Cany143 wrote:
Mainly due to your suggestion, O Minty One, and partly out of curiosity, I did a B&W conversion of the first image. Don't think its horrible, but.... it looks like an image that was seen first in color then later converted to B&W. I didn't do what should rightly have been done, i.e., I didn't start from scratch from the raw file, and even with a few local adjustments made to the version I posted, the attached re-do still has technical flaws that could've been eliminated. Biggest problem is its lack of crispness, and the lens I used (I found in testing) lacks that. Ordinarily we --or at least I-- expect to see large format style crispness in a B&W print, and this image doesn't measure up, no matter what is done to it tonally. Color is often more forgiving than B&W generally is; the brain makes allowances that the eye refuses let slip past.
Mainly due to your suggestion, O Minty One, and pa... (
show quote)