abc1234 wrote:
Why you want to do this baffles me.
Different strokes ... for me, I only moved from film to digital for volume/work flow reasons. When my kids were playing sports, I was the team photog/web master. Digital was the only real option, so I went that way (D70s & D200). I currently have nice digital gear - D500 & X-T2 with related lenses. I still prefer to shoot my F100 or M645. The difference, for me, is shooting a camera versus shooting a computer. I find that when I am shooting digital the convenience of having too much info, especially with the EVF, let’s me be lazy. The M645 is manual everything. If I get the shot, it’s because I thought through all the aspects and made decisions. If I am looking at a histogram in the WYSIWYG EVF, while that is convenient, it takes away some of the ownership of the result. Chimping with a DSLR is much the same.
abc1234 wrote:
I loved film and the darkroom but except for many fond memories and the great education they gave me, digital is so much better.
“So much better” is a subjective assessment. For you it may be so while for others, not so much. If a digital-only workflow floats your boat, great. Other’s boats may float differently.
abc1234 wrote:
Let us suppose for a moment that you decide film gives a better result by whatever criteria you have, are you really willing to drop digital and go back to film?
Why does this have to be a binary choice? I shoot digital, hybrid (film & scan) and full darkroom. Which I chose has to do with what is being shot and the result I am looking for.
abc1234 wrote:
Contrary to one suggestion, I would not scan a print or a negative. If you shoot film, then print film. Otherwise, your interpretation of the results will be frustratingly ambiguous.
I am not sure why what you would do necessarily dictates what others should do. You don’t want a hybrid work flow, ok, don’t use one. I’m fine with that. There are times where such a workflow make sense to others. If it’s all about the final image, who cares how you get there? I agree that if you are trying to figure out the darkroom, comparing a scanned & processed image can be frustrating, but then again, if that is your vision, having such a print on the darkroom wall gives you a bogey and challenges you to figure out how to get there.
In the end, shoot what you like and process the images how you like. Heck, some folks even shoot digital and print in the darkroom.