Photoshop's Panorama program Versus MS's ICE
Dec 5, 2017 09:51:45 #
This pano is a composite of 6 images (24mm, f/11, SS 1/640, ISO 1000) I first tried to stitch them back when they were taken in 2014 but PS pano said the images weren't compatible. I set them aside and moved on. This morning I tried again using MS's ICE. It never batted an eye! So, just for grins I tried them again in PS and got the same result as 3 years ago.
Dec 5, 2017 09:58:52 #
Dec 5, 2017 10:01:07 #
Dec 5, 2017 10:04:18 #
Rich1939 wrote:
I have that with Lightroom Classic CC. LR does panos for me. I wonder if PS and LR are using the same "under the hood" pieces. That sounds like a fun homework project for today!CC 2018 Rel 19.0.
Dec 5, 2017 10:14:33 #
bsprague wrote:
I have that with Lightroom Classic CC. LR does panos for me. I wonder if PS and LR are using the same "under the hood" pieces. That sounds like a fun homework project for today!
More than likely I'll continue to use ACR's pano tool just because it is convenient. I open my raw files in ACR so ICE would be additional steps and, it doesn't export in dng. However, when things aren't working they way I expect ICE will be the next thing I try.
Dec 5, 2017 11:26:51 #
MichaelH
Loc: NorCal via Lansing, MI
bsprague wrote:
I have that with Lightroom Classic CC. LR does panos for me. I wonder if PS and LR are using the same "under the hood" pieces. That sounds like a fun homework project for today!
And if you are doing this test, I noticed that Lightroom and Photoshop gave different perspectives on the same group of images merged to Pano. I found that the Lightroom version seemed to have a "straighter" ground where the Photoshop stitching seemed to create a bowl effect. (I think if I remember correctly, Photoshop had some options that Lightroom did not and I may have made the wrong perspective choice in Photoshop.)
Happy testing
Dec 11, 2017 17:43:04 #
Rich that is a great pano of the trains. I have had the same problem as you about the files not matching. I will have to try some other software and see what happens. Thanks for the great photo and tip.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.