Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Third Party TTL Flashheads - there are almost a dozen out there - which is best?
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
Mar 17, 2019 18:08:25   #
ChristianHJensen
 
E.L.. Shapiro wrote:
OK- Thanks for the information- I didn't see those specs in the ads from B&H and others. That helps the point was trying to make. It's about shopping for a flash unit and making certain to read into the specifications. So...going by those guide numbers, the Metz units are not all that much more powerful than some of the less expensive units. The retailers should not publish misleading guide numbers but tell the whole story. Not everyone is going to use their flash with long lenses. German build and engineering? No doubts- I have some old Metz (401) units from the 1960s and they still work.

Folks are assuming that the name amera brand flash units are superior to the third party units. I won't swear to it but I suspect that some of the big brand speedlights are made in the same factories as the lower priced units. Many also assume that some of the Chineses imported brands won't hold up in demanding work like wedding photography- may be so, but have the ever tried to use one of those units in heavy duty usage or long duty cycles- they may hold up very well. So, for someone who is not going to put that kind of mileage on a flash unit or system, the lower priced ones my last a lifetime.

Since this thread is about being a kind buying guide advisory- I'm just sticking in my 2 cents. I do understand though. As a long-time wedding shooter I always went for overkill. Most of my flash gear could survive in a war zone but some of the lighter duty stuff can still work well in less strenuous conditions.

Plumbers-$$- Yeah, I'm in the wrong business! Those guys charge more than brain surgeons. Well, we don't argue price when the house is floating away or the drains are backing up! I do agree that the crazy tape is not effective for the main riser pipe in the house- too much pressure! There is that TV commercial with a guy sawing his boat in half and repairing it with that stuff. I ain't gonna saw my boat in half anytime soon and if I had had the insane inclination to do that, I would not tape it back together again and go out on the water.

Kindest regards!
OK- Thanks for the information- I didn't see thos... (show quote)


No worries. Sure specs can be misleading. I would be quite certain that the Metz and Profoto flashes live up to their numbers - the Chinese brands - not so sure. In addition i would bet money on the consistency, color temp adherence, thermal protection, etc is superior from those two compared to the cheaper brands.
That being said - I fully understand the urge to save $$$ and for the hobbyist that may make a lot of sense as the potential loss of $$$ when some equipment malfunctions (always happens at the most inopportune time - go Murphy) is limited compared to a wedding/news/sports photographer missing THE moment

Reply
Mar 17, 2019 18:41:45   #
Chris T Loc: from England across the pond to New England
 
E.L.. Shapiro wrote:
OK- Thanks for the information- I didn't see those specs in the ads from B&H and others. That helps the point was trying to make. It's about shopping for a flash unit and making certain to read into the specifications. So...going by those guide numbers, the Metz units are not all that much more powerful than some of the less expensive units. The retailers should not publish misleading guide numbers but tell the whole story. Not everyone is going to use their flash with long lenses. German build and engineering? No doubts- I have some old Metz (401) units from the 1960s and they still work.

Folks are assuming that the name amera brand flash units are superior to the third party units. I won't swear to it but I suspect that some of the big brand speedlights are made in the same factories as the lower priced units. Many also assume that some of the Chineses imported brands won't hold up in demanding work like wedding photography- may be so, but have the ever tried to use one of those units in heavy duty usage or long duty cycles- they may hold up very well. So, for someone who is not going to put that kind of mileage on a flash unit or system, the lower priced ones my last a lifetime.

Since this thread is about being a kind buying guide advisory- I'm just sticking in my 2 cents. I do understand though. As a long-time wedding shooter I always went for overkill. Most of my flash gear could survive in a war zone but some of the lighter duty stuff can still work well in less strenuous conditions.

Plumbers-$$- Yeah, I'm in the wrong business! Those guys charge more than brain surgeons. Well, we don't argue price when the house is floating away or the drains are backing up! I do agree that the crazy tape is not effective for the main riser pipe in the house- too much pressure! There is that TV commercial with a guy sawing his boat in half and repairing it with that stuff. I ain't gonna saw my boat in half anytime soon and if I had had the insane inclination to do that, I would not tape it back together again and go out on the water.

Kindest regards!
OK- Thanks for the information- I didn't see thos... (show quote)


Yup!!! … I wouldn't do that, either, Ed. Guess he was just making a point about how strong FlexTape is!

And, in the overview - he looks like he's miles away from everyone and everything - huh? … If that tape pulled apart, and the boat collapsed, he'd probably drown before that chopper could get down to him!

I suspect that boat was put back together with something more than just FlexTape - dont'chathink, Ed?

Reply
Mar 17, 2019 18:45:17   #
Chris T Loc: from England across the pond to New England
 
ChristianHJensen wrote:
No worries. Sure specs can be misleading. I would be quite certain that the Metz and Profoto flashes live up to their numbers - the Chinese brands - not so sure. In addition i would bet money on the consistency, color temp adherence, thermal protection, etc is superior from those two compared to the cheaper brands.
That being said - I fully understand the urge to save $$$ and for the hobbyist that may make a lot of sense as the potential loss of $$$ when some equipment malfunctions (always happens at the most inopportune time - go Murphy) is limited compared to a wedding/news/sports photographer missing THE moment
No worries. Sure specs can be misleading. I woul... (show quote)


That Murphy has a nasty habit of popping up at the most inopportune moments - eh, Christian?

But, fear of old Murphy - shouldn't deter one from wanting to save the most money, they can …

Reply
 
 
Mar 17, 2019 18:53:52   #
ChristianHJensen
 
Chris T wrote:
That Murphy has a nasty habit of popping up at the most inopportune moments - eh, Christian?

But, fear of old Murphy - shouldn't deter one from wanting to save the most money, they can …


I agree - if the choice is made knowing that the reliability may be a bit lower than the best and, I bet, will not last nearly as long

Reply
Mar 17, 2019 19:17:07   #
Chris T Loc: from England across the pond to New England
 
ChristianHJensen wrote:
I agree - if the choice is made knowing that the reliability may be a bit lower than the best and, I bet, will not last nearly as long


Christian - my array of flash units include a half-dozen Vivitar 283s, along with a 285HV … don't remember how much I paid for them all - and they all still work fine - some 40 years later, but I do remember how much I paid for my Rollei E36RE … it was almost $500 with a second NiCad. I thought that thing would last me - forever. But, unfortunately - that's NOT the case. Right now, it's a relic - just taking up space!!!!!

And a Mecablitz (Metz) I have - a small fold-over unit … I used to use with my RB, when it was needed - is now - dead in the water, too. So, going with a Godox, or a Nissin, or a Bolt, or a Phottix, or a Yongnuo - makes a lot more sense to me, right now … than holding out, until I can afford a Metz, or a Profoto ….

Reply
Mar 21, 2019 16:17:55   #
topcat Loc: Alameda, CA
 
I just got a good flash on eBay for my Sony for a great price. A Neewer NW880s with a Neewer N1t radio controller.
Works great. Of course' it took me a while to lean it, the manuals are not that good, but youtube has quite a few videos on them. It is just a rebranded Yougno.

Reply
Mar 21, 2019 16:45:02   #
Chris T Loc: from England across the pond to New England
 
topcat wrote:
I just got a good flash on eBay for my Sony for a great price. A Neewer NW880s with a Neewer N1t radio controller.
Works great. Of course' it took me a while to lean it, the manuals are not that good, but youtube has quite a few videos on them. It is just a rebranded Yougno.


Does it work with the new Multi-Interface Shoe, used on the a58 and a77 II - or only on the older hot-shoe used on the a77 and the Minolta and Konica cameras, Topcat?


Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.