JohnFrim wrote:
Hi SS,
I don't do model photography, so I have great envy and respect for those who do this successfully. Thus, my comment is simply the opinion of an observer and admirer of the art.
The only balance point that I have issue with is that the model is, in fact, balanced on some sort of stand. Overall I want the image to evoke peace, calm and serenity, but the model's pose can only be achieved via tension in the abdomen and neck, and that creates tension in me as an observer. If her legs and head could have been resting on some sort of support it would put me at ease. I would not want to see another element added to the photo, so maybe the support(s) could have been put under the sheet. Another way of phrasing my concern is that instead of feeling I could admire this woman in this repose for hours, I have this sense that she is saying, "Hurry up, take the shot, I can't hold this pose forever!!!"
Hi SS, br br I don't do model photography, so I h... (
show quote)
John, thanks so much for your observations and comments.
In answer to your observations I'd like to say that shooting Models for me is a lot like watching ballet. I shoot professional ballet on occasion and I see strong ties. And indeed, some Models are ballerinas and professional ballerinas as well.
Any given pose may be very difficult but the job of the Model is to make it look absolutely effortless. Like a male ballet dancer lifting a ballerina. It may be an extremely difficult lift but the lifter not only does the entire lift in slow motion, he picks her up and sets her down in slow motion and doesn't make even a sound, appearing extremely graceful and effortless. You don't see the flex in the bodies to not draw attention to the effect, but only the grace.
In this case my Model is well supported, and we do discuss the pose and the effect involved and the hold time before its shot. And of course there might be multiple takes as well.
The effortlessness of the pose and skill of the Model is what makes it Art!
It's easy to read into a shot a lot more than there is, especially if we study a pose using our own limitations.
Many of these Models are workout animals, not to mention diets. It's what enables a Model to make it look efferetless without straining. Because for them it IS efferetless.
I personally would not perceive any tension unless I was trying to create tension at which point tension would be a deliberate part of my shot. Of course we all perceive any given shot differently.
I have this same themed shot with this same Model in a verity of poses. This is probably my favorite because I view it as the most graceful.
Maybe Bret or others that shot Models can weigh in with their own philosophies about their experiences posing Models!! All Models have limitations based on their individual skills and training.
Thanks John, keep participating and replying so we can get this section of the ground!!! I'm always interested in any and all feedback, as it's all important and constructive since it all comes from someone else's personal way of seeing what we post. Thanks
SS