because it is a 3.5 - 6.3 instead of the 5-6.3 with the 150-600 lens and besides it's a little big for me to be carrying around all day long.
Appreciate your help, David
Nikon D800 is a full frame (FX) camera.
Tamron 16-300mm is a crop only (Di II) lens.
On D800 the images will either be automatically cropped to DX format or will show heavy vignetting that requires similar manual cropping later in post-processing...
Either way, instead of making 36MP FX images, every image you make with that lens on that camera will end upwith approx. 15MP DX images... Not terrible, but lower resolution than current DX camera models such as D7500 (21MP) or D7200/D5600/D3500 (24MP). Sort of a waste of the money spent on an FX camera, to "cripple" it with a DX lens that basically makes the D800 inferior to a less expensive DX camera.
Your best bet is probably the Nikkor 28-300mm FX lens, if you must use a "do everything zoom".
Alternatively, depending upon what other lenses you already have, you might consider a different lens. For example, if you already have a 24-120mm Nikkor as a "walk around" lens, you might add the compact Nikkor 300mm f/4 "PF" to your kit... or the less compact Nikkor 300mm f/4 ED IF. You may be able to use those lenses with a 1.4X teleconverter, too, if you need longer (420mm effective).
Nikkor 300mm "PF" is small and light, about 1.66 lb.
Nikkor 300mm f/4 ED IF is about 3.2 lb. and doesn't have image stabilization.
Tamron 150-600mm "G2" is about 4.4 lb.
Sigma 150-600mm "C" (contemporary) weighs 4 lb.
Yes, both those 150-600mm are both larger diameter and longer than the prime lenses.
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/compare/Nikon_AF-S_NIKKOR_300mm_f_4E_PF_ED_VR_Lens_vs_Nikon_AF-S_NIKKOR_300mm_f_4D_IF-ED_Lens_vs_Tamron_SP_150-600mm_f_5-6.3_Di_VC_USD_G2_for_Nikon_F_vs_Sigma_150-600mm_f_5-6.3_DG_OS_HSM_Contemporary_Lens_for_Nikon_F/BHitems/1111442-REG_207356-GREY_1277357-REG_1082155-REG