Although I'm a big fan of B&W, I really prefer the color shot of this scene. It captures the blue of the icebergs which I remember as one of the highlights of our Alaska trip. They get lost in the B&W. Great image! Mark
I really like both and am having a hard time choosing. I'll go with color and add that the "blue" is actually how it looks. And more so on cloudy days.
I've never understood that either/or mentality. Why not do both? I frequently offer my images in both BW and colour, and hand-colour some of the ones I shot in BW.