Railfan_Bill wrote:
I have been taking photographs of stars, nebula, galaxies, and of course, the Milky Way. My lens assortment starts with a Rokinon 14 mm f2.8 up to a Meade 1000 mm f10 mirror lens. My question is simple: can I find an adapter to fit my Canon lenses to astronomical eyepieces. Has anyone tried this? I remember a long time ago, there were adapters to fit telescope eyepieces to long prime lenses. Any suggestion for a source?
I am a regular contributor to the Astronomical Photography Forum, and the answer is that there is no way to use eyepieces with camera lenses because there is no way to add a diagonal and eyepiece and to get it to focus to infinity. This is due to the fact that the lens is designed to bring everything to focus at the distance of the camera sensor. This distance is too short to get the diagonal (for upright viewing) and the eyepiece since the point of focus will be farther out than the lens provides. It is as simple as this.
There are two exceptions:
1) Kenko sells a unit that the lens can attach to that has a diagonal and eyepiece. This is not a standard eyepiece. It is constructed with a built-in tele-converter such is used to provide things like 1.4x or 2.0x when inserted between lens and camera. Except this time, it is built into the eyepiece they provide. It does work, BUT, the optics are not steller. It is somewhat sharp in the center and blurry towards the edges. I bought it, but I am not satisfied with it, and it doesn't get used.
2) It is possible to use an old m42 lens with an adapter that provides a place to attach a 1 1/4" eyepiece. This is done without the diagonal and the results are of excellent quality. BUT, the image is upside down. It works if you are happy with an upside down image, and the image is way superior to the Kenko image, but it is upside down! Since we are talking about using this for terrestrial viewing, upside down is not very preferable. Image having binoculars that had fantastic optics, but everything was upside down. Would you want to use those binoculars?
As a test, I used both methods and looked at stars at night. The Kenko solution was so blurry that I didn't want to pursue it anylonger. The m42 lens solution, while upside down, was absolutely perfect from edge to edge, with no distortion and no blurriness at all.
The final answer is that to use the Canon lenses with eyepieces, it is just not possible to make it work.
And by the way, I did locate on eBay an eyepiece that is called an erecting eyepiece, meaning that it is doing internally what Kenko is doing. The result was as blurry as the Kenko solution. There is no other solution, or adapter that can make this happen. The camera lens focuses too close behind the lens to allow anything else to work. PERIOD.