Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
HDR Photography -- Before and After
Cool Street Artistry
Page <prev 2 of 2
Oct 22, 2016 00:49:56   #
MtnMan Loc: ID
 
big-guy wrote:
I don't get it. Assuming your final intent was just the rock face which has a very low dynamic range, so you ended up with an overexposed shot that would bring up the shadow detail under the car and an under exposed shot that would have given good detail in the sky and sunlit exposed rock/cement. Then you ran them all through the High Dynamic Range process which brought the sky, sunlit rock face and shadow detail under the car into a compressed exposure and then cropped all that HDR work out and were left with the base 0 ev exposure which you then ran through some basic PP. What was the point of HDR? Don't get me wrong, it's a wonderful photo I just don't understand all the wasted time and effort of running the HDR process and then eliminating it in the crop on this shot. Your other PP gets a big from me.
I don't get it. Assuming your final intent was jus... (show quote)


I too like the shot but could not see where HDR was helpful. The median image seems to have the necessary dynamic range for the portion used.

Composition could have left out the sky and shadow. Or cropping.

Reply
Oct 23, 2016 02:34:08   #
pixbyjnjphotos Loc: Apache Junction,AZ
 
jack schade wrote:
That would make a nice cover for a children's book on cats. Well done.

Jack


Thank you Jack for your viewing and comment. Have a GREAT DAY!

Reply
Oct 23, 2016 02:49:55   #
pixbyjnjphotos Loc: Apache Junction,AZ
 
big-guy wrote:
I don't get it. Assuming your final intent was just the rock face which has a very low dynamic range, so you ended up with an overexposed shot that would bring up the shadow detail under the car and an under exposed shot that would have given good detail in the sky and sunlit exposed rock/cement. Then you ran them all through the High Dynamic Range process which brought the sky, sunlit rock face and shadow detail under the car into a compressed exposure and then cropped all that HDR work out and were left with the base 0 ev exposure which you then ran through some basic PP. What was the point of HDR? Don't get me wrong, it's a wonderful photo I just don't understand all the wasted time and effort of running the HDR process and then eliminating it in the crop on this shot. Your other PP gets a big from me.
I don't get it. Assuming your final intent was jus... (show quote)


Your assumption is correct. The HDR yielded a more vibrant image with better clarity in about 15 minutes than I could achieve with other techniques. It is not quite true to color. I took a challenge from your post to use some other techniques on the median photo. Ended up using the NEF file and processed in Aftershot Pro passing the tif to Paintshop Pro X8 for a little final tweaking. The clarity is quite good and it is more true to color. However, I have over an hour of working the image to get it where it is. Here is the result.

Post processed from median RAW photo
Post processed from median RAW photo...
(Download)

Reply
 
 
Oct 23, 2016 02:56:13   #
pixbyjnjphotos Loc: Apache Junction,AZ
 
MtnMan wrote:
I too like the shot but could not see where HDR was helpful. The median image seems to have the necessary dynamic range for the portion used.

Composition could have left out the sky and shadow. Or cropping.


The HDR process quickly yielded a little more vibrant image with good clarity. It just isn't quite true to color, but, I kind of like it. You are quite right about a little better composition. I just like to leave some room around my main object. The 8x12 that comes out of the camera needs to be cropped anyway to yield an 8x10 or any other standard size. See the result of post processing the median photo in the above post. Thanks for viewing and your comments. Have a GREAT DAY!

Reply
Aug 25, 2021 18:17:30   #
joecichjr Loc: Chicago S. Suburbs, Illinois, USA
 
pixbyjnjphotos wrote:
Parked the car next to a stucco clad flower box on a side-walk. When exiting the car I noticed that some fairly well talented artist had painted three cats on one side of the flower box. It showed some weathering but was still in pretty good shape. This is a three-shot HDR. Nikon D7100, Nikon 18-140 telephoto lens, natural light. Three shots handheld bracketed at plus and minus 0.3 EV. Processed in HDR3 Projects and exported as 16 bit tif to Paintshop Pro X8. Tweaked very slightly for brightness and contrast. Cloned out unshaded area in lower left corner and removed small crack line above middle cat. Cropped and resized for posting.
Parked the car next to a stucco clad flower box on... (show quote)


Yes

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 2
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
HDR Photography -- Before and After
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.