al davis wrote:
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came back from Japan. The reason I ask witch one is my boss and his son like to do the same thing. The difference is they do not take photos. His office could use lets just say some color.
There is a history with my boss and I and I wanted to do something nice for him. It is a family owned business and they have accepted me with open arms. They made me an offer I could not refuse.After 27 years with my previous employer I made this change. The reason for the explanation is my new boss was also employed there also. He left the company and started his own about ten years ago. It turned out to be a very successful business. It is just my way of saying thank you. So I ask my friends here on uhh witch one .
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came... (
show quote)
++++++++++++++++++++++++
Once looking at both images enlarged, #1 is the winner for me because the post processing in #2 did more harm than giving any improvements. #1 is your best option !
John N
Loc: HP14 3QF Stokenchurch, UK
[quote
Once looking at both images enlarged, #1 is the winner for me because the post processing in #2 did more harm than giving any improvements. #1 is your best option ![/quote]
Agree, whatever you've done in no.2 could be undone slightly to get the best of both shots. If it's beyond your abilities (I'm not saying it is) ask the guys in the Post processing section - they're the mutts nutts at this sort of stuff.
Number 2,more detail, well balanced.
Lighten the right side a bit on #1 and you're good.
Pete
al davis wrote:
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came back from Japan. The reason I ask witch one is my boss and his son like to do the same thing. The difference is they do not take photos. His office could use lets just say some color.
There is a history with my boss and I and I wanted to do something nice for him. It is a family owned business and they have accepted me with open arms. They made me an offer I could not refuse.After 27 years with my previous employer I made this change. The reason for the explanation is my new boss was also employed there also. He left the company and started his own about ten years ago. It turned out to be a very successful business. It is just my way of saying thank you. So I ask my friends here on uhh witch one .
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came... (
show quote)
Choice two is a little better balanced, with shadow detail brought out, IMHO.
Thank you all for your help and opinions. This is why I love this site I get honest feedback from people who enjoy the same hobby and strive for perfection. Thanks to all again.
Now it really depends on where the light ( window ) comes from in the room that the print is intended to be hung. 2 would be fine on the opposite wall to the light. 1 would be great to the adjacent of the window, giving the shadow side more meaning.
al davis wrote:
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came back from Japan. The reason I ask witch one is my boss and his son like to do the same thing. The difference is they do not take photos. His office could use lets just say some color.
There is a history with my boss and I and I wanted to do something nice for him. It is a family owned business and they have accepted me with open arms. They made me an offer I could not refuse.After 27 years with my previous employer I made this change. The reason for the explanation is my new boss was also employed there also. He left the company and started his own about ten years ago. It turned out to be a very successful business. It is just my way of saying thank you. So I ask my friends here on uhh witch one .
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came... (
show quote)
The one that flies on a broom!
I like the first one, it focuses on the fall.
Bill_de wrote:
I like the one in the middle. Lighten the right side like in the second one, but leave the rest, including the water, as in the first.
--
And we have a winner. The original choice between two incorrect exposures was no choice at all.
I like them both. Number 2 shows what can be done when you step outside the box with a little more artistic expression....Rich
I like the 2nd one, it is much crisper and has more clarity.
al davis wrote:
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came back from Japan. The reason I ask witch one is my boss and his son like to do the same thing. The difference is they do not take photos. His office could use lets just say some color.
There is a history with my boss and I and I wanted to do something nice for him. It is a family owned business and they have accepted me with open arms. They made me an offer I could not refuse.After 27 years with my previous employer I made this change. The reason for the explanation is my new boss was also employed there also. He left the company and started his own about ten years ago. It turned out to be a very successful business. It is just my way of saying thank you. So I ask my friends here on uhh witch one .
I hiked to this waterfall with my son when he came... (
show quote)
Second, because it has more color in the water and the foliage surrounding the waterfall. >Alan
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.