Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Airline carry on issue
Page <prev 2 of 7 next> last>>
Sep 13, 2019 06:05:56   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Call the airline direct and ask. yes, it is that easy.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 06:49:41   #
Architect1776 Loc: In my mind
 
Peterff wrote:
Are you traveling alone? If not you can share the carry on / under seat options? Gate checking is a good option, since you check your stuff at the gate, and collect it when you get off the plane. I've found it safe and trustworthy. Soft cases for your lenses could work.

Good luck


I fly out of Williamsport and check at gate because of restrictions
So far in 12 years no problems with loss or damage upon arrival at Philly.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 07:01:35   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
rehess wrote:
Surely women can carry handbags - what can men carry?


Manbags.

Reply
 
 
Sep 13, 2019 07:03:10   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
That's lousy! I would bring a compact camera with a decent zoom.

I once flew in a small plane from Boston to NH. When I checked in, they weighed me to decide where I would sit. Their telephone was the pay phone on the wall. In one conversation, they asked the pilot when he thought he would get there. I had no luggage, but some people had to leave their luggage for the next flight because the plane's "trunk" filled quickly. The pilots looked like they were in high school. Interesting situation.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 07:08:59   #
trackmag
 
Driving from SF is your best option. Lots of good things to shoot along the way.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 07:12:18   #
ggenova64
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Good Morning
Can you carry the bag as a Carry On?

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 07:35:29   #
spraguead Loc: Boston, MA
 
United's lowest fares are limited to "no carry on". Usually you can pay a fee to add the carry on, or you can pay a fee for luggage (having equipment in a larger case).

Call them and inquire.

Reply
 
 
Sep 13, 2019 07:39:17   #
alandg46 Loc: Boerne, Texas
 
Several years ago we were returning home via a commuter plane from Albany, NY connecting to a flight at Newark. I keep my camera gear in a backpack stuffed inside a roll-on sized for carry-on. I was told that it would have to be checked. I voiced my concern to a flight attendant. He understood and took my carry-on and personally loaded it in the luggage compartment. Then when we landed he hurried down and got my carry-on off first and delivered it to me. I was impressed and very grateful. The carry-on had my Nikon D800E and D500 along with 24-120 F4, 200-500, 16-35mm, and 70-200mm.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 07:53:08   #
billt1970 Loc: Gambrills, Maryland
 
btbg wrote:


If United allows that it stops the problems with theft. When you get off the plane in Las Vegas there will then be a cart with all of the carry-ons on it right by the plane and you just pick yours up. If United does something similar then all you have to do is make sure it is packed securely.


I had a very similar problem yesterday when flying from Chicago to Little Rock, AK on a smaller plane after getting to Chicago from Baltimore on a 737.

I have a Think Tank airport bag that handles all my gear plus a laptop. As I was getting ready to board I noticed the gate agent tagging passenger’s larger carry-on bag. My problem with that was two fold: First the security of my gear; and second the significant risk of danger from all of the LiOn batteries that may NOT be placed in aircraft holds for fear of them starting a fire. Curiosly the gate attendant hadn’t even thought of that problem! So, since it was physically impossible to carry the bag onboard, I set about collecting and removing the LiOn batteries.

The three batteries for my DSLR were obvious, as was the laptop battery (I took the whole laptop with me). Then, the more I thought about it, there were others to be dealt with. I ended up removing three small specialty cameras (with built-in batteries) plus three batteries used for charging my electronic suite. In all it was about a dozen battery devices. Better safe than sorry that I might have left something behind that could have caught fire and caused my plane to crash!

I will be planning ahead for my return trip, where the outgoing flight will have similar carry-on restrictions. This is what btbg noted in his/her post. The suggestion is that we bring our bags to the gate, but be prepared to remove all potentially dangerous batteries and carry them on the aircraft. I believe that the theft risk in this scenario is minimal.

My real concern is the apparent lack of awareness of the potential problem by the gate attendant. I will be writing to United to have them be more careful in the future raking into consideration the issue of LiOn batteries when gate checking passenger bags.

Best Regards,

Bill Taylor
Gambrills, MD

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 08:06:51   #
Bazbo Loc: Lisboa, Portugal
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Either ship the gear or buy insurance.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 08:22:36   #
coolhanduke Loc: Redondo Beach, CA
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Did you buy a cheap ticket that does not allow carry on? Ive traveled a lot and never saw that. But then again, i think you said it was United. You may call the airlines fir clarification.

Even on commuter planes they will take the bag at the gste and put it in the belly of the plane, aside from checked bags.

Reply
 
 
Sep 13, 2019 08:28:43   #
mizzee Loc: Boston,Ma
 
I’ve done a trip such as yours with all my gear and I’ll tell you it became a PITA very quickly. Think long and hard about all the stuff you’re taking. On our 6 week trip out west, I found that my 16-85 lens was on the camera 95% of the time. The other 5% was a 10-20. If you expect wildlife then add whichever light weight zoom lens. After that trip, I switched to micro 4/3s and never looked back.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 08:28:48   #
Kobuk Loc: Roseville, CA
 
spraguead wrote:
United's lowest fares are limited to "no carry on". Usually you can pay a fee to add the carry on, or you can pay a fee for luggage (having equipment in a larger case).

Call them and inquire.


This is correct it does not have anything to do with smaller plane United Sucks! you have to pay more to take a carry on

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 09:01:18   #
Jack47 Loc: Ontario
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Call the airline. They may allow a personal item.

Reply
Sep 13, 2019 09:17:13   #
Strange
 
splatbass wrote:
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a two week RV trip. I am taking a two cameras, and three or four lenses. It didn't say anything when I booked the flight, but the itinerary they sent (United) says no carry on bags probably due to a small plane from SFO to LAS. So I'm not sure what to do now. Cancel and pay the cancellation fee? Gate check backpack in carry on suitcase? Check a pelican case and risk theft? None of these options are ideal. It is a once in a lifetime kind of trip, with stops at national parks, etc., including the elk rut at Rocky Mountain NP, so it is essential I take my gear (photography is one of the prime reasons for the trip). I can take a personal item (I have a messenger bag that holds a camera and two small lenses), but the telephotos needed for wildlife won't fit.

Any advice?
I booked a flight to Las Vegas from Honolulu for a... (show quote)


Number One - I don't fly United. Poor experiences in the past with that carrier.
Number Two - Watch a couple of light hearted YouTube videos about the experiences of a Canadian Band that flew United Airlines. Google: united breaks guitars

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 7 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.