Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
I gave non-advice to new photographer
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
Aug 8, 2018 02:22:28   #
paulrph1 Loc: Washington, Utah
 
Davethehiker wrote:
A young early twenty's couple from church asked me for advice about buying a camera. They had seen some of my work and my big full frame camera and asked me for advice about buying a camera. They do not have a lot of money and their first baby is about to turn one. Someone had given them a price on used Nikon. I looked the price up on eBay and told her it was not a bargain.

I then told her that she must ask herself why she wants a camera. It was to photograph her baby. I suggested that she buy a small camera that will fit in her purse. I explained to her that cameras are getting better all the time and camera years are like "dog years". What ever camera she buys will out-dated and old in a couple of years. I also suggested that an iPhone might be good enough.

The thought occurred to me to sell her one of my small very good cameras for a very good price and buy myself the latest model. I decided that was a bad idea because she would be constantly asking me how to use it.

Giving someone camera advice is as bad fixing someone up with a date. Unless they quickly fall in love, marry, have beautiful children and live happily ever after, it's going to be your fault. I told her to go to a discount store like Sam's Club play with the cameras they have on display and buy the one that appeals to her.

What would have you told her?
A young early twenty's couple from church asked me... (show quote)


Some on here have suggested you should tell her to buy a cellphone. While that might seem like a good idea from a photography standpoint the photography part will be the end but it is just the beginning of the payment for those monthly phone charges which to me are excessive. That is why I do not own one. You did mention she was on a limited budget. Right? I would say that the advice you gave her was correct. Not only were you wise but you were compassionate not to sell her your old equipment.

Reply
Aug 8, 2018 07:12:21   #
leftj Loc: Texas
 
paulrph1 wrote:
Some on here have suggested you should tell her to buy a cellphone. While that might seem like a good idea from a photography standpoint the photography part will be the end but it is just the beginning of the payment for those monthly phone charges which to me are excessive. That is why I do not own one. You did mention she was on a limited budget. Right? I would say that the advice you gave her was correct. Not only were you wise but you were compassionate not to sell her your old equipment.
Some on here have suggested you should tell her to... (show quote)


I’m sure she probably already has a cell phone.

Reply
Aug 8, 2018 07:45:50   #
paulrph1 Loc: Washington, Utah
 
leftj wrote:
I’m sure she probably already has a cell phone.

you might be and are probably correct. It seems backwards these days where people insist one having the luxuries and want some one else to buy their needs for them. But that is another story.

Reply
 
 
Aug 8, 2018 07:58:20   #
Davethehiker Loc: South West Pennsylvania
 
paulrph1 wrote:
You did mention she was on a limited budget. Right? I would say that the advice you gave her was correct. Not only were you wise but you were compassionate not to sell her your old equipment.


It's no much that I'm being compassionate so much as carefully protecting my own interests. There is a high likelihood that they might have buyers remorse if I sold them one of my cameras.

The husband of this couple is about six four of solid muscle. I have hired him to do chores around my house that I'm currently unable to do. I'm currently recovering from chemotherapy that has left me very weak. I have hired him to clear cut a mile of trail in the woods on my property, using my powered brush hog. A lot of people would not be able to do this kind of work. Next month he is going to dig some post holes for me. I like having this big farm boy available to do things that I'm no longer able to do myself. I deliberately slightly overpay him to make sure he will do chores when I need help.

I like to hike that trail with my camera and take photos of wild life and such. Walking the shaded trail in the woods is a form of exercise that I enjoy doing.

Young Buck on my trail
Young Buck on my trail...
(Download)

Reply
Aug 8, 2018 08:21:24   #
paulrph1 Loc: Washington, Utah
 
Davethehiker wrote:
It's no much that I'm being compassionate so much as carefully protecting my own interests. There is a high likelihood that they might have buyers remorse if I sold them one of my cameras.

The husband of this couple is about six four of solid muscle. I have hired him to do chores around my house that I'm currently unable to do. I'm currently recovering from chemotherapy that has left me very weak. I have hired him to clear cut a mile of trail in the woods on my property, using my powered brush hog. A lot of people would not be able to do this kind of work. Next month he is going to dig some post holes for me. I like having this big farm boy available to do things that I'm no longer able to do myself. I deliberately slightly overpay him to make sure he will do chores when I need help.

I like to hike that trail with my camera and take photos of wild life and such. Walking the shaded trail in the woods is a form of exercise that I enjoy doing.
It's no much that I'm being compassionate so much ... (show quote)

You sound like a great guy and I wish you the best in your recovery.
We all have some sort of self interest in what we do but we, at least I suppose most of us do have some compassion as well.
This brings up a story. i Hand and old car, being 14 years old needed to be replaced. I traded it in for a newer car and when my son-in-law heard about it he told me he would have given me the money for the car for his son. That seemed like a good idea to me and him but I relented because my thoughts were if they had a problem with the car I would have gotten the blame. It was old and just starting to have problems. There were a few problems mostly dents and dings but one never knows.

Reply
Aug 8, 2018 21:10:07   #
WillieC
 
My daughter uses her iPhone and puts it on messaging and Facebook and also does videos and they are all fine and free because she would have a phone anyway.

Reply
Aug 9, 2018 01:57:51   #
Bill P
 
I must say that for a young couple with a baby on the way, an iPhone isn't the best choice. That's a substantial investment that could better go to diapers.

Before retirement, I produced an employee/customer newsletter for a large heavy industrial contractor. I preferred to take my own photos, and was quite good at preparing them and placing them in an indesign document so that they would look as good coming off a four color press as a fine print on my Epson 3880.On occasion, a customer wouldn't let an outside photographer on premises, so project managers would shoot cell phone photos and send to me. Some of the last ones were on both an iPhone 5 and an iPhone 6. Neither looked all that good, but strangely the ones on the 5 were noticeably better to even the most untrained eye, clearer and with better color. A fingerprint on the lens? Just a crap camera? Only the Shadow knows.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 4
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.