rehess wrote:
but from our perspective, the question should be which phone provides the best photography experience.
The top phones' cameras are all really good now. For me, buying a $250 to $1500 "phone" is about upgrading a wide range of features. I buy a new phone NOT JUST for the camera, but because my old battery is weak, or it's no longer supported with the latest iOS (which means it is not secure!), or there is some compelling feature or feature set that I "just gotta have." My current iPhone is fast enough and has enough features that I actually use, that I'm content with it. The 2020 iPhone might interest me, depending upon how good 5G turns out to be in my area. By then, my battery might be going. Of course, a visit to iFixIt.com for a $30.00 tools and battery kit and instructions might cure that GAS.
I probably use 40 different apps on a regular basis. My phone is a radio, a cable TV, an Internet movie player, a music player, a level, a compass, a mapping/GPS device, an audio recording device, a FAX machine, a barcode scanner, a flashlight, and a lot more tools like web browser, email client, and camera. Some of those applications are at least as important to me as the cameras.
If another app comes along that my current phone won't run, and I "just gotta have that," I'll upgrade. (EVERY phone company wants to find a new and unique "killer app" that runs only on their latest hardware.)
I buy a new *iPhone* for the same reasons I drive Toyotas, use a Mac for most computing, and use Adobe CC Photography Plan... They're brands I know, find reliable and useful, and have an operating comfort level with. Most people I know stick with a mix of brands they're happy with... They leverage their knowledge.