Monument Valley, AZ
Sep 30, 2016 14:28:37 #
rdfarr
Loc: Floridian living in AL
Cwilson341 wrote:
Since you describe this as a photo, my preference is no. 3 which is a well executed photo. However, I actually like both one and two very much but they are more painterly.
Thanks for replying. All three were from the same original photo. With Photoshop, I just tried some different "looks" on #1 and #2, and did some adjusting of exposure, contrast, and sharpness on #3.
Sep 30, 2016 23:35:32 #
Oct 1, 2016 07:12:27 #
rdfarr
Loc: Floridian living in AL
warrior wrote:
# 3
Thanks. You're in agreement with most of the other commenters.
Oct 1, 2016 07:25:21 #
Numbers 1 and 2 nice, but my vote is number 3.
Oct 1, 2016 07:59:30 #
rdfarr wrote:
Three renditions of the same photo in Monument Valley.
Which do you prefer?
Which do you prefer?
Very nice I like #2 it looks like an oil painting.
Oct 1, 2016 08:04:03 #
I like both of your renditions in 1 and 2. But I think I like detail of the foreground and "monuments" a little better in 1, but in my opinion the sky is a little too much. I would, assuming I knew how, move a little more toward the sky in number 2, but that sky is a little too close the the original. Really like what you are trying to do with this image. Look forward to seeing other renditions if you choose to do so.
Oct 1, 2016 08:08:53 #
Oct 1, 2016 08:15:01 #
Oct 1, 2016 08:33:35 #
In order of my preferences - 3 (actual photo, minimal processing), 2 (nice watercolor effect), and 1 (the very visible brush strokes in the sky are off-putting for me.)
Oct 1, 2016 08:38:29 #
rdfarr wrote:
Three renditions of the same photo in Monument Valley.
Which do you prefer?
Which do you prefer?
Number 3 for me.
Oct 1, 2016 09:01:26 #
The third, then the first, last the second. I always prefer the natural look with these kinds of photos.
Oct 1, 2016 09:38:03 #
FrankR
Loc: NYC
Without a doubt, #3. A terrific shot and as fantastic a place as it is, show it as it is.
Oct 1, 2016 09:42:13 #
rdfarr wrote:
Three renditions of the same photo in Monument Valley.
Which do you prefer?
Which do you prefer?
Love the First Version !
Oct 1, 2016 09:48:42 #
Oct 1, 2016 10:03:56 #
rdfarr wrote:
Three renditions of the same photo in Monument Valley.
Which do you prefer?
Which do you prefer?
I like the third one!
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.